Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
247printed page
scan 299 of 568

247 Hunters often lure game with imitated calls. If these are not imitated perfectly, the game remains undecided or does not react. The fact that older animals, which have experience, thus possess more engrams,* are much harder to lure than young, inexperienced ones, is proof of homophony. Semon demonstrates hereditary homophony with examples of nest building in birds, which only use an artificial nest if it is adapted to their instinct in form, size, and composition. If one takes their nest away, so they build it again; if, conversely, one presents them with a finished nest, they use it, depending, with the instinctive modifications of their species. In a word, as long as the new original complex "nest" shows an incongruity with the hereditary mneme, it is trimmed until the incongruities are eliminated. If one objects that with such a hereditary mneme the animal has no prior consciousness of what is to be done, Semon replies that this is also the case with humans. The entire process is independent of consciousness. This is also true for humans. We can, for example, be working with intense consciousness and not hear a piece of music being played correctly next to us. As soon as an incongruity, a mistake, occurs in the piece that disturbs our homophonic mneme, we suddenly hear it (transition of the subconscious content to the content of the upper consciousness). Cases of mnemonic homophony, without one or the other of the two excitations — mnemonic or original — reaching the upper consciousness, are commonplace in humans. This is the case with all frequently repeated actions (a frequently traveled path, etc.). Any incongruity, however, requires (especially in order to be eliminated) a new contribution from the upper consciousness. Instinctive homophony is thus just as frequent as that of the upper consciousness, and the criterion can be the same for man and animal.

The idea of grouping all those phenomena in the world of the organic, which involve reproductions of any kind, under a unified point of view...

  • Corresponding original engrams have been added to the hereditary engrams.