Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 2 · 10 January 1902
8printed page
scan 8 of 16

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 2.

Sharp debates arise over the question of the biennial Congress, which attains such dimensions that the sitting must be closed at half-past three in the morning without its being settled.

*

Fourth Day. Sixth Sitting. Opening: Sunday, 10 o'clock in the forenoon. President: Dr. Max Nordau.

Dr. Schalit reports on the draft of the A.-C. for the creation of a Jewish National Fund, known from No. 2 of "Die Welt."

The discussion on this report lasts, with a pause of ten minutes, until towards 4 o'clock in the afternoon, and at times becomes very heated; now and again votes follow upon votes. It is censured from more than one side, chiefly by Doctor Bodenheimer and Mr. Lurie, that the report of the Actions-Comité offers no sufficient guarantees for securing the National Fund, since nothing is provided for the creation of a juridical person. The Lurie motion is to strike the report of the Actions-Comité off the order of the day altogether, and to charge a commission with drawing up the new statute for the next Congress. Against these motions President Dr. Herzl makes the sharpest opposition, for they mean the postponement of a highly important question for at least a year; the National Fund must be created just as the Bank has been created, notwithstanding the possibility of some errors. The misgivings concerning the securing of the property through the creation of a juridical person were removed by a motion of Dr. Kokesch (Vienna), which motion reads:

1. The Actions-Comité is charged to take care that the legal basis of a juridical person be created for the National Fund by the next Congress.

2. The Congress elects a commission from among the jurists of each country to study this question; this commission is to come to an understanding with the Actions-Comité and to take up its work within the next three months.

3. The Actions-Comité is recommended to obtain the creation of the juridical person for the National Fund in the Canton of Basle-City.

4. By the immediate adoption of the draft laid before it by the Actions-Commission, and through the National Fund thus coming at once into being, it is not excluded — rather it is reserved — that the provisions shall be adapted to the several legislations of the various States."

Dr. Herzl now puts these motions to the vote. On a preliminary question put to the Congress, it declares itself unanimously for the immediate creation of a Jewish national property. The vote is now to show whether the Congress demands the safeguards desired by the representatives of the sharper tone, or deems the guarantee of the statute, with the supplementary motion of Dr. Kokesch, sufficient. The manner of voting is discussed in a lengthy debate on procedure. The final vote gives 105 votes for the motions of the Actions-Comité against 85 votes for the motion of Dr. Bodenheimer. — The announcement of this result is received by the Congress with demonstrative jubilation.

Immediately after the vote individual delegates hastened to the tribune to pay in larger sums for the National Fund. Dr. Bodenheimer announces the handing over of 2000 Marks from a Heidelberg society which, at the suggestion of Professor Schapira, has been collecting for the Fund since the First Congress.

At 3 o'clock the debate on the Organisation Statute is continued without a pause. As the speeches on the separate paragraphs, by their length, lead one to expect that the time allotted will not suffice for the points still unsettled,

Delegate Lilien moves: That the Congress take an additional day for its proceedings. (Carried almost unanimously.)

Against the Tschlenow motion, Delegate Cowen proposes that the Manager and the Directors of the Bank shall not be required to attend the annual conferences.

Delegate Director Wolffsohn: I believe a sharp line must be drawn between Congress and Bank. The Directors are present at the Congress not in that capacity, but as Zionist delegates of Zionist groups. To the annual conferences, he thought, the Directors might well be invited as expert men of like mind, but not be compelled by the Congress to come. They will always count invitation and attendance an honour.

In the debate on the possibility of dividing a Country Federation, the Russian speakers stand for unconditional unity.

At 6 o'clock the sitting is interrupted.

*

Seventh Sitting. Opening: Sunday, 6 o'clock in the evening. President: Dr. Herzl.

At 8 o'clock in the evening the sitting was opened anew with a brilliant speech by the well-known English writer Zangwill, which provoked outbursts of great merriment, but also stormy applause. Dr. Nordau translated into German this speech, which Zangwill spoke in English. (We gave this speech in our last number.)

Zangwill's motion, "that the Congress condemn the proceedings of the executors of Baron Hirsch," is not put to the vote by Dr. Herzl. There are words, said the President, which are not lost; but let a vote now be refrained from, although the reasons cannot be stated publicly.

The special debate that thereupon follows on the new draft of organisation yields, on the whole, no new points of view. It is resolved that, unrestricted by an already existing Country Organisation, a separate organisation may constitute itself if at least 50 societies with at least 5000 members join together for it.

When the reporter of the Commission moved the further provision: "the confirmation of this new organisation rests with the Vienna Actions-Comité," the Actions-Comité for Russia declared that under such conditions it could not again accept a new office. As objection was raised to this,