Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 38 · 22 September 1899
14printed page
scan 18 of 20

Page 14. — „Die ✡ Welt“ — No. 38.

Not in the Bible, then, do we find this social spirit of the Jews which is based upon huckstering; on the contrary, the spirit of the Bible is decidedly anti-mercantile. Christianity made it its own, has not ceased to commend it and, up to a certain degree, to practise it as well, and only later did this spirit, in its essence Jewish, turn against the Jews, who had in part become men of trade, The Christian society had for its device ense et aratro. The two social types became the soldier, who shields the soil, and the peasant, the corner-stone of the nation. The biblical contempt for the middleman was publicly taught, and men had against the Jew a Jewish hatred.

In truth the Christian peoples can have borrowed these prejudices neither from the Greeks nor from the Romans. Among the Greeks tillage was regarded as an occupation befitting slaves, and it was the slaves too who worked the soil. And as for the Romans, Cicero indeed, when he spoke of tillage, said: „There is nothing more worthy of a free man“,*) yet he preferred to engage in speculations along with the politicians and to acquire shares in financial companies. Cato likewise wrote „that one can bestow no greater praise upon a man than to say of him that he is a skilful husbandman and a good planter“,**) and nevertheless he lent money at 50% and, as one of the most hard-hearted of masters, let his slaves perish upon the clod. The people, however, was a society of money-brokers and of sharers in the distributions of corn.

If we take France as the type among the modern Catholic nations — for the Protestant nations, which in the meantime were brought up in the reading of the Jewish scriptures, have known how to emancipate themselves through free inquiry — then we shall see that it has always lived in this social spirit of the Bible and of Judaism. As an antisemite one might say that it is judaized; but we shall show at once that precisely in this respect no one is more judaized than the antisemite with his essentially agrarian and — in theory at least — anti-mercantile disposition.

The French statesmen, political economists and moralists have preserved the patriarchal spirit of the ancient Jews. „Tillage and pasturage are the nourishers of France,“ said Olivier de Serres and Sully; and the latter even refused, since he wished to favour tillage alone, to promote the planting of mulberry trees and the silk industry. Antoine de Moret-Chrestien, who desired the equal encouragement of the crafts and of tillage, committed with this demand nothing less than a bold deed.

The mercantilism of Colbert passed for something abominable, and the adherents of the agrarian protective-tariff policy, such as Bois-Guillebert, combated it fiercely. Colbert became, for the feeling of the people, a disagreeable, almost anti-French personage, and a truly national school of political economy first arose in France at the time when the school of Quesnay and of the Physiocrats was founded.

The conception of Quesnay and of his disciples was a dogmatic and scientific transposition of the Jewish and Christian conception of world policy; only that these men, instead of being democrats, were aristocratic agrarians, since they set out from the same thought which Fontenelle once expressed: „If I had my hand full of truths, I would not open it for the people“. In this, moreover, they were of one mind with the whole eighteenth century, whose writers and philosophers wrote and thought only for the privileged,

According to Quesnay*) the nation is formed of three classes: of the productive class of the husbandmen, of the class of the proprietors, that is to say the possessors pure and simple, and of the unproductive class, which is composed of the tradesmen and men of commerce. A realm devoted to tillage, that was the dream of Quesnay: „May the ruler and the nation“, said he, „never let it out of sight, that the soil is the sole source of riches, and that tillage multiplies them.“**) He praised Sully, „that great minister. who, in order to procure revenues for the king and the nation and to maintain the power of the State, desired none but peasants, vine-dressers and shepherds“. Naturally political power too was to belong only to the possessors of land and soil. „He who possesses no land and soil,“ wrote Turgot, „could know only through a feeling, an opinion, a happy prejudice out of childhood, that he has a fatherland“. More plainly and with greater harshness Mably said: „Only the men who possess a patrimony have a fatherland“. That meant excluding the poor from the community, and that was not only the disposition of the Physiocrats, but of all the pseudo-democratic philosophers of the eighteenth century.

One finds this view, that only the man who possesses soil has a fatherland, again among the antisemites of to-day; for that reason they deny to the Jew the title of citizen.

We have just seen. how through the Physiocrats the biblical view has been altered. At the end of the 18th century and during the first years of the 19th, it was the teachings of the English political economists, of Smith and others, which developed at the time of the beginning and the growth of industry.**) From the year 1834 onward, in the epoch of the great expansion of English industry, the Christian political economists in France felt, however, the necessity of returning to the sound, the revealed doctrines, to the doctrines of the Bible. Men praised anew tillage, „the solid foundation of all national prosperity,“ they formed a „Religious Association for the Progress of Tillage in France“, a society at whose head stood the Duke of Montmorency and whose purpose it was „to bring husbandry under the influence of the principles and of the practical exercise of the Catholic religion“. These teachings found defenders such as de Villeneuve-Bargemont, who published a treatise upon Christian political economy in which he said: „Of all the activities to which man can give himself in order to secure his existence and his happiness, the most upright, the one most suited to a just distribution of wealth, the occupation least subject to the disastrous vicissitudes in the activity of labour and in the level of wages, at the same time that which in the happiest manner maintains the equilibrium of the population, which finally was bestowed by Providence upon men first of all as at once a trial and a consolation, is indisputably the occupation of tillage, that is to say, the working of the soil itself, in order to obtain foodstuffs or the first raw materials. The French and Italian political economists of the 18th century, who regard the earth as the source of all riches, have recognized a great truth, which moreover religion has long since proclaimed“.

*) Cicero: De officiis. **) Cato: De re rustica.

*) Economic Table. (Tableau économique.) **) General Maxim. (Maxime générale,)