Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion and First to Zion · 1866
77scan
of 88

40 First to Zion

…"and nation shall not lift up sword against nation"? And further: would Samuel, Heaven forbid, dispute the future building upon which a Sanctuary of fire will come, when there is no change from the law of nature greater than this? From all this it is proven that the days of the Messiah are before the coming of the son of David, and then the world follows its customary course, and there will still be sword and spear for the war of Gog; and after the coming of the son of David, then Samuel agrees that there will be no more sword from nation to nation, and there will be a new light, sevenfold that of the days of creation, and then the Sanctuary of fire will come. And in this Samuel will certainly not dispute, that when the subjugation to the kingdoms ceases there will certainly be the great obligation to engage in the service of the altar without a Sanctuary of fire. For is it for this that He will redeem us from the subjugation, that we should, Heaven forbid, transgress the commandment of the Torah to offer the daily offering and the other communal sacrifices? And would any commandment of the Torah be changed, God forbid? Surely it is great heresy and unbelief for anyone to say so —. And indeed we say in Ta'anit 17 that the Rabbis hold that even at the present time priests are forbidden to drink wine, lest the Sanctuary be speedily built, and we require a priest fit for the Service. And if we say that the Sanctuary will be built only after the Messiah, will not Elijah come a day before, and a whole day is enough for his wine to wear off? Rather, certainly, speedily in our time, when there is permission, it will be built at once, and it will not be permitted to wait even one hour until his wine has passed off, but the obligation is immediate. And as it appears from the spirit of the vision, the altar or the Sanctuary will be built before Gog; and Gog will come and cause sacrifice and meal-offering to cease, and afterwards the son of David will come and restore the holy place below, and the Sanctuary will appear from above; and so it is (in Daniel 9:26): "And for half of the week he shall cause sacrifice and meal-offering to cease", from which it follows that there was sacrifice and meal-offering before Gog and before Messiah son of David; and this is clear.

  1. Further, the Rabbi our teacher Rabbi Hayyim Mordekhai mentioned above and the Rabbi our teacher Rabbi David Ziskind mentioned above objected to my way from what we say in Zevahim 29: all holy things that were slaughtered before the opening of the Sanctuary are unfit. And he also objected to that which Rabbi Yohanan holds, that one who slaughters outside at the present time is liable, because it was sanctified for the time to come: but there are no doors! And it is an argument from the lesser to the greater: if at a time when there are doors, which are fit for mixing and fit for opening, it is unfit, how much the more when there are no doors. And I replied: for Tosafot in Yoma 63 raised an objection similar to this from an altar that was damaged, and did not object against Rabbi Yohanan from the opening of the Sanctuary; but Rashba raised this objection from the entrance of the Sanctuary, and answered that where there is no entrance and no door we have no difficulty with it. And I explained his answer: that if there is a Sanctuary and an entrance, then it is closed before the Shekhinah and is not called "before Yahweh", and therefore they are unfit; but where there is no House at all, the Shekhinah has not moved from the place of the Ark, and behold it is open and not closed, and it is "before Yahweh". And therefore Tosafot did not object from this, nor against "they offer although there is no House", and their difficulty is well resolved.

  2. The Gaon of Altona mentioned above objected to my way from the order of the prayer (Megillah 17): "And once Jerusalem is built, David comes, etc., and once David comes, prayer comes, as it is said, 'And I will bring them', etc.; and once prayer comes, the Service comes, as it is said, 'Their burnt-offerings and their sacrifices', etc." Here this verse is said after the coming of the Messiah, and this is a proof that there is no acceptable sacrifice until the Temple is built through the coming of Messiah son of David; end of his words. And I replied to him (besides what I brought above, section 4, clear proofs that it is always acceptable, if we have the ability and the permission to perform the Service): behold, I have already brought proofs from the Midrash and from the Zohar that several redemptions will take place in the future, as is written in the portion Pinhas, that four redemptions are destined to be, and so the Midrash wrote on "And Pharaoh's cup was in his hand"; and likewise I wrote that the four correspond to the parts of time, as is in the portion Vayishlah in the holy Zohar on "She that looks forth as the dawn, fair as the moon, bright as the sun, awesome as bannered hosts". Here are four; and therefore our prayer is founded on two sides: the first, the complete redemption which is after the son of David; the second, the first and second mentioned above. And the order of the Men of the Great Assembly is a proof for my way: that after the blessing of the years, where it is written, "And you