Page 2. — "Die Welt." — No. 16.
Schismas
(continued from page 1)
… would be apt to cause him less anxiety than a peaceful Jewish state-formation in Palestine? It would be somewhat disrespectful to credit the statesmanlike genius of the great Pope with such a diplomatic conception directed against the little Jews, who are driven by no craving for worldly power, but only by the wish to be allowed, unhindered, to be man, Jew, and citizen, and to raise up a house of their own again there, whence they came. For what else does national feeling mean in a people than this longing for a house of its own? Ah yes, there belongs to it the building concession of the magistracy of Europe, first of all of the Sultan, to whom the ground belongs, and then of the great Powers, which must resolve to approve the Jewish State. And it is not at all to be denied that this concession may be made more difficult by a protest of the Pope with the Sultan. Only one does not understand what effect the protest is to produce in the Yildiz Kiosk, if it has no other ground than that of the protection of the Holy Places? To the Islamic Caliph these are, no otherwise than to the Jews, venerable historical relics, and the little lamp with which the Greek tended them may without harm to Islam be entrusted to the Jew as well.
The more so since, if one reflects rightly, neither any ecclesiastical nor any Turkish interest would suffer the least damage from the realisation of the Zionist aim. Leo XIII. is no Caraffa, and it is surely repugnant to his lofty cast of thought that at the end of the XIXth century a modern substitute for the yellow badge should be sought with hypocritical brutality. To him, one should think, the thought of creating a national, self-founded, unaggressive rallying-point for the Jews upon the soil which has never ceased to be their ideal home must be pleasing for this very reason, that it is at once a historical and a humane thought, a worldly one in the best sense and a pious one. Like an unearthly figure, almost disembodied and with great luminous eye, this aged man moves among men; it would truly become him well to strip from himself also the fetter of the traditional curialist policy toward the Jews, and to recognise in Zionism the liberating idea. To set up Jerusalem against Rome, the Temple against the Mosque, is not the mainspring of Zionism; it is for the humanity in the Jew that it wrestles after a guarantee. To stunt the success of this wrestling merely that the Jews may remain scattered would truly be too small an endeavour for the human stature of Leo XIII. The tiny ones may well be dismayed at the imposing impression which, from the site of a once fruitless Council, the successful Congress of the Zionists has produced; the Sage of St. Peter's should be too great to take fright at it. Papa supra grammaticam.
The Week.
Vienna, 16 September 1897.
The anti-Zionist movement among the Jews in Hungary has nothing alarming about it. Hungary's most recent past and its present make such things appear intelligible. But in Hungary too care has been taken that the cedars shall not grow into heaven, and so we can calmly bide our time. The Hungarian Jews distinguish themselves by particular bravery and energy, and their temperament has shaped the antagonisms there a little more weakly. Less patient than others, they would for that reason not simply suffer a race-hostile current to pass over them. For the present this opposition is contagious only for the Zionists in Hungary, and later the anti-Zionist associations will doubtless be seen to by the autochthons — but not in Hungary alone.
* * *
Mr. Zadoc Kahn, the venerable Grand Rabbi of Paris, has allowed himself to be interviewed upon Zionism. An interview is always a delicate business. As a rule one is questioned there about things of which one does not like, or does not find it easy, to speak. Mr. Zadoc Kahn too appears to have found himself in a similar position. That he directs himself above all against the national side of the movement is natural. The official loyalty of which men avail themselves on such occasions will here always confound "fatherland," "home," and "nationality." Zionism, moreover, is a matter of courage, and this courage will present itself readily enough when there is no longer any cause for opportunist effusions of sentiment. Mr. Zadoc Kahn denies national motives to the movement on the ground that it is willing to content itself with — Argentina, should the promised land prove unattainable. That is a small logical error. For the issue of a work, which after all depends upon all manner of external circumstances, cannot be regarded as characteristic of the inner driving causes. One thing Mr. Zadoc Kahn concedes, like all the rest: it is well that the poor Jewish brethren should be conveyed somewhere and land acquired for them, so that they may live without having to fear judicial raids. But the possibility of founding a state he doubts, for it is difficult, and bound up with every conceivable confusion, to erect a realm. And that is not so incorrect either. One must build railways, organise a post, provide for schools, offices, police, and public lighting, prescribe laws, appoint judges — in short, one has one's hands full, and how easily may something important be forgotten!
* * *
After the Ringtheater fire there was founded in Vienna the First Voluntary Rescue Society, with the task of rendering first aid in all accidents occurring within the area of the metropolis. Jews and Christians have since taken part in common in this beneficent undertaking, but such a mixture did not suit the anti-Semitic Town Council, which therefore refused the subvention of the Rescue Society. Now an Aryan Rescue Society has been formed in Vienna, and the Town Council is at last in a position to support a useful institution, which probably appears to the gentlemen more useful still, since participation in the merciful works of the new society is barred to Jews by its statutes. The parodying cases so often invented during the late subvention dispute, in which an Aryan, injured indeed but sound in his convictions, disdains to have his bleeding wounds bound up by Jewish physicians; the question whether the new Aryan rescuers will refuse their assistance to a Jew; or the establishment of the satisfying fact that one who now breaks a leg or his neck in Vienna may henceforth permit himself the luxury of choosing his helpers according to his religious, political, or national inclinations — these are in the end merely newspaper jests. But, as usual, they do not hit upon what is right and important in the matter. It is in no way to the Jew's shame if measures must be taken to prevent him from being charitable, self-sacrificing, and helpful. This, moreover, is not so seriously meant. Their gifts and alms will in future be accepted just as hitherto. On that score the Jews may be free from anxiety. At most people will break themselves of the habit of saying "thank you" to them; but certainly they will refuse ever more energetically to associate with them. In this Aryanism laid down by statute there lies nothing else than the principle of withdrawing everywhere and in every field from social community with the Jews. And that will not remain without effect. The more associations of programmatic race-unity arise, the more