Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 50.
(continued from page 1)
...rendered fit and ready for a work of civilisation that human material for which we are preparing the homestead and which we need for it; there are bred in it qualities which are indispensable for its high destiny to come. It is from this point of view, and not on account of its agitational value, which however I do not underrate, that I recommend the economic action of the present. Its means will indeed be, as Farbstein says, palliative means — nothing more and nothing less; but if their application takes place with the intention I have just indicated, and with the circumspection which our delicate conception of the exposed position of Zionism demands, we shall have no cause to fear that the masses will grow mistrustful later on. It is not a headlong plunging at any price that I shall advocate; on the contrary, it is precisely in the case of the several proposed means that I shall seek strictly to mark out the limits of their effect and of their applicability.
And here, in the discussion of the several economic remedies, Doctor Farbstein will often find me at his side so far as scepticism towards their healing power is concerned. In particular the misgivings set forth in the essay referred to with respect to productive co-operative societies and consumers' unions are in many points shared by me. As regards the consumers' unions, which already in the debate at the Fourth Congress met with an unfavourable criticism on the part of the delegate Wiener, I associate myself both with his observations and with those made by our comrade Farbstein. They may be allowed to hold good for certain places, if one regards them merely as savings associations without any greater social-educational and social-political value.
As regards the productive co-operative societies, thorough studies of the material available upon institutions of that kind (non-Jewish ones) have made me sceptical. Of Jewish productive co-operative societies there are scarcely any reports, and I address the request to those of our comrades who possess, or are able to obtain, knowledge of the existence and of the successes of such establishments founded from the Jewish side, that they communicate their experiences to me, for the clearing up of the question, before the Congress, or in the discussion at the Congress. In any case the creation of such productive co-operative societies presupposes the organisation of the sale of the products. We shall have seriously to examine whether we are equal to that organisation, when the vast multitude of Jewish handicraftsmen in Russia and Galicia shall enter upon co-operative production.
Farbstein's adverse judgment upon the advantage of credit banks for handicraft and small industry, both in general and for the specifically Jewish conditions, undergoes a correction quite as much through the favourable reports which are at hand from Russia upon the small (non-Jewish) credit banks as through the communications concerning the successes of such credit institutions as have already been set up from the Jewish and the Zionist side. The professional organisations also — trade unions, associations of journeymen, with their serviceable social institutions such as sick funds, invalidity funds, the registry for work and insurance against unemployment — may already to-day be recommended on the ground of a practice which, if not long, has yet been repeated in many forms and in various places.
A strengthening, or even a mere preservation, of the middleman's trade appears to me, as it does to Farbstein, to be out of the question; but a sudden and brutal annihilation of it should nevertheless be guarded against.
With credit co-operatives and professional organisations something beneficial may still be done here. Here, too, one must bear in mind the domestic industry planned for Galicia by the Order of Bnei Berith as a substitute for economic positions that are being lost or are threatened, although upon this point I should, as a hygienist, have to demand certain safeguards. The centre of gravity of our solicitude lies, however, in the influencing of the education and the choice of calling of the Jewish youth, of which it will perhaps be necessary to speak at the coming Congress more fully than has hitherto been the case.
It will be seen that in the main the points of the programme drawn up at the Fourth Congress will again appear this year in the proposals for economic elevation. Only that this time there is added the retrospect upon a year of fruitful exertion in our field.
I shall have to disappoint those who expect from the introductory report upon economic elevation a consideration of special territorial and local conditions and requirements. Apart from the fact that the report would have to undergo an unusual expansion through a comprehensive treatment of these points of view, it may surely be expected of the representatives of the several Landsmannschaften that they should supplement the rapporteur's guiding statements in the discussion by reports which, drawn from their own observation, have a more living effect than deductions which have sprung from a study of the literature, however thorough. To this I may add that, since at the Congress I intend also to discuss the organisational side of the question and to assign to the several country organisations a considerable share in the carrying out of the practical social work, the Congress will have fully done its duty when it has sufficiently cleared up and settled the questions of principle.
They were hours full of sadness in which I sought to penetrate the mournful material of fact concerning the economic misery of our scattered people; I closed the study with the anxious question: Shall we succeed in supporting the decrepit body of the people until healing awaits it upon the soil of its fathers? And the answer which, after mature reflection, I was obliged to give myself, ran: Let us try!
The Fifth Congress.
Order of Business:
1st Day (Thursday):
A) Morning sitting, 10 o'clock.
- Opening of the Congress by the President of the Actions Committee.
- Election of the Credentials Committee, of the Congress Bureau and of the remaining committees.
- Standing orders.
- Report of the Actions Committee: a) General part. Rapporteur, the architect Oskar Marmorek. b) Cassa report. Rapporteur Dr. O. Kokesch.
B) Afternoon sitting, 4 o'clock. 5. Discussion upon the report.