204 One thing emerges from all of this with all desirable clarity: that specific racial energies, instinctive fundamental racial forces—in the sense that a people's talent could for all time only express itself in one quite specific, that is, the specific way—hardly exist.*
Renan, however, and his successors assert—for achieve- ments in the field of pure thought as well as in that of material culture—the exclusive decisive role of instincts.
Monotheism, according to Renan, was found through “instinct.” He denies the Semites a “racial instinct” for the creation of polytheism and mythology in the childhood of humanity and for the creation of a philoso- phy in the age of maturity. He asserts the lack of “racial instincts” for the creation of epics and dramas; for the ability to conduct large-scale trade; for the ability to form great and whole things, in general: he asserts the lack
- Of course, it cannot be disputed that in any given era, a psychological peculiarity probably exists for every race. The psychological peculiarity of the Jews is evidently different from that of the English, that of the Italians different from that of the Russians. Different, usually, is the way of perceiving and feeling, and consequent- ly the way in which these feelings are expressed. Thus, in the field of folk customs, literature, music, and the like, different and also qualitatively unique creations could then come about in different races. But these peculiarities—for which, by the way, there is no standard of comparison—are completely irrelevant as soon as we speak of the capacity for scientific achievements. One can claim that there is a national music, but there is no national chemistry, no national mathe- matics, and no national steam engines.
But even the type of this purely psychological peculiarity itself is variable, because the racial instincts that arose through external influences can be modified again by external influences—admittedly, as a rule, not in one and the same individual, nor in a few successive generations, but certainly in the course of longer historical periods.
Therefore, the following can be said with certainty: Different qualities of talent that are permanently constant and purely endogenous do not exist—and least of all for scientific achievements and for achievements of any kind in the field of material culture.