Part Two
Of this the essay shall be called
Essay on Holy Things
- And now it falls upon me to set before the eyes of the understanding Creator the Torah dialectics which I was privileged to debate while I was still young in years with my lord, my teacher and master, the great and holy Gaon, pious and humble, the master of Israel, our teacher Rabbi Akiva Eger, of saintly and blessed memory. Here is a copy of his holy words, letter for letter, in which at first he answered against my words; but Yahweh, blessed be His name, was my help to answer the lion while he was still alive, until in the end he agreed with my words, and he also asked his son-in-law, the pious Gaon our teacher Rabbi Moses Sofer, to give his opinion on this as well, and he too agreed to permit it, as we shall copy it all, with Yahweh's help, here:
Copy of the words of the holy one of Israel, our teacher Rabbi Akiva Eger mentioned above, of blessed memory.
Great and abundant peace to the honour of my master, dear to me as my own soul, the Rabbi etc., our teacher Rabbi Hirsch, may his light shine. The letter of your holy honour reached me during the intermediate days of the past festival, through our friend, your brother-in-law, the Rabbi etc., our teacher Rabbi Henekh Segal, may his light shine. As to the substance of the matter, I do not agree. For even before our hand reaches to judging the place of the altar and the measurements of the altar itself by handbreadths of four of our medium thumbs, which is very difficult, since to enlarge them by generous measures, by "laughing cubits", is impossible, for "all this is in writing from the hand of Yahweh, He made me understand", there stands before us a hard mountain in the matter of the priesthood. For in the Responsa of Rashdam, Even ha-Ezer, section 235, after he discussed at length whether a captive woman, on the evidence of a witness from the mouth of a witness, is permitted to a priest, he concluded: And if one relies on what Rivash wrote in his Responsa, section 92 (in the case of a captive woman and a priest), and this is his language: "All the more so the priests of our generation, who have no written record of lineage, but only for the sake of good order it has become the custom today to read first in the Torah as a priest." Thus the priests of the present time who go up first, it is nothing but a mere custom, since they have no book of lineage; learn from this that they are not complete and certain priests but doubtful ones. And if so, since the prohibition of a captive woman is only a rabbinic prohibition, it is enough for us to be stringent in what is certainly forbidden; but in a matter of doubt it is proper to say that a rabbinic doubt is resolved leniently. And further, it is a double doubt: perhaps she was defiled, perhaps he is not a priest. End of his words. And in my humble and feeble opinion, this is correct, to derive from the words of Rivash that they are priests in doubt; but as to what Rashdam wrote, that being called to the Torah first is nothing but a custom