Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
109scan
of 139

Mount Tzvi 55

…behold, we are witnesses that he intends a sacrifice and a complete consecration; and at any rate in his language there is no hint at all that he did not intend consecration. And how shall we say that the consecration does not take effect? And its holiness, where has it gone? But there is no need to enlarge on this, since in any case it is established for us as Rav Hamnuna, that even where he states explicitly "Behold, this is a burnt-offering, to offer it outside", the consecration takes effect and he is punished with excision outside. Afterwards there came to my hand the collection Torah mi-Tzion (first year, section 16), and I saw that the great Rabbi and Gaon Rabbi Shimon Sofer, may his Rock preserve him and give him life (rabbi of the holy community of Erlau), wrote there: "And behold, they can offer whichever way: if the halakhah is as Maimonides, that one offers even though there is no House, it is permitted; and if as Rabad, and there is no holiness at all, he offers on a doubt, and it is not unconsecrated animals in the Court; and he is not liable for slaughtering behayyin, since it is not fit within." End of his words. And behold, in section 4 it has already been explained that there is no foundation for these words; besides the fact that Rabad did not dispute Maimonides on the law of one who slaughters and offers up in this time, apart from this I have brought that according to all opinions it is forbidden to slaughter the Passover offering on a high place, even at the time when the high places were permitted; and even were I to grant him that there is no excision, at any rate a prohibition of the Torah certainly exists, even with what is not fit within. And this is not the place to enlarge on it.

And behold, I found that the Gaon Rabbi David of Karlin, of blessed memory, wrote: "It seems that this we could remedy: to consecrate the Passover offering on condition, that if the place is holy for the future, according to the view of Maimonides, it shall be consecrated for the Passover offering, and if the place is now unconsecrated, it shall be unconsecrated, and the sprinkling shall be as one who sprinkles mere water, and the burning as one who burns mere fat." And nevertheless he concludes on this at the end: "But we cannot do this according to the opinion of Maimonides, because of several matters and doubts; and if we err in them we shall incur excision for entering the place of the House, according to the opinion of Maimonides, since the holiness of the House was not annulled." End of his words. And one may add to his words that there still stands before us a great impediment: what shall we do about the priestly garments? For it is established for us as Rabbi (Yoma 6a) that the girdle of an ordinary priest was mixed kinds; and how shall he wear mixed kinds on a doubt? Perhaps it is as Rabad, and then he wears mixed kinds not in the place of a commandment. And at first sight it may be said that of this there is no need to be concerned, according to what is explained at the end of the Laws of Mixed Kinds: the dispute of Maimonides and Rabad on one who wears the priestly garments not at the time of the Service, whether he is flogged on account of mixed kinds; and so they dispute on this in Tosafot (Hullin 110b, and in Menahot). And if so, it is again permitted whichever way: according to Maimonides he rightly wears mixed kinds, for it is the time of the Service; and if as Rabad, that it is as not at the time of the Service, then Rabad, according to his own view, holds that mixed kinds were permitted in the priestly garments in every case, even not at the time of the Service. But after examination this is not so; for they have already raised a difficulty against Rabad from what we say (Arakhin 3b): "Granted that it was permitted at the time of the Service; not at the time of the Service it was not permitted"; so that one must necessarily say that even according to Rabad it was permitted only at a time fit for the Service, and so I found in the book Bi'ur Halakhah; and at a time not fit for the Service, such as at night, even Rabad concedes that it is forbidden on account of mixed kinds. And further, the chief source of Rabad's words is that passage (Yoma 69a), where it is taught: "The priestly garments: one who goes out in them into the province is forbidden; and in the Sanctuary, whether at the time of the Service or not at the time of the Service, it is permitted, because the priestly garments were given to be enjoyed." And if so, it is decided from its own place that in the province it is forbidden; and according to this, in this time, according to the view of Rabad, the Court too is like the rest of the province, and it is forbidden on account of mixed kinds. And it is plain that according to Rabad one cannot say as the answer of the Kesef Mishneh on behalf of Maimonides, that this baraita does not speak of mixed kinds but of deriving benefit from consecrated property; for if so, how does he prove that even not at the time of the Service there is no prohibition of mixed kinds? Behold, necessarily, according to Rabad, concerning

14