Mount Tzvi
…he says explicitly that one offers sacrifices even though there is no House; but according to Rabad, that the holiness of the Temple is annulled, if we join to his view also the approach of Rabbenu Hananel, that in this time the high places are forbidden, then even in the place of the altar itself he is as one who slaughters and offers up outside, and is liable to excision. And nevertheless one must not say that now the difficulty returns to its place, why Rabad was silent toward Maimonides on the law of one who offers up outside in this time, since there is much between them; for this is not so, since at any rate in the law of Maimonides itself, which deals with one who offers up truly outside, not in the place of the Temple, and deals with the liability of "outside", in this Rabad does not disagree at all; and as for the inference of exemption in the place of the altar, Rabad did not descend to object to him, since he does not deal explicitly with this; but indeed, if it should happen that one slaughtered and offered up in this time in the place of the altar, one must be concerned for liability of excision according to the approach of Rabad.
And besides this, even according to Rashi, who does not hold like Rabbenu Hananel, and according to the one who says that the holiness of the Temple was annulled, the high places are permitted also in this time, one may argue that it is impossible to offer the Passover offering on the ground of the permission of the high places, as it is taught (Zevahim 114b): Rabbi Shimon says: From where do we know that one who sacrifices the Passover offering on a private high place at a time when the high places are forbidden transgresses a negative commandment? Scripture says, "Thou mayest not sacrifice in one of thy gates"; and it concludes there that it deals with a time when the high places are permitted, and the Passover offering is not offered on a private high place, and it is under a negative commandment; and so Maimonides ruled. If so, according to Rabad, that it was not sanctified for the time to come, and it is a time when the high places are permitted, nevertheless one who slaughters the Passover offering on a high place transgresses a negative commandment.
At first sight one must examine why Rabad did not object (in chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House) there also at halakhah 11, where Maimonides ruled that one does not add to the city or to the Courts except by the king, and by a prophet, and by the Urim and Tummim, and by a Sanhedrin of seventy-one, etc. According to what is explained in Shevuot (16a), that Rabbi Huna and Rabbi Nahman disagree whether "with all these" was taught or "with one of all these" was taught, that this depends on the dispute whether the first holiness was sanctified for the time to come or not; and according to the one who says it was not sanctified for the time to come, perforce "with one of all these" was taught; and if so, according to the approach of Rabad that the holiness of the Temple was annulled, perforce we do not need all of these for sanctifying the Court, and he should have objected to Maimonides on this as well. And then I found that the book Male ha-Ro'im preceded me in this, and he also uses this difficulty as a foundation for his words, that in truth Rabad too holds like Maimonides. And in my humble opinion there is no necessity in this either, for simply one may say that from the outset all agree that we need all these that are counted in the Mishnah of Shevuot; and something like a proof for this is that Rabbi Huna and Rabbi Nahman do not disagree there in Shevuot also on the first clause of our Mishnah, which teaches that one does not add to the city and to the Courts except by a king and a prophet and the Urim and Tummim; which implies that Rabbi Nahman does not disagree, and holds that for the fulfilment of the commandment we need all of them. And even if we wish to strain and say that they disagree on the latter clause of the Mishnah and the same applies to the first clause as well, even so there is no objection here against Maimonides, who took up the language of the Mishnah as is his way; and just as Rabbi Nahman would explain the first clause of the Mishnah, so it is possible to explain the language of Maimonides also according to the approach of Rabad. Then I found in Ritva (Shevuot 16) that he wrote that even according to Rabbi Nahman, for the fulfilment of the commandment we need all of them. And with regard to the case after the fact, which Maimonides wrote in halakhah 14, that if it was not sanctified with all these it is not holy, here in truth there is an objection of Rabad, that the first holiness was annulled and the sanctification of Ezra was a complete sanctification and not for a remembrance alone; and consequently it is explained from his words that with one of all these also the sanctification takes effect. Further, one must examine closely why Rabad waited