Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 23 · 10 June 1898
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 23.

(continued from page 1)

…Salisburi could for a single moment have thought of founding so weighty a measure as the prohibition of immigration upon this cobweb of hollow reasoning. Where, then, are these thousand aliens relieved? In the East of London. Out of whose pockets? Out of those of the ratepayers in the East of London. Who are the ratepayers in the East of London? The immigrant workers from Poland and Russia. But from whom has Lord Salisbury the mandate to protect the propertied Jews against the poor Jews?

According to the report of the "Times", the speech with which the Prime Minister supported the Bill was repeatedly interrupted by the laughter of the Lords — not by the laughter of the Lords who thought otherwise, but by that of the assenting Lords. With the utmost effort one can discover nothing in the speech that could remotely resemble a jest; at what were the Lords laughing? It was the laughter of the initiated in the presence of the simple; the people of England is given a tale of horror to hear about the burdening of the ratepayers by aliens, but the augurs in the Upper House laugh over the successful joke.

More candid than Lord Salisbury's argument was that of the mover of the Bill. Lord Hardwicke said it roundly: the immigrant Polish and Russian Jews work, in comparison with their British rivals, more and better for lower wages. Here at least it is possible to believe in the legislator's good faith, even though those who know are perfectly aware that the Jewish workers never appear as rivals of the natives, but bring new industries with them or create them. This has been demonstrated so often by the recognised authorities — as, for example, by the famous political economist Charles Booth — that it is superfluous to lay any particular stress upon the fact; it was, moreover, expressly mentioned by the Liberal opponents of the Bill as well. But neither this nor a thousand other facts could have restrained the Lords from bringing in the Bill. The Conservative Cabinet stood in need of a popular measure in order to regain some footing in the country — whereupon the learned Lord Salisbury, who assuredly knows the history of the Jews in the dispersion very well, had recourse to the surest means: an anti-Jewish measure always makes its author popular, in England too, and at the end of the vaunted century.

It is a thousand pities that the report of the division in the House of Lords does not name the ayes and the noes. How did the peers of English nationality and Mosaic confession, Lord Pirbright and Lord Rothschild, vote? Lord Pirbright, formerly Baron de Worms of unpleasant memory, owes his rank as a peer to the faithful following he rendered to Lord Salisbury and the Conservative cause — what does he think of the Bill which closes the saving haven against his persecuted kinsmen from the East? When Lord Pirbright was still simply Baron de Worms he had a certain influence upon the English Premier; has he now, as a peer of England, lost that influence, or has he no need to exert it in favour of his persecuted kinsmen? Sundry occurrences within the London community, and this or that utterance from a competent quarter, give ground for supposing that the improbable assumption is the correct one. The English Jews of the Adlerian observance will breathe again with relief when Lord Salisbury's shameful Bill attains the force of law. With the short-sightedness that distinguishes all Anglo-Saxons of the Mosaic confession, from the Chief Rabbi Dr. Adler down to the meanest Russian pedlar who has earned a few coppers in the dirt of Manchester, these people will hail the prohibition of immigration as a benefit to the Jews already settled in England. "Let the poor, restless fugitives see for themselves how they are to find shelter — to us, who have become Englishmen upon English soil, they are a sore burden, for they recall our own origin and give occasion to the superstition that the Jew in England is a foreign element, not wholly assimilated to Anglo-Saxon blood."

The English Jews of the standing and the influence of a Lord Pirbright have let a brilliant opportunity slip. Now, as never before, was the moment to show that they understand the right of Israel to exist among the nations; now was the time to tell the noble Lords and all the world what a sin — nay, more! — what a blunder it is to show the door to a handful of work-seeking, one might almost say work-craving, Jews. Lord Pirbright and his colleagues in the Upper House evidently reasoned somewhat after this fashion: "Hitherto we have opened the door out of grace and love of our fellow-men to the poor Jews whom Russia would not have; but now we can no longer permit ourselves this luxury of humanity towards aliens, because our own proletarians require more elbow-room. Since charity begins at home, we declare that we can exercise no further grace towards the Russian Jews, and we turn them back." The assertion that England, or any other State at any period of history, opened its gates to the Jews out of grace is a lie, a dangerous, manifest, crying lie, almost as monstrous as the lie of modern humanity. Whoever knows Jewish history knows it: never have we received a morsel of bread, never a drop of water for nothing from the hands of the nations; we have paid for every kind of hospitality, that of Russia included, with our sweat and with our blood. Who is so simple to-day as to believe that we were ever tolerated out of grace? Wherever Jews live they are a necessity — now for a whole people, now for particular classes, in sorrowful times for particular individuals. The entire history of our people might be written from this point of view. Everywhere that ponderous races felt the obscure need to raise themselves from a lower state of civilisation to a higher, everywhere that a nation set its course towards creating, besides the values which nature bestows, new values of human labour, and towards establishing a right relation between the two, everywhere there we were welcome as teachers and pioneers. In the barbarous centuries as in more recent times the nations have called us, and they have found their account in their "hospitality". As the Slavs did in the Middle Ages, so Holland and Turkey in the sixteenth, England in the eighteenth, America in the nineteenth century called for Jewish labour and Jewish spirit of enterprise — they did not tolerate them out of grace; and in our own days, now, when the ungrateful East is driving out its Jews and the West is showing them the door, at this very moment Mexico is calling Jews, with every manner of promise, into that land so richly endowed by nature and so grievously neglected by men. We are not what the Lord's Aliens Bill would make of us, beggars who appeal to the humanity of the nations, but workers who pay with high, with usuriously high interest for the soil made over to us on loan, on loan for short terms.

The Aliens Bill has not yet become law; Lord Pirbright has still the opportunity of showing Lord Salisbury the folly of his petty, unworthy and fatal policy towards the Jews.

❦