Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 13 · 28 March 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 15


It hoped that the press and public opinion would take the part of the Jews; it believed, further, that it could attain its end by suitable representations to the Powers.

Public opinion, upon which the Alliance had built (cf. Leven's report of the year 1873), has left it in the lurch. In defiance of its hopes, the cause of our co-religionists has not been made, through the exertions of the Alliance, a cause of all civilised men; and the press, which was to have protected the oppressed Jews, has for the most part gone over into the camp of the enemies of the Jews.

By the diplomatic steps which it took, on the other hand, the Alliance did achieve results — but only on paper: the legal and political status of the Jews it could not improve by this means either.

In 1873 the directors of the Alliance met the Shah of Persia in Paris, and they used the occasion to commend the Persian Jews to his goodwill; in 1876 and 1878 they demanded of the representatives of the Great Powers assembled at Constantinople and Berlin the emancipation of the Roumanian Jews; in the year 1880 they turned to the Madrid Conference in order to improve the condition of the Jews of Morocco.

All was in vain.

In spite of the promises of the Shah Nasr-Eddin, nothing has changed in the condition of the Persian Jews; the Megilla which, as Crémieux dreamed, would one day tell of the Alliance that in the nineteenth century saved the Jews of Persia, will unhappily never be written. In Roumania the condition of the Jews is worse than ever; the Alliance did not become a rampart that protected them; the Conferences at Constantinople and Berlin have not lessened their sufferings; formerly they were chastised with whips, now they are chastised with scorpions. In Morocco, in spite of the resolutions passed by the Madrid Conference and in spite of all the assurances of the Sultan Muley es Hassan, everything remained as of old.

In Russia the Alliance never received permission to found schools; nor did it ever have the opportunity of discussing the repeal of the Jewish laws with the Russian rulers.

The diplomatic action of the Alliance is therefore to be regarded as a failure.

The emigration movement, too, which the Alliance encouraged and supported materially, has brought forth little of profit.

But here it is not the idea that was mistaken, but the manner in which it sought to realise it.

Instead of a well-considered plan, it followed a zig-zag course.

In 1869 it urged the Russian Jews to emigrate to America; it itself defrayed the passage-money of 800 emigrants — in 1896 it puts forward the assertion that the solution of the Jewish question, so far as Russia is concerned, lies in Russia itself.

In 1882 it supported the colonisation of Palestine with counsel and deed; in recent years it is helping to destroy the Palestinian work of colonisation.

The balance-sheet of its emigration and colonisation endeavours is as follows:

Millions of Jews have left the old Ghetto in Eastern Europe and have moved into a new one in America; only a few thousands have been settled as farmers in Palestine and have there found a legal and political betterment of their condition; this last, relatively favourable result, however, is due in the first place to the work of the Choveve-Zion and to the millions of Baron Rothschild. To improve the condition of the Jewish masses by emigration and colonisation the Alliance has not been able.

For the fiasco in the Argentine, the causes of which Zangwill set forth in one of his recent speeches, no reproach is to be made against it, since it did not found the Argentine colonies, and has only for a few years, in common with the Anglo Jewish Association, taken over their administration.

Whoever knows the results of the work of the Alliance hitherto will well understand that the means it has employed for the uplifting of the Jewish population should be subjected to revision, and that care should be taken that the unsuitable ones remain unused henceforth, and that only such means be employed as have been proved by experience or are recommended by reflection.

We regard Jewish distress as a consequence of the struggle for existence; the Jews, who by race and religion form a distinct group of mankind, are in most cases regarded not as friends but as adversaries; powerless and numerically weak as they are, they must succumb.

Here the Alliance schools avail little; education that cannot be turned to account does not make the Jews fitter for the struggle; by means of schools the uneducated Jewish proletariat is merely transformed into an educated one. And no argument, no protest, and no appeal to love of humanity and to advanced culture will induce the victor to give the Jews weapons, by lessening the political and social pressure, wherewith to carry on with equal chances the struggle for bread and for the pleasures of this world.

Accordingly an economic betterment of the Jewish masses is possible only by their leaving the countries in which the pressure is too great, and in which it will not lessen within any foreseeable time — for instinctively every living creature seeks to flee the region in which it sees death by hunger before it — and settling in such countries whose possessors have an interest in being able to count upon the help of Jewry in the struggle against mightier enemies, and who will receive and regard them not as adversaries but as fellow-workers and allies. But whither is the stream of Jewish emigrants to be directed?

To America in no case: in the North the gates are being closed before the Jewish proletarians; in the South the Argentine experiment warns against further Jewish immigration. Only one country fulfils all the reasonable requirements that can be made of a field for Jewish immigration, and that country is Palestine. It is capable of nourishing millions of our brethren; Turkey, the possessor of Palestine, hard pressed economically and politically within and without her borders, knows that an industrious Jewish population can only be of use to her.

The eyes of the Jews of Eastern Europe have for years been turned towards Palestine. According to the Bulletin of the Alliance of the year 1895, "it is not only the attraction which the Holy Land exerts upon pious minds that leads the Jews to Palestine, but above all the need of the peace and the security which they lack in Russia and Roumania; it is also anxiety for their existence, so insecure in the land of their birth; it is, lastly, the desire to live by agriculture, with which they are bound up by the most ancient traditions of our history."

The Alliance will do justice to its task in the future in that it — the emigration of the Jews from Eastern Europe and the other countries in which their