No. 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…the movement and of eager collaboration in its tasks. These hundreds of thousands, whom, in spite of all the diversities of local conditions, in spite of the fact that no contact has hitherto ever taken place between them, an astonishingly uniform spirit animates, are the living Judaism, and they mean to remain it. The speaker characterised the circles from which the objection to Zionism proceeds. There are, first of all, the Jewish millionaires and milliardaires — fortunately not all of them, but the majority — who use, or misuse, their social relations with the decisive Christian circles in order to impart to them quite false, indeed downright slanderous, notions of Zionism and of those who bear it. Perhaps they are believed, since they are held to be the appointed representatives of the Jewish people. Yet, most gratifyingly, not everywhere. "We have a proof of this, at which I would only lightly hint, that our enemies may not tax us with tactless obtrusiveness. It is no longer a secret that illustrious heads of States take the liveliest interest in the Zionist movement and have deemed it worthy of their favour and grace. It needs no further exposition that a movement which is taken seriously by one of the noblest of rulers, one of the greatest, most far-seeing, most ideal and yet at the same time most practical directors of the destinies of peoples, may no longer be treated by anyone as a negligible quantity." The speaker threw light upon the proceeding of the Protest Rabbis, who, by setting themselves against the holiest strivings of the Jewish people, have forfeited all standing with it; and he then demonstrated what grave wrong the Jewish proletarians and theoretical Socialists commit against themselves and against their people by throwing themselves into the arms of Socialism and, for its sake, disavowing their membership of the Jewish people. Socialism contains impossible Utopias, such as collectivism, which sound Jewish sense will never accept, and an inclination towards revolutionary means, which are repugnant to the conservative instincts of the Jews, who are always and everywhere loyal to the law. But beside this it has also sound and morally lofty ideals, and it is these that make it so attractive to the Jewish proletarians and to many educated Jews. Now, if one looks more closely, one perceives that everything in Socialism that is sound, reasonable, possible, noble, is simply old Jewish ideals, which in the past of the Jewish people were historical reality, and whose revival is precisely the goal of Zionism. Ideally minded Jews must by natural necessity flow over into Zionism, even though they be to-day adherents of Socialism, because the latter, in its view of the world, in its brotherly love, in its demand for social justice, reminds them of immemorial Jewish traditions, the memory of which may have been darkened in the Jewish national soul, yet has never wholly been extinguished. The speaker closed his exposition with an appeal to the Socialist Jews not to expect their salvation from Socialism, but to co-operate in Zionism, of which they might become the most valuable element.
The speech of Dr. Nordau at the festive Commers of the Jewish-national fraternities in Vienna was communicated by us to our readers in abstract. As this abstract naturally does not everywhere coincide with the wording of the speech delivered by Dr. Nordau, Dr. Nordau requests us once more to emphasise that the report given in No. 5 of the "Welt" is not in all its linguistic particulars completely identical with his speech. Through the fact that the Commers speech was rendered in the first person, the appearance might be awakened as though it were a question of a verbally faithful reproduction of it. As this is not the case, Dr. Nordau desires this express statement on the part of the Editorial Office. We gladly fulfil this wish, of course.
The Editors.
The Week.
Vienna, 9 February 1899.
Vienna has had in the past week a "sensational trial" which reaches beyond local interest, because it affords typical enlightenment upon the strategy of the "defence against anti-Semitism." The entire Viennese press has deposited in its columns all the foot-deep sweepings which the private life of an anti-Semitic deputy harboured in its discreet niches. This rubbish, whose chemical composition we do not care to discuss more closely, was with its miasmas to cast Viennese, or rather Austrian, anti-Semitism upon the sick-bed. Such was the intention of the Jew-friendly sheets. It is therefore to be established at the outset that the road along which this "defence" marches out to the combat against anti-Semitism is the most unappetising conceivable. It runs along the gutter and is hemmed on both sides by a long-drawn row of latrines. In this alley the Jews of to-day serve their ideals; here they defend Judaism. Upon a hill of guano they plant the Jewish banner; by stirring about in the turbid waters they rescue the honour of Judaism. That, with this method of combat, a not inconsiderable quantity of the street-matter necessarily clings to their own persons — that they do not observe. Well, de gustibus, as is well known, there is no disputing; but the group of defence-Jewry must not take it amiss of other Jews if they have no real desire to solve the Jewish question upon this sodden, slippery road.
* * *
Well, reasons might no doubt be found which could render plausible the endeavour to solve the Jewish question by scandal trials. Commonplaces might for example be brought forward, à la "the ideal end sanctifies the unclean means," "the physician who would open an abscess must not have squeamish fingers," and the like, and one might let oneself be persuaded, with a conquest of the feeling of disgust, to wade towards the lofty goal, were it not that from the very outset this repugnant road is a road that leads nowhere. What in fact do the Jews want when they lift the round wooden lid from the unflushed interior of some anti-Semitic representative of the people? Do they wish to compromise the deputy in the eyes of the anti-Semites? Possibly! But this method of seeking to get the better of anti-Semitism is wholly senseless. For what will happen when the anti-Semitic electors perceive that their chosen one has uncleannesses about him? One group of the electors — we will not decide whether the larger or the smaller — will, if it does not from the very beginning incredulously cast aside the accusations of the Jews as groundless insinuations, continue in spite of all demonstrable blemishes and defects to hold the deputy in high esteem, to value him and to elect him to the representative body. The defence against anti-Semitism by means of scandal trials will fail, because it does not embarrass the electors that a man of spotted morals has issued from the ballot-urn. Everything has remained as it was, and the Jews have stepped into the mire to no purpose. On the contrary, through the intervention of the Jews anti-Semitism is rendered yet more vulgar. The Jew-hatred of the irritated deputy and of his adherents will necessarily assume ruder, more spiteful forms through a comprehensible vindictiveness, and the supposedly deadly dagger has thus been transformed, in the hand of the defence-Jews, into a spurring goad.
* * *
A second group of anti-Semites — let us say the more decent — will, at the sight of the gangrened places