Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 14 · 3 April 1901
14printed page
scan 14 of 32

14

The Social-Economic System of Revision according to the Ancient Jewish Constitution.

By Dr. Alfred Nossig. (Berlin.)

I.

In a work now in course of publication, which contains an attempt to develop, upon the basis of an inductive treatment of the social and economic material of fact, a purified, rational Socialism, I remark: ¹)

“My Socialism goes back to older sources, in which the catchword is indeed not yet named, but in which the essence of a just and reasonable order of society was grasped with more far-sighted and happier insight than in the ‘Communist Manifesto.’ In the ancient, not in the modern Bible of Socialism I found, if not the solution, yet the key, the introduction to the solution of the economic problem. Here, and in the political writings of the great Greek philosopher, are indicated, in my conviction, the general principles by which the social reform of to-day also — for all the far more complicated nature of its task — ought to let itself be guided. In those portions of their work which endure the fiery ordeal of criticism and possess lasting value, the modern theorists of Socialism have accordingly leaned, consciously or unconsciously, upon the views of those ancient thinkers; and their most excellent achievements, as for example the investigation of the laws of surplus labour and of concentration, form scientific confirmations of economic observations from which their antique predecessors set out. But there, where the moderns take up a standpoint deviating in principle, criticism almost regularly convicts them of a misapprehension of human nature and of the laws of development of the social fabric; there the socialist doctrine, if it is to find general recognition, must be subjected to a purification, not after the word, but in the spirit of those greater knowers of mankind. ²)

* * *

Those great principles which, springing from the experience of history, ought to be decisive for the design of all future organisations, may be formulated as follows:

  1. Neither the free system nor the bound system is a social-economic panacea. In general the fabric of society cannot be built up enduringly upon the ground of either one of these principles. Out of the one the other always grows by nature: out of constraint and collective organisation there arise freedom and individual isolation; out of freedom — compulsion and collective regulation. In fact both principles have always subsisted side by side. This observation, which is corroborated also by the experience of antiquity, leads to the recognition that the social structure must reasonably be based upon a mixture of the systems, in such wise that the one principle is wisely tempered and beneficently supplemented by the other.

  2. Even this mixture, which in practice has always come about of itself, by no means guarantees enduringly satisfactory conditions; social and economic development leads in the end always to intolerable abuses, which can be removed only by a fresh intervention of the governing power, by a fresh regulation of relations. For property alone can be made approximately equal, but never the nature of men and the destiny of their lives. The more capable in acquisition, the craftier, the more thrifty, and those favoured by incalculable accidents, will always, through material success, crush the rest, and the inequalities will at length swell to the monstrous. Hence the regulating interventions must be periodic, even as the natural development of economic life leads periodically to abuses; in other words, the periodic sanitation of the social organism must belong to the system.

  3. Upon this condition, but indeed only upon the observance of it, the violent development which proceeds from the blind class struggle may be replaced by a conscious and foreseeing guidance of society. For it is not the revolution that is the essential thing in the natural processes of adjustment, but the reorganisation which follows upon the revolution. A system which makes revolution in a manner a measure of state, the basis of an unstable, ever-renewed order, does away with the necessity of those bloody collapses of societies. And the regulation of social and economic life for the securing of tolerable, approximately just conditions is not in itself hopeless, as history teaches; only it cannot enduringly defy time and the natural laws of development. But from the moment when this weakness is systematically remedied, conscious regulation becomes sovereign. ³)

* * *

It remains now to furnish the proof that these principles, which ought to light the way of a rejuvenated rational Socialism, are in fact already contained in the ancient Jewish constitution.

Two things would follow from this proof. It would be shown that the great mission which the most enlightened elements of Judaism have again and again brought to the remembrance of their race of thinkers and martyrs — to fight for reason and justice, to hasten the rise of a humane social organisation among all peoples and to point out the main outlines of it — has not been without result, and that a deep insight speaks out of the words of the prophet: “Out of Zion shall go forth the law.” (Isa. 2, 3.)

It would further become clear that a future Jewish State could borrow the ground-lines of its social and economic organisation from the traditional national legislation, and that upon its codifiers there would fall only the task of carrying forward the legislative work of their forefathers in a modern sense.

To this proof I have devoted a special and as yet unpublished work, from which I take what here follows:

II.

Though the Jewish legislators completely comprehended the high social and economic significance of individual benevolence, though they treat it as an indispensable factor of the general prosperity, yet the humane disposition of the well-to-do citizens is not the sole guarantee which they give to the poor; the moral precept is not the exclusive form in which they come to the help of the needy; and the continuous alleviation of economic sufferings by means of voluntary gifts by no means exhausts the system of adjusting economic differences which we find in the ancient Jewish constitution.

It cannot be urged with sufficient emphasis: the economic system of the Jews rests, like the political, upon a mixture of principles; in this field also the ancient Jewish law applies no single pattern to cover the manifold social necessities.

Beside individual charity there appears the care of the State, the public measure; beside the moral precept — legal compulsion; beside the unbroken and continuous mitigation of economic contrasts — the more radical equalisation of the conditions of property from epoch to epoch.

The ordinances of which we speak form the chief content of the law of the seventh year; on their account this year is also designated the year of release.

In another connection the significance of the seventh year for the preservation of the fruitfulness of the natural sources of existence shall be set forth. Here we would examine its bearing upon the regulation of social and property relations.

The Jewish law points with full clearness to the fact that the ordinances of the year of release are wholly indispensable for the adjustment of economic contrasts. For it runs in the introduction to them: “There shall indeed be no beggar among you . . . . .; but only if thou keepest all the commandments which I command thee this day.” ⁴)


¹) “Revision des Socialismus”, Berlin, 1901 (Akadem. Verlag für sociale Wissenschaften), Vol. I, Prolegomena, p. X.

²) Henry George already, the father of the modern land-reform movement, comprehended the imperishable content of the social-political legislation of the Bible and its significance for the solution of the social question of the present. Compare his tract “Moses, a lecture” (Boston, 1897), which proves that the author of “Progress and Poverty” found the impulse to his own ideas and to his activity in the Pentateuch.

³) “Revision des Socialismus”, Prolegomena, page XXVII ff.

⁴) Deut. XV. 4—5.