Moses Hess · Rome and Jerusalem · 1862
50printed page
scan 70 of 264

50

…disowned, and is at last reproduced as the ripe fruit of the tree of life.

The great thinkers and noble characters have, moreover, never mistaken this essence of the Jewish religion of history; they did not see in every modification of the view of life a new religion, and did not imagine that they could reform the historical basis of our cultus. — Sadier and Maimuni, Spinoza and Mendelssohn, in spite of their advanced intellectual development, did not become apostates, although there was no lack of dogmatic judges of heresy who wished to cast them out, or actually had cast them out. — Our modern rationalistic dogmatists, too, would long since have removed from the synagogue as heretics those Jews who have declared themselves for Spinoza, if they had still possessed the power to blow the horn which once produced in Israel quite another effect than the alarm-trumpet of a Frankfort rabbi in a Frankfort Jewish-theological journal. —

Unsatisfied by the Reform, and repelled by the heresy-hunters on the orthodox and the heterodox side alike, you ask to which religious community one should still attach oneself with one's family within Judaism to-day? — I know only One Jewish community, the ancient synagogue, which happily still exists, and will, I hope, continue to exist until the national rebirth of Judaism is accomplished. — I myself, if I had a family, would, in spite of my dogmatic heterodoxy, not only attach myself in public life to a pious Jewish congregation, but would also keep all the days of mourning and festival in my house according to the precepts, in order to keep alive in myself and in my descendants the traditions of the Jewish people. Without doubt, if I had any influence upon the synagogue, I should, towards the embellishment of the Jewish