9 The Gate of Zion
…that the academies have ceased. In Babylon all agree that it is permitted to go up from Babylon, and Maimonides set down the law as it was then, in the time of the Talmud.
- Now, the Rabbi in the Megillat Esther wished to build a siege-work against the words of our great master Nahmanides of blessed memory, and his words are astonishing. These are the words of Nahmanides (in commandment 4, which he counted there): That the commandment on which they enlarged, namely dwelling in the Land of Israel, etc., all of it is this positive commandment which we were commanded, to possess it and to dwell in it; if so, it is a positive commandment for all generations, obliging each one of us even in the time of exile; and the language of the Sifre, etc., that it is equal to all the commandments. Thus far the words of Nahmanides. And the Megillat Esther wrote on this, and these are his words: And as for what he says, that the Sages enlarged on the praise of dwelling in the Land, that is only in the time of the Temple, etc.; and a further proof that it is not a commandment is from what is said, "He who goes up from Babylon", etc. And as for what is said in the Sifre, that they wept and read this verse, "and thou shalt dwell in it", it seems to me that it was not in their power to fulfil this verse, because the House was destroyed, and over this they wept and rent their garments, etc. Thus far from his words. And it is a wonder that so great a man should have erred in vision. First, in all the words of the Talmud there in Ketubot, such as Rabbi Zeira and Rabbi Abba, who slipped away from Rabbi Yehudah when they went up to the Land of Israel; and Ulla, who used to go up and did not merit to die there, and they brought his coffin up there, and Rabbi Eleazar said: You, Ulla, shall die on unclean ground? They said to him: His coffin has come. And he said to them: Its receiving him while alive is not the same, etc.; and so Rabbi Hanina said there concerning going down for levirate marriage outside the Land; and so there in the story of Ilfa. Thus all of it is in the present time, for all the Amoraim mentioned above lived a long time after the destruction. Second, as for what the Megillat Esther wrote on the Sifre, that they wept only because they could not fulfil the positive commandment of dwelling on account of the destruction: is it not said expressly that they wept when they went out from the Holy Land, and therefore returned to their place? Thus the chief cause of the weeping was that they had gone out from the Holy Land; and without doubt such great men felt at once that their holy spirit was diminished when they left the Land; therefore they wept, and returned at once, and said, "It is equal", etc. And it is further astonishing of the Megillat Esther: did not Maimonides himself, whom he comes to defend, write expressly (in chapter 8 of the Laws of Kings, halakhah 9): It is forbidden to go out from the Land of Israel to outside the Land for ever. Thus far his words. "For ever" proves expressly that there is no distinction between one time and another; and so Maimonides brought there all the sayings in the Talmud which enlarged upon this commandment, and likewise the saying "Its receiving him while alive is not the same as its receiving him after death", and it is taken from the incident of Ulla, which was in the present time. Therefore it is clear that all the words of the Megillat Esther are refuted by this.
Said Natan Friedland, who brings it to press
How very mighty are the proofs, especially, and a support to the words of the Gaon Rabbi Tzvi Kalischer, of how the whole of Israel transgresses the verse And the Land shall not be sold in perpetuity (Leviticus 25). Behold, it is found written in the words of Rabbi David Lira in his book Ir Miklat and Glosses, portion Behar, on the verse "And the Land, etc." mentioned above, and these are his words: "Maharamash wrote that on the redemption of the Land our redemption depends, and on its subjugation our subjugation depends." Thus far his words. It follows that in these few words Maharamash comprised how the redemption is in our hands, for it depends on the redemption of the Land; and he relies on the verse "And the Land shall not be sold in perpetuity", for the country now stands under the rule of "stand and give back" — and so long as we are able to take it out of their hands, and on account of money or negligence our desire for it is lessened and our longing for it is small, and we have drawn back our hand from buying, is it not at every moment as though we had abandoned it in perpetuity in their hands, and as was spoken with full mouth by the holy one of