The Words of Lurie 20
…proofs, many of them, for this; and Rabbi Joseph made known to him the essence of his intention; and so Tosafot explained at the end of their words, like Rashi's explanation. If so, it is proven that Rabbi Joseph too did not hold so in the conclusion. And now there remains no question or difficulty at all against our words.
Here ends the Essay on Holy Things.
Anyone who has an objection to make against my way in this holy matter, let him please inform me, and I am ready to answer those who question me, with the help of God, blessed be His name.
And these are the words of one who seeks the good of his people in the Land of Israel and pursues the love of Jerusalem, a shoot come forth from the stock of the holy Ari of blessed memory: he is Doctor H. Lurie in Frankfurt-on-the-Oder. The Holy One, blessed be He, who confirms the word of His servant and fulfils the counsel of His messengers, has promised us: And it shall be, before they call I will answer; they are still speaking, and I will hear.
Trusting in the merit of the fathers, I founded in the city of Frankfurt-on-the-Oder the Society for the Settlement of the Land of Israel, before I knew anything of the aim of the Rabbi, the Gaon, the author of the book Seeking Zion; and I rejoiced greatly to see from his book and from his speech that he agrees with all his heart to the society mentioned above, and that three of the great men of the generation agree with his words. And although it was in my mind at first to print a book on the matter of the Society for the Settlement of the Land of Israel, I said in my heart: Beware of making many books; and it is not for me to speak before one who is greater than I in wisdom and in number; but two are better than one. Therefore I will set out for you, pleasant reader, how very closely the words of the Rabbi, the author, accord with the words of the Men of the Great Assembly in the prayer of the New Year: And so, Yahweh, give honour to Thy people: first, equality of rights among the peoples (emancipation); praise to those who fear Thee (they will be held in honour if they are faithful); and hope to those who seek Thee (to those who seek the peace of Zion); and afterwards, joy to Thy Land (and He will make her wilderness like Eden and her desert like the garden of Yahweh); and gladness to Thy city (those who study Torah in Jerusalem shall eat and be satisfied); and afterwards complete redemption, speedily in our days. And so said Rabbi Samuel bar Nahmani: It is a tradition of the Aggadah that Jerusalem will not be built until the exiles are gathered in. And if you say in your heart: If Yahweh does not build a house, its builders have laboured on it in vain, it is not out of wisdom that you ask concerning this; for where, then, have you seen that they should cease to build the House because the Holy One, blessed be He, does not build it in His glory and in His own person? So did your fathers in the days of the prophet Haggai, when they said: The time has not come for the house of Yahweh to be built. What did the prophet Haggai answer them? Is it a time for you to dwell in your panelled houses, while this House lies waste? And now, thus says Yahweh of hosts: Set your heart upon your ways, etc. And Haggai, the messenger of Yahweh, spoke with the message of Yahweh to the people, saying: I am with you, says Yahweh. And Yahweh stirred up the spirit of Zerubbabel, etc. 1). And in like manner, my friend the reader, answer him who comes to trouble your mind and raises an objection from the words of the holy Zohar, portion Vayikra: The virgin of Israel is fallen, she shall rise no more. You know already that David went back and upheld them by the holy spirit, as it is written: Yahweh upholds all who fall, etc. (Berakhot 4). Indeed, the answer to the words of the holy Zohar you will find in the book of a preacher of our time, in what the Zohar said on the verse mentioned above: "And I will not again raise her up" is not written; a parable of a queen, etc. And the book mentioned above raises the difficulty: how is it possible that the words of the holy Zohar should oppose a number of verses of consolation, and the return of Israel, as it is written: Return to Me, and I will return to you, and many like it? And he resolved it: that Israel will not rise again by bodily strength and by force, that they will not go up as a wall, but their raising up will come through the awakening of their strength and their soul to favour her dust and to cherish her stones 2). Therefore awake, you generous ones, and take heart; seek righteousness
- His words are right, but I have yet another answer in my mouth: that in truth it is known that the Sanctuary of Yahweh, which His hands, blessed be He, have established, will come; but that will be at the latter end of the End of the right hand, which is the fourth End. But at the beginning of the salvation, which is the third End (as is explained in the Midrash cited in the first Essay of this work), we shall merit only that a new altar be established in Zion, as is proven from the Jerusalem Talmud. And it is also proven that it is called a Sanctuary, as is explained above (Essay on Holy Things, section 9). And by this it is understood that there is a difference between the End of the right hand and the End of days: the right hand is the fourth End. And see in the Midrash, 5, Emor, chapter 30, cited there.
- Besides his precious and true words, I wonder how it could enter the mind to overturn a building built upon the Jerusalem Talmud and the Midrashim and the Scriptures for the sake of a slight inference from the Zohar; but that even this verse which the holy Zohar brought