Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
59scan
of 139

Essay on Holy Things 30

…on the law of the Torah, by which we follow presumption; and to this Ribash agrees. And from this there appears to me a firm foundation, that certainly by the Torah every priest stands in his presumptive status, whether for leniency or for stringency, as is proven from Maimonides mentioned above, and as is written (in chapter 1 of the Laws of Forbidden Relations) that one burns on the strength of presumptions, whoever has been presumed so in the city for thirty days, even on his own word; and here he wrote that one is flogged on presumption, and, as the Mishneh la-Melekh wrote, it speaks of one who has been presumed so. And there is likewise a clear proof from Rashi (Ketubot 24), the comment beginning "They sought their register, those that were reckoned by genealogy": "Because they intermarried in the exile with the peoples of the land and bore them sons, as is written in the book of Ezra, and these are profaned; therefore those born in the exile needed to establish their lineage when they went up from the exile at the Second Temple." End of his words. So it is explicit that only because of a clear flaw did they need to establish their lineage; but had there been no flaw, we would rely on presumption without establishing lineage. And what is said in the Talmud there, that he permitted them only the holy things of the provinces, refers to the time of the clear flaw, as Rashi explains; but after they had already been clarified and sifted in the days of the Second Temple by the court of priests, in bringing near and in thrusting away, the flaw departed, and we rely on the majority by the law of the Torah. And so the Yam shel Shelomoh, which our master cited, which was stringent in the matter of devoted things, wrote, "if not the majority, close to half have become mixed"; so even Rashal, who went beyond measure, more than enough, nevertheless held that most of them are fit. And by the Torah we certainly follow the majority, and the Rabbis made a higher standard in matters of lineage; and only where there is no positive commandment against it did they make the higher standard of requiring lineage of them; but wherever a positive commandment would be neglected, it remains under the law of the Torah, that we rely on majority and presumption. And according to this, in the case before us, if we should have permission to minister in holiness, there is certainly a great positive commandment of the Service, and where a positive commandment would be neglected we rely on the law of the Torah; and if so, there is also no proof from the Responsa Hut ha-Shani and those who agree with him, who were stringent with them in a matter forbidden to non-priests, for they all speak of a case where no positive commandment is neglected, which is not so in the case before us.

And if one should argue that only where there is already a positive commandment do we rely on the law of the Torah, but to perform an act, to build an altar, and to bring about a positive commandment and rely on presumption — whence? There are two replies to this. First, that from Pesahim (69) it is proven that a positive commandment overrides even though one is not yet obligated, as with an uncircumcised man who has not been circumcised, who is liable to excision on account of the positive commandment of the Passover offering, as is said explicitly in the Talmud there, for this reason. And further, even today there is the positive commandment of the Service, only that there is a hindrance and compulsion on the part of the government there; but when there is permission — for we hold that it was sanctified for the time to come — and if so, whenever there is in the world a way to do it, with the possibility of permission, we transgress a positive commandment each and every day, and so of itself we rely on the law of the Torah. And further, to build an altar is also a positive commandment, if it is permitted to us; and since there is a positive commandment to build, of itself there is also the positive commandment of the Service as of old; and this is clear. And further, it seems to my humble opinion that, since by the Torah we certainly follow majority and presumption, our Sages of blessed memory cannot at all uproot a positive commandment of the Torah where it is not possible with those of attested lineage; for if so the commandment would be uprooted entirely. And indeed the Magen Avraham (section 589, subsection 4) wrote that where the commandment would be uprooted for ever we do not make an enactment; for the power our Sages of blessed memory have to uproot is only occasional, such as not to blow the shofar on the Sabbath in a given year, but to uproot the commandments for ever, no. And if so, how shall we uproot the Service for ever for the sake of a higher standard?

Further, it seems to me that even those who are overly stringent agree that the examination of four mothers is effective, as Rabbenu Tam ruled in the Sefer ha-Yashar, cited in Tosafot, chapter Asarah Yuhasin