No. 27. — "Die Welt" — Page 9
(continued from page 8)
…citizens were to be classified. To the first were to be reckoned those Jews who adopt European enlightenment, who occupy themselves with handicrafts and agriculture, and so forth; these Jews should accordingly enjoy various rights and privileges. The remaining Jews, on the other hand, who persist in their fanaticism and in their suspect occupations, were to be regarded as useless citizens, and their obstinacy was to be punished by various restrictions: these uneducated fanatics should, as hitherto, not be permitted to dwell in the villages or upon the frontier; the holding of public offices should not be allowed them; for them the penal laws of the earlier period of compulsory assimilation were to remain in undiminished force. A proposal was even brought forward that, after the example of Austria, fifteen years after the opening of the Jewish government schools no young Jew should be granted permission to marry who could produce no school certificate; the "enlightened," on the contrary, were to enjoy this agreeable right wholly without restriction.
"In this way" — the memorandum concludes — "by bringing all the parts of this project into accord with the fundamental principle of the reformation of the Jewish people, and by undertaking compulsory measures besides, one may hope to attain the aim of the government, if not very rapidly, yet quite surely, and thereby to reform a numerous class of citizens for the good of the Empire."
Count Woronzow, one of the most enlightened and most influential statesmen of that time, opposed this project with decision and openly declared his opinion to the government that such a division of the citizens into useful and useless was unjust and would moreover not lead to the desired goal. In his memorandum, "most humbly submitted" to the Emperor Nicholas I., he writes, among other things, the following: "I venture to believe that this measure is injurious also to the interest of the State, and all too severe. On the one hand, hundreds of thousands of industrious hands will be withdrawn from their activity, which is of great utility to the petty trade and the small industries and which there is now no possibility of replacing, nor will there be any for a long time to come; on the other hand, the lamentations of so enormously great a number of unfortunates as will be visited by the sad consequences of these measures will serve for the condemnation of our government both among ourselves and beyond the frontiers of Russia."
"I venture to believe," he writes in another place, "that the general appellation 'useless,' applied to several hundred thousands of human beings who by the ordinance of the Most High have lived in the Empire from time immemorial, is in and for itself severe and unjust." Count Woronzow recommended that no new compulsory measures whatever be applied in regard to the Jews, since they were already restricted in their rights in any case, but that provision be made for the opening of many useful schools, which "will draw favourable consequences after them and will in any event cost the Empire far less than the measures now proposed." Such liberal opinions were uttered by other enlightened Christians also, as well as by the influential Jewish bearers of culture of that time. But the time when these philanthropic intentions could find their way to official recognition on the part of the government had not yet come. This one thing only was attained, that the appellation "useless" was replaced by a more courteous one, "those who perform no productive labour," and that the reprisals were somewhat mitigated; the complete abolition of compulsory assimilation was, however, not attained, and therefore neither could it be attained that the whole of Russian Jewry should look forward to the endeavours of the government with full confidence. In the imaginings of the pious Jews the measures of the government still retained the character of "גזרות"; these pious ones continued carefully to go out of the way of "enlightenment," and the government did not cease to persecute the obstinate, until the time of the sixties dawned, a time whose historic rôle is of enormously great moment both in the life of the Russian parent people and in that of the Russian Jews. Before we pass on to this period, however, we shall seek in the next article to answer the question why in fact the Russian governments of those days, which bore themselves so indifferently towards the question of the cultural elevation of the Russian parent people, manifested so lively an interest in the enlightenment of the Jews.
(To be continued.)
Letters from Paris.
By A. Ludvipol. II.*)
A contributor to the "Univers Israélite," who signs his articles with the cipher R. T., has felt the need of taking the Jewish millionaires under his protection against the wicked Zionists. He writes in one of the latest numbers of the "Univers":
"These Zionists propose to us that we separate ourselves voluntarily from our fellow-citizens of another faith. They seek to persuade us that the Jews will never be treated by the Christians as equals, and that it would be better for us to become unfaithful to the land which our forefathers have inhabited for centuries and to unfurl the purely Jewish banner.
Now when the majority of the French Jews made known their aversion to these endeavours, our good Zionists thundered against the Jewish financial aristocracy, which thinks of nothing but its money, and against the idle and corrupt bourgeoisie. They branded, not without a semblance of justification, certain faults which come to light among the rich Israelites. Naturally, in order to give the attacks more weight and to justify the flaming tirades, it was necessary to work with generalisations. This was the surest means of meeting beforehand the protests which could not fail to come. After our Jewish nationalists had reviled the mass of the French Jews, they turned to the rest of Jewry, whom they called upon to leave the faithless French co-religionists to themselves and to ally themselves with the Russians and Roumanians in order to return to Palestine."
We for our part have truly nothing against it if M. R. T. remains behind with the "faithless."
The president of the Central Committee of the "Alliance israélite universelle," M. Narcisse Leven, has addressed the following letter to the founders of the "Deutscher Hilfsverein," of which I spoke in my last letter:
"We are inclined to receive in friendly fashion all new institutions which have in view the welfare of our co-religionists, to accept their co-operation and to devote ours to them. In the history of the sufferings of Jewry there has been no crisis in which the 'Alliance' has not sent forth its appeal to every force, to every kind of readiness for sacrifice. Are we not at this very moment working in union with the committees and communities of all lands to lessen the frightful distress of the Roumanian and Russian Jews?
If your work desires nothing else than to give this aid a greater extension, more coherence and system, then it has our assent without reserve. Yet on reading your communication we could not but reflect that you also, nay, chiefly, intend to occupy yourselves with the moral situation of the Jews of Europe and Asia. Now, that is a very delicate matter, for which we should like to claim your quite particular attention. It is a task to which, as you know, the 'Alliance' has devoted itself these 42 years. Supported by the Jews of all lands, it carries on this work with a perseverance and a success which you too must acknowledge. It carries it on in community with the Israelites of Germany. These have been its fellow-workers since the founding of the 'Alliance,' and they have contributed mightily to its development. Their share is a large one in all that the 'Alliance' has undertaken against intolerance and religious persecutions, in all
*) Cf. No. 26.