Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
97scan
of 139

Mount Tzvi 49

…without the sanctification of the Court, and on the grounds of a public high place. To this one must say that, according to what is explained (Zevahim 117b), "when you come into the Land of Israel, you shall offer; obligatory offerings you shall not offer", and see there in Rashi, that "a man" is written and the verse does not distinguish between a great high place and a small one, so that for an individual only vow-offerings and freewill-offerings were offered, but not obligatory ones, even on public high places; and so they rightly needed to sanctify it with two thank-offerings, so that it should have the law of the Temple in all its particulars, and so that the obligatory sacrifice of an individual too could be offered in it *) — there is no proof from there that an altar alone is not a public high place, since even without this one must say that they sanctified it for the sake of the obligatory sacrifice of an individual. And it is still not settled for me: whence does Rashi know that obligatory offerings were offered for individuals, and that therefore they sanctified it with two thank-offerings? Perhaps they did not sanctify it, and indeed obligatory offerings for individuals were not offered at all. It is possible to say that it counts as a public high place only with the consent of the majority of Israel, and therefore in the days of Ezra, when the majority of Israel was not there, it did not count as a public high place, and so they needed to sanctify it with the sanctity of the Sanctuary; or we may say that after the Sanctuary was first built, the commandment came into force never again to offer except in the sanctified place; and although Rashi does not hold like Rabbenu Hananel, and for Rashi, according to the one who says it was not sanctified for the future, the high places became permitted again, nevertheless there is a commandment to offer only in the Temple, as in the words of Maimonides in chapter 1 of the Laws of the Chosen House, halakhah 3: "Once the Sanctuary was built in Jerusalem, all the places, every one of them, were forbidden for building in them a house for Yahweh, etc." Now the late Gaon Rabbi David Friedmann of blessed memory proves from here that Rabad holds like the view of Rabbenu Hananel in Tosafot on Zevahim and Megillah, that there is never any permission for high places after the Sanctuary was built, even according to his own view that the sanctity of the Sanctuary is now annulled; for Rabad did not dispute Maimonides on this law, and from his silence he concedes to him. At first sight one may say that this is not compelling, for in these words of Maimonides no prohibition of high places at all is stated here; here our Master taught us another law, that all places were forbidden for building a house for Yahweh, and this applies also according to the one who says that the high places are permitted at the present time; but nevertheless the commandment of building the Sanctuary cannot be fulfilled except in the chosen place, and in another place it would not have the law of a Sanctuary, and the individual does not offer an obligatory sacrifice there, and also there is no meal-offering on a high place; and there are further practical consequences in several matters, for each according to his own view. And certainly the one who says it was not sanctified for the future would not dispute an explicit verse, which says: "This is my resting-place for ever"; and consequently, according to the one who says it was not sanctified, there is also a commandment to sanctify it with the sanctity of the Sanctuary, since the verse has revealed that one is to offer only in the chosen place, and without sanctification there is no advantage of this place over another place as regards the act of offering itself.

Now, according to what has been said, what he concluded in the book Seeking Zion, to permit the offering of sacrifices by force of


*) See the commentary of the Gaon Malbim of blessed memory on Ezra 3, verse 5, and these are his words: "It appears that Scripture is precise that only burnt-offerings were offered and not other sacrifices; from this it is implied, as is the opinion of Rabad, that the sanctity of the Sanctuary was annulled, following the opinion of Rabbi Simeon according to his words in Zevahim, that on a public high place even the community was permitted to offer only Passover offerings and obligatory offerings that have a fixed time, etc. And his words are astonishing, and at first sight it escaped him what we learned in the Mishnah: Rabbi Eliezer said, I heard that when they were building the Sanctuary they made curtains for the Sanctuary and curtains for the Court; and on this it is said in the Talmud: from this it follows that Rabbi Eliezer holds it was not sanctified for the future. And it is clear from this that even according to the one who says it was not sanctified for the future, even for him it was sanctified with the sanctity of the Sanctuary by means of curtains, and as Rashi wrote, that they sanctified it with two thank-offerings.