Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 24 · 14 June 1901
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 24.

(continued from page 1)

…genius, but not the millions. Yet the millions will come. If only all the rest were as easy to accomplish. For Dr. Herzl has set himself a task whose difficulties stand unique in history. Mazzini united Italy again, but the Italians were upon their native soil. A national rebirth by way of emigration is an altogether novel problem. Yet emigration has always formed a part of the Jewish ideal in the Golus. "Next year in Jerusalem!"

Nearly 250 years ago sober European Jews, in the belief in the Messianic mission of Sabbatai Zewi, sold their business and tied up their knapsacks in order to make pilgrimage to Jerusalem. How wholly different it is to-day. Dr. Herzl does not adorn himself with the pose of the prophet; he calls upon you no longer to paralyse the hand of Providence by sloth and timidity. Not manna, but manly courage is Dr. Herzl's motto. Not dreaming, but work. Let no rich Jew fear that he will be dragged off to Jerusalem. Jewry offers a sorry spectacle since it has basked in the light of freedom. Dignity and firm resolve seem to have wholly vanished from Jewish life. The practical people have gained the upper hand, and woe to the people that lets itself be led by them upon the rein. Dr. Herzl seeks a fairer lot for his people. Dr. Herzl's idea is meant not only for the poor Jews with their lack of the barest necessities, but also for the rich with their lack of ideals; nay, still more, for the whole great world, which it seeks to raise once more out of the barbarism into which it has sunk back, up into the bright heights of idealism. Never, since Rome perished of its inner rottenness, has the world so urgently needed the uplifting spectacle of a movement which, free from corruption, strives towards the ideals of the noblest humanity. Whatever Doctor Herzl's fate may be, he has graven his name in indelible letters into Jewish history. To his name attaches the glory of having raised the call for courage and self-confidence at a time when the Jewish people, enslaved and oppressed by others, threatens to sink into scepticism and self-contempt.

*

Dr. Herzl's Speech.

If it be true that God gave man speech in order to conceal his thoughts, then this holds good for me in particular of my English speech. Nature has denied me everything that belongs to the delivering of an English address in public, and above all the accent. And I am not one of those happy people who do not know how bad their pronunciation is. I know it, alas.

Now I have no wish whatever to conceal my thoughts when I speak to you, although there are also circumstances in which, in the interest of the cause, one cannot say everything. There is a measure in things, and I must the more readily observe it to-day and in this place, since it is a neutral place. Here are both comrades and opponents of my views, and I feel it my first duty to mock no one who has sat down in friendship at table with me. I accepted your invitation with a particularly heartfelt gratitude precisely because I know that I have opponents in the Maccabaeans' Club, and that this opposition stops at the ideas and does not extend to the person. When five years ago you distinguished me by appointing me an honorary member, I had already taken part in a good deal with which you may afterwards not have agreed. I would not now commit the indiscretion of seeing in your invitation of to-day a subsequent approval of all my speeches and actions; but perhaps I do not go too far in assuming that you still hold me worthy to be your honorary member.

There is nothing of which I could be prouder, when I consider the character and purpose of your Club: "To raise the moral and intellectual level of the Jews."

In these last years I have often had the pain of being attacked by Jews, evidently for no other reason than that I concerned myself with Jewish affairs.

Had I occupied myself with Chinese affairs, the Chinese would have attacked me. To be sure, I am somewhat better entitled to Jewish matters. But, as is well known, no one asks about that. Even though I therefore understand the attacks, I have nevertheless cause to wonder at their vehemence and injustice, and I feel the need to complain of it among my own kind. With that, however, I close these remarks already, for I will not cloud the peace of our banquet even by the recollection of the strife of the last years.

On the contrary, it is my honest wish that the battle-axe between Jews and Jews be buried now and for ever. In order to be able to say this, the opportunity of speaking in the Maccabaeans' Club was especially welcome to me. The movement to which I devote my modest powers is not only dependent upon winning the sympathies of all Jewish societies; it is also fitted for that as no other is.

In the non-Jewish world it has frequently aroused astonishment that we could find opponents among the Jews at all, so natural and self-evident did that appear which we proposed for the solution of the Jewish question.

I will readily admit that in the presentation of our cause we have committed many a grave error; that we were too indistinct in speech, too clumsy in action; that we did not acknowledge with gratitude enough the merits of those who, before us or at the same time as ourselves, were active for the interests of Jewry.

All these misunderstandings and differences must, however, as a matter of course come to rest at a moment when we possibly stand before a turn in the destiny of the Jewish people.

My honoured friends and opponents! You will readily understand how hard it is for me to speak precisely upon that point whose discussion you now expect of me. There is a danger if I say too much, and a danger also if I say too little. I have had many an unfavourable experience with the interpretations put upon my words. My conscience is quite clear of having awakened deceptive hopes among the masses of our adherents, and yet this too has been cast up against me. I have never promised miracles, but have only pointed to self-help as the way of redemption.

I said: "Reckon not upon help from strangers, reckon not either upon the benefactors or upon the softening of the stones; for the benefactors give at most humiliating alms, and the stones do not grow soft. Upon itself must a people that would rise set its whole reckoning."

In this fashion, as is well known, we began our toilsome road. There were bad moments and good — moments in which one despairs, and moments in which one hopes again. It was in such a good moment, in the autumn of 1898, that I said here in London to my brethren in the East End that I the realisation of our