Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 34 · 25 August 1899
2printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 34

Thirdly, the gathering of the Jews upon the historic soil of their ancient home (lively, long-sustained applause and clapping of hands) in sufficient numbers to be there no longer a reluctantly tolerated minority with inferior rights, but a majority of full human and civic worth. (Renewed lively applause and clapping of hands.) You have judged that this third means is the only worthy one, the only one that promises success, and you have joined yourselves to Zionism, which has set itself the very task of applying this one remedy to the sufferings of the Jewish people. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.)

The picture of the condition of the Jewish people has been fixed by us; the small incidents of the day can alter nothing in it and have therefore no particular significance. It is no longer worthy of us to dwell plaintively and groaning upon such petty single traits. Yesterday workmen in a Bohemian factory town laid waste Jewish shops. To-day our brethren are plundered and stoned in Jassy. On a third day Jews suffer cruelties in Nikolajew. On a fourth, poor pedlars of our race are maltreated in Chicago. What do these excesses prove? That hatred lies in wait for us everywhere? That everywhere only the thin wall of legal order and police regulation protects us against the evil passions of the populace, ever ready to break out? We know this even without the particular proofs. And even if these were to be wanting for a whole year together, it would be without influence upon our judgment of the general situation of the Jewish people. That indeed is what distinguishes us Zionists from the childish, short-sighted pedlars of trifles of our race, who live from hand to mouth, think no further than the day, and are incapable of a far-seeing national policy in the grand style. If once a few months pass without Jews being injured in body and goods by brutal violence, then these senile babes can never do enough with their pleased rubbing of hands and their grateful rolling of eyes; then one hears them exulting in their poor bleating voices: "Thank God! Now it goes well with the Jews! Now their old distress is at an end!"

If, on the contrary, here or there, in some urban centre of civilisation or in a village at the world's end, window panes rattle under a shower of stones and Jewish limbs are broken, then what an outcry there is! Then what a clasping of hands! Then these singular creatures with the mole's eyes and the sparrow's brains (lively merriment) put on an air of amazement passing all self-possession, as though something wholly unexpected had happened for which it was impossible to be prepared. (Lively applause and clapping of hands.)

"Is it conceivable! Such barbarism in our time? Why, it cries to heaven!"

We Zionists do not lull ourselves in blissful hope when for a whole year no Jews have been baited, maltreated and plundered at any spot upon the globe; but neither do we utter cries of surprise when deeds of violence are committed upon our brethren. If these do not occur, that is a wonder for which we are thankful from the bottom of our hearts; for the suffering of every single Jew touches us nearly, even though we do not put our pain upon the stage. (Lively applause.) But if the deeds of violence do occur, then we record them with bitterness, yet without astonishment, as the necessary consequence of the situation which we have clearly discerned and, suffering self-deception no longer, laid bare.

This is a point which a report upon the general situation of the Jewish people must touch again and again.

It seems to me needful, therefore, to illuminate it thoroughly for once, so that in coming years neither I nor my successor in the office of reporting may be compelled to dwell upon it any longer:

You know that geology has sought to explain the formation of the earth's surface by two opposing theories, which are termed briefly the volcanic and the Neptunian. According to the volcanic theory, seas and continents, mountain ranges and strata of rock owe their origin to fearful upheavals, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, the sudden sinking and emergence of portions of the earth — catastrophes which occur suddenly at intervals of hundreds of thousands or of millions of years and at one blow alter the countenance of the earth.

The Neptunian theory, on the contrary, assumes that lands and seas and all their details are the work of enduring forces of nature which are noiselessly yet unceasingly at work, which at every moment produce only the very tiniest changes, but which after thousands of years have quietly and evenly built up continents and mountains and worn them down again, have deepened seas and filled them up. The volcanic theory is the more melodramatic; it makes of the earth's history a prodigious spectacular piece, and such a piece is always sure of the applause of the gallery (merriment). The Neptunian theory is the less theatrical, but it is the more convincing for serious minds practised in observing the ordinary procedure of nature.

Among those who have to pass judgment upon Jewish history in past, present and future you will likewise find representatives of the volcanic and of the Neptunian theory.

The former, the Vulcanists, attach importance only to the occasional great acts of violence against the Jews. For them the history of the Jewish people is exhausted in the history of the Jewish catastrophes. For them it strides from the destruction of the Temple to the massacres of the Crusades, from the expulsion out of England and France to the driving forth from Spain, from the butcheries of Chmielniecky to the bloody persecutions of the early eighties. The Neptunists, on the other hand — and to this class I reckon myself — do not ascribe the same importance to the catastrophes, however fearful they may have been, and do not recognise them as the sole, or even as the principal, forces which shape the more recent history of the Jews.

For us it is the ordinary conditions which surround us evenly and enduringly that are the influences which shape the destiny of the Jewish people.

All nations, even the most glorious and the most powerful, have in their past grievous misfortunes, upheavals, civil wars, crushing defeats, which were at times so fearful that recovery from them seemed impossible. Yet in the long run these did them no harm, and did not check the upward march of their brilliant fortunes.

Why? Because between the blows of fate there always lay centuries, or at the least decades, of quiet