Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 33 · 19 August 1898
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 33

Such subordinate folk were the Jews to him at that time — folk who now, if Liberalism prevailed, might possibly become his masters and superiors. Comprehensible enough that the rough-hewn Junker from the Mark resisted this with hands and feet. Against the impending Jewish judge and official he felt a grim hatred, but not against the Jew as a person. Bismarck's friend, Kleist-Retzow, declared in a speech in the Diet: "I will gladly eat and drink with a Jew and even lie in one bed with him. But God forbid that a Jew should become village magistrate or judge." These words faithfully reproduced Bismarck's view of that day as well.

The years rolled away; the storms of revolution and reaction blustered past, and the blindly raging youth of both camps grew gradually into a ripe and energetic manhood. The narrow and passionate Junker from the Mark became at length a mighty statesman and the founder of the Empire. With his sharp eye for practical politics he perceived that up to a certain degree he had need of the co-operation of Liberalism, and that without concessions this help was not to be obtained. Accordingly he granted a variety of things: universal suffrage, freedom of trade, partial parliamentary government, a law of civil marriage. Among the earliest and most significant concessions was also the complete emancipation of the Jews. It was precisely two Jewish parliamentarians, Lasker and Bamberger, who stood near to him at that time and lent him their not-to-be-despised support.

But, as Bamberger early perceived, it was no instinct of liberty, but a political (practical-political) instinct that moved Bismarck to this alliance with Liberalism. His heart knew nothing of it, but beat as before for a patriarchal and "divinely ordained" order of society. At that time he also fell into an embittered war with Social Democracy, Originally he had hoped to set the workers in a patriarchal relation to a Government caring for them in fatherly fashion. This hope came to nothing, and he had to live to see the workers striving to carry through the idea of equality far more radically, and also more literally and more trivially, than the Liberals. In the former Junker of the Mark and future grand seigneur every drop of blood reared up against it, and he flung down the gauntlet with a clash before the hated movement. At the same time, however, yet another party was then rising, whose fundamental tendency must have been far more congenial to him, because it corresponded to his nature — the Christian-Socials.

The idea of equality has in truth monstrous dangers, so long as there is still a social question, so long as an abyss yawns between the construction of constitutional law and the actual conditions. Two effects are called forth by this contradiction: a revolutionary ferment among hot-blooded natures in a socially dependent position, and a need for patriarchal subordination and idyllic contentment at any price among the weaker elements. The one would leap the abyss by force, the others shut their eyes before it. The one are the Social Democrats, the others are the Christian-Socials. These last wished, in the days of Stöcker, to be men loyal to the King to the very bone, and they bitterly hated those who preached Liberalism to them, who wished forcibly to open their eyes and to show them the abyss. But the Jews were at that time the most conspicuous spokesmen of the Liberals and Social Democrats. and so the Christian-Socials became anti-Semites.

Bismarck found himself in a peculiar position The orthodox-ecclesiastical veneer of the new party was in truth repugnant to him, and it was he who coined the scornful phrase about "Stöckerei und Muckerei" Highly congenial to him, on the other hand, was the social-patriarchal and King-loyal tendency of the new party. Here at last he found what he had originally sought among the Social Democrats and had not found. Accordingly he made use of these confederates against the revolutionary labour movement and against the hated levelling Liberalism. In this he followed throughout the categorical imperative of his nature, which simply compelled him to look upon the world with patriarchal eyes and to defend with claws and teeth the patriarchal order of society against the spirit of the age. Of the Jews he hardly thought in the matter, and perhaps did not so much as see them, just as a giant storming passionately towards his goal does not see what small creatures and plants he treads down on the way. He paid no heed to the Jews, any more than the commander in battle pays heed to the individual soldier or even to whole regiments. And if we would be just: what did five hundred thousand Jews signify to the Chancellor of a people of forty millions as against the danger of a social revolution! Without scruple he then sacrificed the Jews to his considerations of practical politics.

Nevertheless Bismarck was never an anti-Semite proper in Stöcker's sense. For of course the statesmanlike genius, the Minister of a European great Power, could not remain confined within the petty-bourgeois limits and in the petty-bourgeois hatred of the court preacher. The time of a trim and fatherly Junker rule over loyal small burghers was simply past once and for all. Bismarck sought other forms and means for his patriarchal manner of governing, and he believed he had found them in the Cartell. The fundamental idea of the Cartell was quite simple: the fusion of the liberal and the conservative aristocracy. To this idea the Prince remained faithful to his last breath, even after his fall, in which Stöcker had a hand, and this conception really determined his later relation to the Jews.

As the actual philosopher of the Bismarck epoch later historians will doubtless designate Friedrich Nietzsche. Between the two men, who are often played off against each other as opposites, there existed a deeper connection than is suspected. Bismarck too, although through his working the high tide of German chauvinism was unloosed, looked far out beyond the hedge-fence of national prejudices. "He was a good European", Christoph Tiedemann assured us but lately in his pamphlet. And Nietzsche, who altogether and everywhere thought of the United States of Europe, who consoled himself for the flattening of the German spirit with the thought that another people would thereby be deepened; Nietzsche too did not remain free from German-patriotic oppressions. He had likewise pondered much upon the Jewish question, and laid down the results of this pondering in aphorism 251 of his book "Jenseits von Gut und Böse". He wished to close the doors towards the East, towards Russia and Austria, so that the still young German kind should not be absorbed by the primeval Jewish race. The Jews already settled in Germany, on the other hand, were to be made as much at home as possible, and their peculiar racial virtues to be incorporated cautiously and with selection into the new German nationality. "It is obvious that the stronger and already more firmly stamped types of the new Germanism could still enter into relations with them with the least misgiving, for example the noble officer from the Mark: it would be of manifold interest to see whether to the hereditary art of commanding and obeying — in both of which the country named is to-day classic —