Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 50 · 14 December 1900
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 50


(continued from page 1)

…the end of the last century there were at times rich Jews in the Central and Eastern European lands, but never rich Jewish families. An upstart could quickly acquire a great fortune, but there is hardly an example of his having been able to bequeath it to his children, much less to his grandchildren.

Such a legal and economic condition was insufferable, and it is intelligible that our forefathers made the utmost exertions to obtain a secure right of residence. The "Court factors," "Schladlanim," or army contractors leaned upon the favour of rulers well disposed towards them, in order to break the intolerance of Jew-hating municipal administrations and to force for themselves the right of settlement in the towns closed against them. I recall the struggles of Wertheimer, Court factor to Charles VI., with Pressburg and the Zipser towns, and the still more famous struggles of Cerfbeer, army contractor to Louis XVI., with Strasburg. More rarely did they seek, through the influence of the landed nobility, to wring concessions from the Crown, as in the case of the Jews who, after their expulsion from Vienna, were received by Prince Dietrichstein and by Count Johann Pálffy. (1670.)

The struggle of all the Jewish communities for rights of settlement had yielded various results when the French Revolution broke out. Here the Jews were permitted to dwell in certain towns, but residence in other towns and in the open country was forbidden them. There they might dwell everywhere, but nowhere acquire landed property. In one State the secondary schools and the universities, the guilds, certain branches of trade were closed to them; in another they might at least study medicine and philosophy, follow a handicraft and deal in all wares. The Revolution altered these conditions at a stroke. It established equality before the law for all the inhabitants of the land, and wherever the French came they threw down the ghetto walls and raised the Jews whom they found there to the rank of full citizens. But when Napoleon had been overcome by the united forces of reaction in Europe, then everywhere, save in France, men sought to restore the old conditions. Wholly this was indeed not possible, for the French period had created a moral atmosphere from which no one in Europe could withdraw himself, and which did not permit the complete disfranchisement of an element of the population against which no definite offences could be alleged. Meanwhile men did whatever they in any way could to press the Jews down again into their pre-revolutionary legal position.

Two decades of comparative freedom and equality and the example of French Jewry had wrought deep changes in the Jewish soul. The Jew would no longer be a pariah. He gave up without pain his old mystical ideals of Messianic redemption and replaced them by an intelligible, more tangible ideal — legal equality with his Christian neighbour. His national policy was now directed to the attainment of emancipation, and to obtain it no means seemed to him too unworthy, no self-abasement too intolerable.

Between the endeavours of the Jews of the XVIIIth century to obtain the abolition of the legal restrictions upon their freedom of movement and of calling, and the efforts of the Jews of the XIXth century to beg for political equality, there exists, beneath a superficial appearance of similarity, a harsh and wholly irreconcilable contrast. The Jews of the XVIIIth century demanded the right to be permitted to be Jews in security and freedom; the Jews of the XIXth century begged the favour of being able to strip off their Judaism conveniently and without attracting notice. Out of this contrast are explained all the developments of Jewish history in the last generations.

Emancipation gave the Jews not merely the civil rights of free movement, of landed property, the capacity of free choice of a calling, of the free joint use of all State and communal institutions; it gave them also the political rights, that is to say, a share in that power of the State which the people exercises in a constitutional country. For the Jews who wished to remain Jews and to develop as Jews into free, cultivated, well-to-do men, only the civil rights were of importance, for they strove not after dominion, but after quiet. For those Jews, on the other hand, who cared little or nothing for their Judaism, the political rights had the greater significance, for they permitted them to step out of the circle of Judaism and of Jewish interests, to intervene decisively in the affairs of the State, that is to say, of the Christian majority, and to strive after State offices and dignities, that is to say, after a share in the power of the State.

This striving did not and does not in any way benefit the Jewish people in its totality, but at most the individual place-hunter himself. It compels the Jewish State politician to suppress in himself everything that marks him as a Jew, that is, as a type differing from the majority of the people, and therefore to divest himself of his Judaism with desperate exertion; and it violently goads on the anti-Semitism of the majority, since that majority will indeed condescend to endure the Jew as a neighbour, but will not suffer him as a master over itself. Assuredly, as a master. For according to the monarchical conception, which has not been overcome even in the so-called republics, every servant of the State, be he employed in the administration, in the army, or in the judicature, represents the sovereign and exercises a portion, entrusted to him, of the highest power over the subjects. He commands and the subjects must obey. But historical experience teaches that peoples never willingly let themselves be governed by men whom they do not recognise as their own flesh and blood. Even conquerors can lay the sword out of their hand only when the governed no longer feel them to be intruders, when they have in a manner naturalised and adopted them. The Jews are no conquerors, and they are nowhere recognised by the majority as its own flesh and blood. They must therefore infallibly arouse the most violent resistance against themselves if they raise the claim to exercise governing power over the majority, unless it should succeed with them to deceive the majority as to their Jewish descent. The Jew who will make full use of his political rights must begin by concealing, and where possible strangling, the Jew within him. A Jewish national policy which works towards the attainment of the political rights is therefore a policy of national ruin, of national suicide, a denial and an abolition of itself. The contemptible little Jewish communal sheets, which are such faithful mirrors of the degradation and characterlessness of decaying Judaism, record with emotion every appointment of a Jew to a State office. The weak-heads who write these notices do not know that every time they are hailing with high delight an apostasy from Judaism. For