Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 2 · 11 June 1897
3printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 2. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.


(continued from page 2)

…proved that the Jews can be a people — let us say, can become a people.

Let it be granted that the Jews are to-day no people, but excellent, genuine Germans, Englishmen, Russians, and so forth, in nothing distinguishable from all other Germans, Englishmen, Russians, and so forth. Yet surely, even upon Dr. Güdemann's own assumption, the English Jews are no more genuine Englishmen than were those English "Pilgrim Fathers" who sailed to America in the "Mayflower" to escape the pressure upon conscience which they suffered in their English home. Those indubitable Englishmen developed out of themselves a new people, which feels itself far more sharply opposed to the English than I could ever wish the Palestinian Jewish people to feel towards any European Christian nation. So have genuine Spaniards in Argentina, Mexico, Chili, and so forth formed new peoples with a strongly pronounced un-Spanish, nay anti-Spanish national consciousness; so have genuine Portuguese formed that Brazilian nationality which is very little kindly disposed towards the Portuguese. The reason is this: peoples arise not from unknown biological causes operative in primeval times alone, but also from historical causes, which may sometimes be caught in the very act. When a vast majority of a people declares to a precisely defined minority: "You do not belong to us, you are strangers among us," nothing remains to that minority but to order its affairs in accordance with this notice of dissolution of fellowship; and if the outcast minority feels this proscription in its heart as an intolerable pain, its instinct of self-preservation justifies the endeavour to create for itself less painful conditions of existence. Therefore: even were it true that the Jews are to-day no people, anti-Semitism would be a sufficient reason for them to become one.

The revival of Jewish nationality "contradicts the spirit of the Jewish religion, falsifies it, is quackery"; "in the intention of helping Judaism, Judaism may perish." Dr. Güdemann accordingly rejects Zionism in order that Judaism may take no harm. As the means of preserving it he recommends assimilation. He covers this recommendation with a few names of authority; beside Philo and Maimonides, who were very good Jews, and whose character, life, and writings raise the sharpest protest against the employment of their names in support of Dr. Güdemann's thesis, he names Mendelssohn also. With this citation he is fortunate indeed! Mendelssohn was so successful an assimilator that all his descendants are to-day good Christians and pillars of the Evangelical State Church in Prussia. That, at least, is consistent. Does Dr. Güdemann desire this sort of assimilation? Then he has chosen the fitting standpoint. He does not occupy that standpoint alone. The Pole Frank took it up in the last century. His adherents went, with a refreshing logic, to the very end. The Frankists did in fact assimilate themselves; of their descendants the greater number have to-day, after four or five generations, forgotten their Jewish origin, and are Catholic national Poles with only now and then a somewhat treacherously curved nose. This result could presumably be attained in Germany and the other countries as well. It is only strange that a Grand Rabbi of all men should describe it as desirable. And stranger still, that while he recommends the road which leads infallibly to the ruin of Judaism, and which historically has in every case led to that goal, he should at the same time profess to stand forth for the preservation of Judaism.

Another of those inconceivable contradictions in the inmost substance of the thought, which make it so hard to regard Dr. Güdemann's polemic as the first work of a serious man, is this: that Dr. Güdemann first denies that the Jews are a people, and then blithely speaks of the mission of the Jewish people. A thing which does not exist at all can surely have no mission! But let us assume that Dr. Güdemann ascribes this mission not to the Jewish people but to the Jewish faith, and that the Jewish faith would survive the assimilation after the Mendelssohnian example which Dr. Güdemann recommends. What sort of mission is this to be? "The moral perfecting of all men, the fraternization of the whole of mankind." How can Dr. Güdemann show us this fraternization? We have never been wanting in brotherly love for all our fellow men. Let him preach it to the anti-Semites! "Que messieurs les antisémites commencent!" We shall wait and see what reception is prepared for his sermon. A small minority which suffers precisely from this, that a great majority will not acknowledge it as brethren, can hardly cry out to that majority: "Let us be friends, Cinna!" That gesture is noble and magnanimous when the stronger makes it. When the weak, the persecuted, speaks to the enemy of fraternization, such an attitude bears another name. A mission of that kind is at once unworthy and impracticable; and to demand that for its sake the Jews shall renounce the recovery of the land of their fathers is simply to mock them.

But what is the sense of all this talk of a mission of the Jewish people? The nebulous phrase concerning the mission of peoples is the mystical form in which is expressed the knowledge, or the surmise, gained by looking back over history, that a given people has in a given manner influenced the course of development of human civilization. This mode of expression confounds causality with finality. It assumes that definite tasks are assigned to a people from the outset, and that it lives and works with a view to the accomplishment of those tasks. The truth is that it creates definite phenomena of cultural history by living and working as, in virtue of its natural endowment and the influence of all outward circumstances, it can and must live and work. A people has no other mission than to live, and to develop fully all the capacities germinating within it. Then, without intention and without consciousness, it fulfils quite of itself the tasks of universal human history. A downtrodden, persecuted, despised Jewry in the midst of anti-Semitic peoples is without value for mankind; a free, strong, life-loving Jewry will become a useful fellow labourer in the work of the progress of mankind as a whole. Collaboration in that work may, for aught I care, be called a mission. In any case this mission will assuredly not be fulfilled by a Jewry baited by anti-Semitism, whereas by a nationally independent Jewry it may perhaps, nay probably, be fulfilled.

Like many faint-hearted and timorous Jews, Dr. Güdemann too evidently fears that Zionism, which has for its premise that the Jews avow themselves a distinct people, will permit the anti-Semites to accuse us triumphantly of having no fatherland. Faint-heartedness and fear are bad counsellors. The anti-Semites did not wait for Zionism in order to brand us as men without a fatherland. But our Christian fellow countrymen, in whom we may presume a sense of justice, will believe us when we speak to them thus:

"We Jews are loyal citizens of the State to which we belong. All the interests of the fatherland are ours as well. We have not one single interest which is opposed to any interest of our fatherland. We are strong and deeply feeling men, and therefore we cling with more than average love to the place where our cradle stood and where the bodies of our fathers moulder; for that place signifies for us, as for every man, the memory of our childhood, it is bound up for us too with our dearest emotions, and this memory is with us more vivid, all emotions are with us more vehement, than with men of a less sentimental and passionate temper. So intimately do we cling to our homeland that our soul, even then,