Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion and First to Zion · 1866
70scan
of 88

Essay on Holy Things

…at all. 3) On the matter of the presumptive status of the priests, a long dialectic: that according to Maimonides, even without a flaw, we take the concern into account with regard to heave-offering, for only Rashi and Rabbenu Tam hold that only where there is a flaw, as in the case of Ezra, do we take it into account. Nevertheless, as to the law, the Gaon, may his light shine, agreed with me and brought support for my way, and this is his language: "But for all that, the words of his honour, may his light shine, are not to be set aside. For the Beit Yosef, in section 2 of Even ha-Ezer, asked why Rif and Rosh did not bring the whole Mishnah and the passage of Kiddushin 76, and also in Ketubot 24 and 28 they did not bring it; and he answered that they hold that the whole passage follows Rabbi Meir, who requires investigation, but according to the Rabbis, who dispute Rabbi Meir, all the priests and the women are in the presumption of fitness and need no investigation at all; and if there are objectors, some slight investigation is needed, and this is understood of itself and need not be spelled out in the halakhah. So the Rabbi, the Beit Yosef, answered. But still, if these hold like Maimonides that with heave-offering of Torah law we take the concern into account even in our day, they ought to have brought this law, etc. It must therefore be that Rif holds that in this too no investigation is needed, etc. And if so, we certainly hold like Rif and Rosh (and Rashi and Rabbenu Tam); and the Tur too disputed Maimonides in section 2, and the Ran too wrote like Rabbenu Tam in Ketubot 24, etc.; and Maimonides is alone in this. And it is possible that even for Maimonides, who took the concern, it is not a reasoning of Torah law, but Ezra was stringent in the matter because he had many priests, which is not so when we judge concerning all the priests; and in the manner of what his honour wrote, that one does not set aside a great commandment for the sake of a concern." Thus far the language of our teacher Rabbi Eliyahu, may his light shine. And I replied to him that I need not go on at length any more, since in his dialectic he concluded by agreeing with me as to the law. But in my opinion Maimonides too concedes; for it is known that lineage is more stringent than heave-offering, and if in matters of lineage he wrote that a flaw is required, all the more so with heave-offering. It must therefore be said that Maimonides, in the case of heave-offering, speaks of a time when there was a flaw, or of where there is a flaw in the present time, or that he was stringent where there was no need of a commandment; and so his honour also agreed with me. And one may further say that Rabbi Meir follows his own method, that he takes the minority into account and requires investigation, and the Rabbis follow their own method, that they do not take the minority into account and do not require investigation; and we hold like the Rabbis, as the Rabbi, the Beit Yosef, wrote. And as for Maimonides, one may say that he holds that wherever an easy investigation is possible, it counts as a case where "it is possible to clarify", and one does not rely on the majority; and consequently, where investigation is not easily possible, Maimonides concedes to Rif and Rosh and Rashi and Rabbenu Tam and the Ran, and there is nothing more to it.

  1. On knowing the place of the altar by means of the Western Wall, the Rabbi, may his light shine, raised a difficulty from Zevahim 62, where we say: "Granted the House, its form was recognisable" (Rashi explains: the foundations of the walls), "but the altar, how did they know it?" And it answers that they had a prophet. Evidently they knew the foundations of the Court, and even so they needed a prophet. And I replied to him that this difficulty does not touch me, for on the Talmud itself it is difficult: why did they need a prophet, when they could have measured? But in truth it is no difficulty, for Rashi explained there, on the passage beginning "One testified to them concerning the altar": "that it has room to be enlarged up to sixty", end of his language. And if so, what did knowing the measure help them? For they needed to add to the first altar, and they did not know at which place the holiness of the addition up to sixty would begin; and for this they needed a prophet. And so it is in Maimonides' Commentary on the Mishnah, chapter 2 of Middot. Further, since they did not find the foundation of the altar, and the Court was large, they could not know which place in the Court was fit for the altar; which is not so for us, since tractate Middot has taught us all the measurements to the north and to the south. And I found further support in Midrash Rabbah on the Song of Songs, on the verse "My beloved is like a gazelle; behold, he stands behind our wall": "Behind the Western Wall of the Temple, for the Holy One, blessed be He, swore to it that it would never be destroyed; and the Priest's Gate and the Huldah Gate were never destroyed", end of its language. If so, there would be a great sign from the wall and from the gates. And the Rabbi, may his light shine, devised a further stratagem by means of the Foundation Stone, and there is no need to dwell on it. The Gaon, may his light shine, also brought support from Midrash Rabbah, section 64, that in the days of Rabbi Joshua ben Hananiah permission arrived from the king to build the Temple, and they accepted it and wished to build it; and afterwards the enemies informed against them and the king annulled it. And behold, then too there were no prophets, and without doubt there was a possibility of finding the place of the altar, as above.

  2. Further the Rabbi, may his light shine, brought an astute observation, from what we hold according to Maimonides, chapter 5 of the Laws of the Vessels of the Sanctuary