45
…can be held responsible for it. Not the caprice of men, but the power of circumstances, has dissolved orthodox Judaism. — With what congregation, you ask, with what synagogue, is one to join oneself and one's family to-day? — Or are we perhaps, you exclaim maliciously, to reproach our cultivated Jewish teachers for having brought us the light of science in place of the hard shell of Rabbinism, "broken through from without"?!
No, dear friend, we will hold no one responsible for a crisis which, though dangerous, is in the end salutary, because necessary; a crisis which it lay in no man's power to avert, and whose worst symptoms, moreover, are already past and will hardly recur. — Judaism, which at its first contact with modern culture threatened to dissolve, Judaism — we may say it to-day without fear of being given the lie by history — has happily survived this last danger also, perhaps the greatest that ever threatened its existence! — Neither from the side of science nor from the side of life do adversaries arise against it to-day, but at most from the side of those who present themselves as their representatives and mediators without being called thereto.
Far be it from me, moreover, to underrate the untiring labours of those Jewish scholars and teachers to whom our present Jewish generation owes everything, culture and prosperity, its social position and its moral and intellectual progress, and to whom alone it is to be ascribed that, in the midst of the dissolution of all social bonds, the Jewish family still stands as a model. — Those scholars and teachers are rather the worthy successors of our old Rabbis, who, during an exile of two thousand years, the pillars of