can be expressed in the following form. ceteris paribus, i.e., under the same climatic, geographical, historical, social, etc., conditions, at the same level of personal development, with one and the same personal biography, in a word, with the absolute equality of all other conditions—two people, who are not identical in a physiological respect, will give a non-identical psychic reaction to a completely identical stimulus. Physical differences are always accompanied (how and why, this is for now a secret of nature) by psychic differences. Now take two people belonging to different ethnic groups—two individuals with a different racial recipe. It is clear that under equal conditions they will react non-identically psychically. Of course, there is nothing more difficult than to “describe” the psyche of each tribe, to give its exhaustive formula; all attempts of this kind have proven unsuccessful. But in general, not everything that exists, and in whose existence we have no power to doubt, is amenable to precise definition. It is impossible to “describe” the racial psyche, but it is nonetheless certain that each “racial” (in the above-mentioned sense) group possesses a special, peculiar “racial” psyche, which manifests itself to one degree or another—despite all the diversity of individual human personalities—in each individual of that group (except, of course, for intermediate types).
Marxists recognize the significance of the fundamental historical factor only in economic moments, or, to put it somewhat more concretely, in the state and development of productive forces at each given moment. Let us not now discuss whether this is true or not; let us assume that it is true. Let us assume that at the very foundation of the historical process lie the moments of production. But production, after all, depends on the natural conditions of climate, the structure of the surface, etc.; this was recognized in their time even by the creators of the theory. The aggregate of these conditions influences the productive activity of man in one direction or another, compels him to choose certain paths of the most—
169