Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 7 · 16 July 1897
7scan
of 20

No. 7. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

. . . bundle, they go away; the land in which they have done no evil, in which they wished only to make the immodest attempt to live, is henceforth forbidden them as a place of residence. And here a question arises. Does no one put it to himself, who reads that families consisting of men, women, children, old people, sick people must suddenly depart! Where do these people go? is the question. Whither? . . .

* * *

In recent days there was an exceedingly brilliant theatrical performance. The piece given was: "The Theoretical and the Practical Anti-Semites," a farce in 2 acts with an intermezzo. Place: Mährisch-Aussee. Scene: general meeting of the North Moravian League. The leading idea of the comedy is no new one. First act: the Teutons Druschba, Bodirski and comrades from Vienna move that membership of the League be restricted to Germans of purely Germanic descent, that is, that Jews be excluded from admission. Storm and tempest. Intermezzo: variations on the theme "argentum, etsi judaicum, non olet." 2nd act: the chairman declares: "We are just as much German Nationals and just such race anti-Semites as the Viennese. But since without the Jewish moneys we should be ruined, we here in Moravia will be only 'theoretical' anti-Semites and not 'practical' ones as well, like the Viennese." (Oho and Heilo.) Thereupon the motion that the League should further remain merely "theoretically" anti-Semitic, that is, that it should for the future also accept Jewish money, is carried by three-fifths against two-fifths of the votes. The curtain falls. The Jews present applaud tumultuously, and tears of joy trickle down their cheeks . . .

The (social-political) "Brünner Sonntags-Zeitung" devotes a lengthy review to this farce and closes with the words: "But if, on the ground of such experiences, the Moravian Jews do not resolve with all speed to shun the fellowship of racial associates of so exceedingly lofty a morality, and to be German on their own account, independently of all Germanic-nationalists and German Liberals alike, according to their own requirements: then let them not demand of others that respect which they deny themselves." Poor Jews! Within a single year they have already been German Liberals, German Progressives, social politicians, social democrats. Now they are to become "Germans on their own account and at their own risk." The leading Jews of Bruenn, who still do not know that they are Jews, repeat it devoutly. So the Jewish question appears solved for Moravia.

Leroy-Beaulieu on Anti-Semitism.

(Conclusion).

Monsieur Leroy-Beaulieu does us harm, as many Jews estranged from our nation do us harm, and their trains of thought are often his as well. Comparatively the finest and most magnanimous of his reasoning is that directed against religious anti-Semitism. That is the first part of his exposition. He begins by correcting the error that the anti-Christian movement of the last century, in France above all, proceeded from the Jews. "It was no Jew who gave out the watchword Ecrasons l'infâme! It was Voltaire, and instead of having been a pupil or a friend of the Jews, he might rather be claimed by the anti-Semites as one of their forerunners."

Under Louis XVI. there were scarcely a few hundred Jews in Paris; most of them were poor and unknown, relegated to outlying suburbs. These were too weak to be able to exercise any influence whatever upon the Revolution, upon the secularisation and de-Christianisation of modern society. Later, to be sure, the Jews appear to have collaborated duly in the de-Christianisation of society. How did they do it? As individuals, or in Jewish and Judaised associations. As individuals they were and are powerless. Of Jewish associations Leroy-Beaulieu knows only one worth mentioning: the Alliance Israélite Universelle. And as a Judaised association Freemasonry at most might be named.

Leroy-Beaulieu explains the character of the Alliance Israélite, which was founded in the seventies by Crémieux and was to guarantee, in all countries, and particularly in the barbarous ones, the interests of our co-religionists, freedom of religious observance and the safety of persons. He finds nothing to object to in this association, modelled upon the "Evangelical Alliance." We Zionists are here of another opinion than Monsieur Leroy-Beaulieu and the Alliance Jews. We hold this institution to be a foolish one. Never has a folly of association done so much harm in proportion to the utmost possible benefit as this comical "Universal Alliance," which is neither universal, nor an alliance, and least of all Jewish. With its pompous and empty name this Alliance has made our opponents believe that a secret international brotherhood exists for the establishment of a Jewish dominion over the world. The sooner this Alliance vanishes from the face of the earth, the better it will be. We Zionists are in the plainest and most decided manner opposed to every such international association of Jews, which, were it effective, would represent that rightly detested "State within the State," and which, being powerless and insignificant, offers nothing but disadvantages. This is not the place to set forth our opposing standpoint in detail. Let only this be said, that for the solution of the Jewish question we desire not an international society but an international discussion, that is to say: not leaguing and intriguing, secret interventions, by-ways, but candid debate under the constant and complete control of public opinion.

Very interesting are Leroy-Beaulieu's remarks upon Freemasonry. He shows that the Jews were able to gain admission to the lodges only late, and in some countries cannot even now. The anti-clericalism of Freemasonry is therefore not the work of the Jews, even if they gradually, and perhaps with passion, took part in it. It was probably the greatest political blunder of the Jews, who had but just been set free. Psychologically, to be sure, this blunder is explicable. With a veritable delight many took part in the assault upon the Church, from which the Jews had for centuries been so bitterly persecuted. Upon this point too our education has since been completed. The modern Jew, even if he be a freethinker — nay, then all the more — will let every man be saved after his own fashion. Are we to wage religious campaigns now, we who waged none even in the time of our national existence, we who never sought to make proselytes? Before the mysteries of life we too stand with the humble word "Ignorabimus"! For the condition of the weak, for the education of the young and for the parting consolation of the old, religion still seems to us irreplaceable. Thus the anti-clericalism of the Jews was nothing but rancune. And rancune is the stupidest of policies. We are paying for it.

Leroy-Beaulieu is weak in his discussion of national anti-Semitism. We shall see at the conclusion why. National anti-Semitism he expounds evasively. He merely admonishes the Catholics not to employ the reproach of cosmopolitanism lightly; for the Church too is cosmopolitan, it is so above all. He establishes what we know well enough: that the Jews were everywhere, but a few years ago, on the point of assimilating, and that this movement was brought to a standstill precisely by those who reproach the Jews with not merging into the population surrounding them. He mocks further at the ethnographic dilettantism of the anti-Semites. The Jews, he says, are no coherent race, and the like. As though the anti-Jewish movement were in any way altered by the fact that its catchword can be faulted scientifically. That is the naïveté of the scholar.

If we were able and obliged just now to establish, in Leroy-Beaulieu's own words, that he is no friend of the Jews, we shall find in the third part of his exposition that he nevertheless does not wish to do the Jews any injustice. We would be