Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion · 1862
10scan
of 43

Seeking Zion

…and Nahmanides and Radak mentioned above. And so Nahmanides further wrote on the words of Isaiah, peace be upon him, who said: "Says Yahweh God, who gathers the outcasts of Israel: I will yet gather others to him, to those already gathered to him"; and he explained that at first He will gather many of the outcasts of Israel, but not all of them, and after the war of Gog He said "I will yet gather others to him, to those gathered to him", that is, they will be gathered a second time to join those who were gathered long before. And so it seems to me to be made plain from the mouth of Yahweh in our holy Torah: "Then Yahweh thy God will restore thy captivity and have compassion upon thee, and will return and gather thee from all the peoples whither Yahweh thy God hath scattered thee." He said "will return" twice: for at first "He will restore thy captivity", only a part of them, "and have compassion upon thee" on this account, because thy iniquity will be pardoned through the sweet savour of thy sacrifices; and then "He will return and gather thee from all the peoples" a second time, a great ingathering of them all, and then He will bring them on swift beasts, "and kings shall be their foster-fathers". It also seems clear to me that it was concerning the beginning of the redemption that some of our Rabbis of blessed memory said, "There is no difference between this world and the days of the Messiah save subjection to the kingdoms alone"; and it is in Sanhedrin 99. And these days, in particular the coming of Gog, are called the days of the Messiah, for these days will work and bring it about that the Messiah, revealed and hidden, of the Jerusalem Talmud mentioned above, will come. But when the complete redemption comes after the war of Gog, then the works of Yahweh will be wondrous: new heavens and a new earth, and "the covenant with death shall be annulled", "He will swallow up death for ever". And it was not of those days, God forbid, that they said "There is no difference between this world" etc., but only of the time before Gog; and this is clear. And something like this the Kotev wrote in the Preface in the Ein Yaakov, on the saying of Rabbi Hillel, "Israel has no Messiah", explaining his words: that Yahweh, blessed be He, will put it into the heart of the kings to recognise the truth, and then the prophecy of Zephaniah will be fulfilled, "I will turn a pure language"; see there.

  1. Isaiah the prophet, peace be upon him, further taught the people knowledge in accordance with our way, in saying: "Those that come, Jacob shall take root; Israel shall blossom and bud, and they shall fill the face of the world with produce" etc., "And it shall come to pass in that day" etc. (Isaiah 27), "and you shall be gathered up one by one, O children of Israel", "and it shall come to pass in that day that a great trumpet shall be blown" etc. Here he made known that all Israel will not come at one time, but "you shall be gathered up one by one"; and like one who beats out the ears of corn, little by little he will bring in his grain. And he said "those that come ... shall take root": those who come first, at the beginning of the redemption, Jacob will take root like the root of seed in the earth, to bring forth abundant growth; and afterwards Israel shall blossom and bud on holy soil, for the root will put forth a flower; they will multiply and grow until "they fill the face of the world with produce", for they will go on growing ever greater until the world and its fulness has yielded its fruit, for all the nations too will come to Zion. And concerning the end of the redemption he said: "a great trumpet shall be blown, and those who were lost in the land of Assyria shall come" etc. And so he said further (Isaiah 11): "And it shall come to pass in that day that Yahweh shall set His hand again a second time to acquire the remnant of His people that shall remain from Assyria" etc. Behold, you see that there will be a first ingathering and a second ingathering, "and he shall strike his roots" in the first, for those of the sons of Jacob who come of themselves will take root in the land of Goshen, and afterwards Israel shall blossom and bud in the whole country.

And in the Talmud we find, in Sanhedrin 97, that Rabbi Akiva held of Ben Kahiva, who reigned in Betar, that he would shine forth as the Messiah; and he expounded what Haggai said, "Yet a little while, and I will shake the heavens and the earth"; that is to say, before the completeness of the redemption comes there will be one small kingdom, and that is Ben Kahiva, and afterwards "I will shake the heavens and the earth". And far be it that the Tanna Rabbi Akiva erred in the true meaning of the verse; rather, it is clear that this is the meaning of the verse: that at the beginning of the redemption there will be a small sprouting of salvation, in that they will be gathered one by one from the exile to make a settled land, and afterwards they will offer up a sweet savour and it will be accepted for them, and afterwards "I will shake the heavens and the earth". Only in this did Rabbi Akiva err, that he thought Ben Kahiva was the small kingdom, and it was not so, for "the vision was yet for an appointed time"; and so it will be in the last generation, whose spirit will be exalted for this. Would that we might be "the generation of them that seek Him".

Further, in Isaiah 55: "And I will bring them to My holy mountain, and make them joyful in My house of prayer; their burnt-offerings and their sacrifices shall be accepted upon My altar; for My house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples. Says Yahweh, who gathers" etc. Each time he spoke of the two kinds, the beginning of the redemption and the consummation of the redemption. "And I will bring them to My holy mountain" is the beginning of the redemption, when there will be only an ingathering to the holy mountain and not the Temple; and afterwards "and make them joyful in My house of prayer", for many of the righteous of the world, who assemble and are gathered there, will pray there; as we shall explain further from a Midrash. And he said "their burnt-offerings and their sacrifices upon My altar": that at the beginning of the redemption there will be only a built altar and not the Temple; and afterwards "My house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples". Afterwards he said, in accordance with the words of Nahmanides