Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
150printed page
scan 202 of 568

150 of determining whether this racial identity has a deeper meaning.

In the view that the history of the West Asian-European cultural sphere is best understood through a precise knowledge of the nature of the Aryans and the Semites, people have always toiled with a characterization of these two "races."

Renan introduced one of his major works, "Histoire générale et système comparé des langues Sémitiques," with a depiction of the Semitic peoples. His characterization of the Semites was almost universally recognized as the only correct one, so that one need only look into any book in which Semites are mentioned to find Renan's words repeated ad nauseam.

The Semitic race, he says, is a "race inférieure" [inferior race], which stands far behind the Aryan race. He further attributes to the Semites an "absence de complexité des nuances" [absence of complexity of nuances], then a "sentiment exclusif de l’unité" [exclusive feeling of unity]. The Semites, he claims, are incapable of grasping diversity, multiplicity, and therefore arrived at monotheism instinctively. They also produced no mythology, no philosophy, and no science. Polytheism and philosophy, he opines, are the outflow of that ability to grasp multiplicity; in the childhood of humanity this ability produced polytheism, in the age of maturity, philosophy. The Semites lacked imagination, therefore they have no epics, no drama, and their poetry is therefore subjective.

The Semites are characterized by "simplicité" [simplicity], the inability to form something great and whole. Therefore, they never conducted large-scale trade, were unable to form large organized states, and produced no aristocracy, no feudal system, no military organization.

He denies the Semites any spiritualism. Religious intolerance, supposedly unknown to the Aryans, is exclusively a product of the Semitic spirit, for which humanity, of course, owes it no thanks. Lax morals and stark egoism, in that the Semite, as Renan claims, knows only duties to himself, are also, according to him, main