Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 37 · 16 September 1898
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 37

(continued from page 3)

…in common. Now, the motives which called these societies into being have most certainly not been from the outset motives of charity, nor is the system of charity carried through absolutely, for a certain rational employment of the moneys is taken into account. But it is subject to no doubt at all that the system of charity has, thanks to the conditions prevailing there, become a necessity, and that consequently nothing there is done upon the basis of a uniform and methodical labour.

In the Rothschild colonies the produce must be delivered up to the Administration, and monthly allowances are then distributed, a veritable form of relief, so that unhappily it must even frequently give the impression of a sport.

The causes which hinder the colonisation are:

  1. The form of charity; 2. the lack of a legal regulation; 3. the lack of complete publicity — and it is in this sense too that I understand last year's words "public and legal."

Through the form of charity, idleness is in part called forth. Honoured Assembly! It is precisely the small colonisation that means to set out to create something exemplary. But it is precisely the small colonisation that cannot accomplish this under such conditions. It is a fact that colonists who years ago tilled the soil of Palestine in the sweat of their brow, who had displayed an immense readiness for sacrifice, who had to struggle with the greatest difficulties and did also vanquish them, have, thanks to this system, in the course of time sunk into a kind of indifference and come to a certain beggary. I need only point to Samarin and Ekron. Ekron consists of colonists who were formerly peasants in their own homeland and became precisely that afterwards in Palestine as well. The introduction of the whole system has brought about there a complete upheaval, and hence nothing but hopelessness, no self-confidence.

If you fall into private conversation with a colonist, you will always hear that he does not know what future lies before him; that he is not dependent upon himself; that his whole property depends upon others; that he does not know what debts he has to pay; that he has nothing to do with the management of the colonies, etc.

Through the haphazardness of the dealings an insecurity is created; obstacles come forward perpetually which make a rational activity almost impossible, and immense sums of money have been consumed in the course of the years, perhaps not fewer than the Jewish Colonial Bank now demands, and the results correspond to these sums not at all. That even the very greatest friends of the small colonisation will have to admit.

I adduced just now that this is brought about thanks to the two circumstances that there is no legal regulation and no publicity, and now I will explain that in part.

The whole colonisation was placed upon the ground of the baksheesh system.

Immigration, the purchase of land, the building of houses, all depended upon it. At every step, therefore, publicity had to be shunned, and because publicity had to be shunned, elements were able to force their way in which under complete publicity would never have forced their way in. This we must declare here before the Congress, for it is not merely my own opinion, but that of the greater part of all the colonists in Palestine.

It was uncommonly difficult to carry through a consistent labour; let us say, a consistent labour was quite impossible. Besides this, a mistrust has formed itself among all which works uncommonly injuriously. Thanks to the circumstance that there is no possibility of control, that everything happens in this secrecy upon the principle of the baksheesh system, and that one must apply it at every step, the colonists there have grown mistrustful in such a fashion that one must say a certain reaction is present in them; in this way, therefore, they have also in part sunk morally. Then ignorant and unsuitable persons forced their way in, a protectionism of the most outrageous kind developed itself in Palestine, and out of the people's cause there was in fact made, for years, a sport.

Are the Jews at the present time, then, peasants? To this too I must give only a half answer. I cannot by any means say that even with regard to these 5000 we have attained that condition which we wish to attain. It is best where the colonists are thrown upon themselves and can cherish hopes, as for example again in the colony which I have already adduced and which is worthy to be set up as a model colony, in the colony of Castinje, and much more independently in Katra and other places. The great complaints which are raised, specially on the part of the administrators also, against Sichron, Rosch-Pinah and in part against Rischon, spring from hopelessness. One need only fall into conversation with these colonists to see how this has gradually altered.

I will by no means deny that in recent years a certain improvement has set in, and especially, gentlemen, precisely in the course of this year. What the publicity of the Basle Congress has profited the colonists in Palestine in particular, one must now observe there at every step. The colonists have positively come alive; only now have they begun to feel that there is a word in the world, publicity, and that they too possess a voice before Jewry, a voice which until then had died away.

Many for that reason talk thoughtlessly at random; everywhere there prevails great ill-feeling against the Administration.

We speak of the Administration of Baron Rothschild. Gentlemen! I wish here to make a sharp separation. The Administration and Baron Rothschild are quite different parties. I am not of those who are in any way inclined to render homage to magnates, nor have I the intention of doing so here at the Congress towards Rothschild; but this I must nevertheless say: at every step, in all the colonies, in the course of all conversations, I was obliged to convince myself that Rothschild himself is in extraordinary earnest about the whole affair, that he undoubtedly does this not merely from ideal motives, but that he also really endeavours to take a hand in the entire affairs of the colonisation.

But, gentlemen, the way from Palestine to Paris is long, and when one comes from Paris to Palestine, as is also likely to be the case shortly, one learns just that which one is given to see outwardly, and that is precious little. These are just fine colonies.

As regards the Administration, however, I shall not express myself so favourably about it. I have no intention of pronouncing an absolute sentence of condemnation upon the entire Administration of Baron Rothschild; I will even expressly acknowledge that there are exceptions in this Administration also; but I must