Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 4 · 24 January 1902
10printed page
scan 10 of 20

Page 10 — "Die Welt" — No. 4

(continued from page 9)

…ment of religious Judaism there follows, in my firm conviction, beyond all doubt the transition to national Judaism."

"Indifferentism in Judaism has been combated by Zionism in a quite considerable manner."

"The question, law-observant or not, seems to me quite idle to discuss at the moment. —

If we strive for a better condition of life for millions of our co-religionists who now drag out their lives under impossible circumstances, who go panting under the heavy burden that weighs upon them — if these persons have a legally secured home there, whither the longing of their faith draws them, then of themselves they will be able, and will wish, to be quite other Jews than in many cases they are to-day."

"According to the theory of those people, then, we should also have no right to work for the needs of daily life, but should, in our trust in God, rely upon what the Father of all assigns to us without our own effort. Never, never has Judaism so conceived its trust in God; on the contrary, it was precisely from its trust in God that it drew the courage to work."

"With us Jews, doing is always placed in the foreground."

"Should we be permitted to do nothing towards the attainment of that goal which has ever hovered before us throughout our whole historical development, throughout our whole religious conception?"

"One must act — so said to me at the Congress the venerable Rabbi Rabinowitz of Sopozkin, who assured me that he had received some 250 letters from Russian rabbis of the strictest religious observance, all of whom declare themselves for Zionism."

"This as a contribution to the idea of Zionism, in which connection one can only regret that this idea, which must be so clear, so self-evident to every Jew who loves his Judaism, must ever and again be argued afresh."


By Way of Elucidation.

We have received the following communication:

Under the title "Jewish Questions in Dispute" a notice appeared some time ago in the "Kölnische Zeitung," the contents of which have already been reproduced in an earlier number of the "Israelitische Rundschau." In a communication to the "Kölnische Zeitung" the chairman of the Rabbinical Association, Rabbi Dr. Maybaum, declared that "the contents of this notice were invented from beginning to end," and at the same time warned the "Kölnische Zeitung" against trusting any reports about the German Rabbinical Association that might come from the Zionist side. Whether this latter insinuation was in good taste we leave undecided. But since the charge of untruthfulness has been raised against the Zionists, we take occasion to clear up the facts completely. We have all the more urgent cause to do so since Dr. Martin Schreiner, in No. 2 of the "Allgemeine Zeitung des Judenthums," issues a declaration whose tortuousness can serve only to confuse the real state of affairs. On the 7th of December of last year a letter of the following tenor reached the Central Committee of the "Zionist Federation":

To the Central Committee of the "Zionist Federation for Germany."

As the National-Jewish Society of the Students at the Lehranstalt für die Wissenschaft des Judenthums in Berlin, we consider ourselves bound to draw the attention of the Central Committee of the "Zionist Federation for Germany" to steps which the "German Rabbinical Association" intends to take with the Prussian Government in the very near future, and which are calculated to compromise the national-Jewish and Zionist idea as well as its adherents. It is intended, namely, to submit to the Government a petition of approximately the following tenor:

a) The Mosaic confession shall be placed on an equal footing, politically and religiously, with the other confessions in every respect.

b) Accordingly the rabbis shall be appointed by the State, their salaries guaranteed by the State, and they shall also be pensioned by the State.

c) The communal administration shall stand in the closest relation to the Ministry of Public Worship, as is the case in Württemberg and Baden.

These demands are in themselves, no doubt, as unobjectionable as they are justified. The danger, however, lies in the grounds given for these claims, which are to run as follows:

a) The Jews are nothing but a religious community, and as such they have the right to demand legal equality with the other confessions.

b) Were the Jews a nation, they would have no claim to it.

c) That the Jews are in fact nothing but a religious community is to be maintained, among other things, on the authority of an apologetic-polemical work by Dr. Martin Schreiner, to appear within the next fortnight.

We cannot answer for the exact wording, but for the fact we vouch.

We beg you, in the event of these lines being published, to name us only if it be absolutely necessary in the interest of the cause.

Respectfully, The Committee. By order: (Signed) Dr. Max Schlesinger. (Signed) Emil Cohn. (Signed) Gotthold Weil.

Immediately afterwards we received from another reliable quarter, likewise from Berlin, a confirmation of this communication, which tallied completely with the contents of the notice that appeared in the "Kölnische Zeitung."

When thereupon there appeared in the "Kölnische Zeitung" Dr. Maybaum's denial — which, after these communications, was wholly incomprehensible to us — we turned to our trusted representatives in Berlin, and upon their representations received from the committee of the National-Jewish Students' Society at the Lehranstalt des Judenthums the following communication:

Berlin, 18th December 1901.

Dear Doctor,

We maintain everything that we have communicated to you.

Our information comes, each and every item of it, from our lecturer Dr. Martin Schreiner, who communicated it to several of his pupils.

When, some two weeks ago, we informed the teaching staff of the founding of our National-Jewish Society at the Lehranstalt, Doctor Schreiner told us that this would thoroughly upset the calculations of Dr. Maybaum and the Rabbinical Association, inasmuch as the latter would shortly be submitting the said petition.

He made the same remarks at length on repeated occasions, and added that this matter had also been discussed at the recent committee meeting of the Rabbinical Association held in Baden-Baden.

If you consider that Mr. Maybaum, the chairman of the Rabbinical Association, and Dr. Schreiner sit on one and the same teaching staff, and that, according to Dr. Schreiner's statement, his own book is to serve as a scientific foundation for the rabbis' petition, you will understand that we could not for a moment doubt the authenticity of what he communicated.