Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 31 · 5 August 1898
15printed page
scan 15 of 16

No. 31. — "Die Welt" — Page 15.

(continued from page 14)

…we do not wish to torment ourselves by bringing before us again this sum of twistings, distortions and conscious untruths. So much the more joyfully must one be surprised when one gets into one's hand a little book which, though in places oppositional, is on the whole yet kept objective.

"Zionism", says Dr. Hirsch, "this friend and foe must concede, is, regarded in respect of its driving motives, so thoroughly noble and humane a movement, borne by so great and warm a brotherly love, that it would truly be ignoble, unbrotherly, indeed un-Jewish, simply to go out of the way of the Zionist question, to withdraw before Zionism into the sulking-corner of a self-satisfied philo-Semitism, to clench the fists in the pocket against anti-Semitism, and to pass sentence upon an attempt at a solution of the Jewish question because it proceeds from Jews."

These are strong but true words. And yet they are not strong enough for the lecturer, and he continues: ". . . . the cause itself remains none the less earnest and noble for that, for it is the cause of self-help, of self-liberation and of Jewish self-consciousness. We all love Zion, if only we love Judaism, and because we love Judaism we love the Jews, all who endure and suffer for Judaism; therefore we respect every attempt, every earnest will that would alleviate, banish and blot out these sufferings."

And now Dr. Hirsch proves that Zionism is no work of fancy of enthusiastically disposed men, nor even a product of the times of modern anti-Semitism, and shows us the great line of noble Zionists from Ezekiel and the heroic Bar Kochba down to us, to the man of '48 Moses Hess and the English statesman Benjamin d'Israeli. And how practically and by no means utopianly Moses Hess, for example, thought upon Zionism, the author proves to us by a quotation from "Rom und Jerusalem". "Palestine shall become our still greater future, for the interests of the world's commerce and of politics will press towards the founding of counting-houses and settlements upon the road to India and China. And this Zionism "is not the child of a momentary mood, is not the romantic whim of embittered die-hard Jews, of idealistic dreamers or of ambitious journalists who would gladly for once be ministers, but the red thread, the latent force, the perpetuum mobile of Jewish national and religious history, the dream and the longing of the Jewish masses, who gladly and lightly renounce everything, bread and education, rank and station, the whole Danaan gift of emancipation, if therewith they cannot remain Jews, but also the hope and the longing of many modern, educated Jews who cannot, and also will not, filch or even feign for themselves an entrance into Christian society, into offices and dignities, into ease and comfort." We can quote no more, for the whole first part of the lecture is an inspiring appeal for Zionism. The second, to be sure, looks more critical. Dr. Hirsch can find the Jewish nationality only in religiously coloured manners and customs; to him the Jewish nationality is nothing else than a certain ethical solidarity. We are willing to content ourselves with this conception, for the concluding proposition of our argument runs indeed: for the full development and the living out of their nationality the Jews need a common territory. That, however, even this ethical feeling of solidarity is a sufficiently strong bond Dr. Hirsch himself proves, in that he speaks in another place of the Jews in the East, who still stick deep in the old Jewish nationality and whose only cultivated language is the Hebrew tongue. The side of the idea of Zion pertaining to public law is to him, however, the most questionable, and against this he attempts to polemise, but in a distinguished and measured, if not convincing, manner. "It is clear that with a mass, be it ever so great, which is wholly destitute of modern culture, which has few peasants and few workmen to show, even though it be rich in religious and moral intelligences, neither an agricultural nor an industrial state, nor indeed any state of culture in the modern sense, could be established."

These are assertions and conjectures which have been refuted as often as they have arisen. We need not on this occasion repeat what is well known.

Sch.


Books Received.

Am Ende des Jahrhunderts. A retrospect upon 100 years of intellectual development. Volume III. Edited by Dr. Paul Bornstein: Juden und Judenthum im neunzehnten Jahrhundert. By Dr. S. Bernfeld. Berlin 1898. Published by Siegfried Cronbach.

Palästina, Land und Leute. Travel sketches by W. Bambus. Berlin 1898. Siegfried Cronbach, publisher.

Israel Berlin: "Die Haushaltung der Gesellschaft". Berne 1898.

By the same: "Neue Gedanken über die Entstehung der Familie und der Religion". Berne 1898.

In the publishing house of J. Ehrenpreis, Lemberg, there has appeared: "Der amerikanisch-spanische Krieg" (Jargon), together with pictures from the history of the Jews in Spain.

Dr. Gustav Dalmann: "Christenthum und Judenthum". Leipzig 1898.


Feuilleton.

Die Goldschilds.

A Novel of the End of the 19th Century

by Friedrich Prince Wrede.

(13th Instalment.)

With a superior smile the young scribe developed the theory that there were only two kinds of men, those with strong and those with weak souls. Among the first he counted his Lisi. In her he would not only find a firm support, but would also attain, through a union, a higher degree of perfection, which was after all the task of our earthly pilgrimage.

"Dn", said David dryly, "but that is not thought in a Christian way at all!"

"How so?" asked Karl-Raphael in astonishment.

"I can remember having read something similar in the doctrine of Surja.

But now the cousin grew seriously angry. How could one confound the like! That would be to compare the babbling of a child with the speech of a matured man!

David, however, laughingly cut the thread of his holy indignation. "Karl!" he cried, "I do not comprehend you! What do you want with the whole rubbish of weak and strong souls? Take an example from your future brother-in-law — from Georg! Do you believe that he would occupy himself with such stuff? It would never enter his head! When once it has come so far with him, he will simply take the head of his sweetheart between his two hands — look her firmly in the eyes and cry: Lass — I am fond of you! And with that, basta! You see, out of such a wooing there then arises a healthy race!"

"Yes!" Karl-Raphael conceded, smiling at his cousin's coarseness. "But one must first of all consider whether a marriage is well-pleasing to Heaven!"

"Fiddlesticks!" blustered the Doctor. "All honour to the angels and the saints! But when upon earth two human beings are aflame with ardent love for one another — then that is the will of the Most High, and the rest of Heaven has nothing else to do than to give its blessing thereto!"

Who knows to what blasphemies the wicked David might yet have been provoked, had they not meanwhile reached the goal of their walk.

Lisi and the parents greeted the Doctor in the little front garden and proudly received his well-meant congratulations