Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
152printed page
scan 204 of 568

152 are completely identical. Nevertheless, Renan contrasts a supposed Semitic racial disposition with the racial disposition, the genius, of the Indo-Germans. And just as his circumstantial evidence has been rightly attacked in its details and has become completely untenable, especially through the excavations of recent years (as early as 25 years ago, Hommel reported that Renan himself had declared that his book was half antiquated by the results of Assyriology!), so his hypothesis collapses into nothing through the demonstration that the relationships between the individual races are completely different from what was thought back in 1862.

The only opponents Renan found at the time were those who had dedicated themselves exclusively to the study of the Semitic languages and literatures and the history of the Semitic peoples. This relatively small group, whose voice however matters a great deal here, spoke out decisively against Renan from the very beginning.*

Chamberlain examines the foundations of the 19th century. An important factor in the intellectual life of this century is Jewry. Not only through the religions that originated from its bosom, but also through the active participation of the Jews themselves, through their role in modern practical and intellectual life. If we wish to correctly recognize the role that belongs to Jewry among the foundations of the 19th century, we must first understand Jewry itself precisely. If Chamberlain were to pass judgment on it, it would be that of the racial inferiority of the Jews. This unfavorable assessment, he claims, is not merely a matter of personal feeling; rather, it has the same certainty as any other fact of natural science. And Chamberlain also dedicates a separate, large section of his book to providing the historical and scientific-natural proof.

He first establishes that the Jews owe their origin to the crossing of three completely heterogeneous races:

  • See Chwolson (Attempt at a Characterization of the Semitic Peoples), Hommel, et al.