Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 29 · 18 July 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 29

Mr. Norman: You lay stress here upon the moral forces which attract these Jewish immigrants, but you surely overlook the fact that they are drawn by equally great material forces. The fact that they find it easier here to succeed in competition and to make money certainly plays no smaller part in bringing them over than the moral power.

Dr. Herzl: An emigrating Jew lives under conditions in which he is unable to foresee what will be the case ten years hence, when he may make larger undertakings, when he shall have climbed to a higher social level. At the moment of his immigration his only thought is not to suffer hunger. I believe there is less reflection in it than you think. He is driven onward as by a force of nature, like a stream of water which seeks out the place of least resistance.

Mr. Norman: The immigrants think, then, when they come to this country, that there is less hunger to be suffered here?

Dr. Herzl: That brings us to the condition of the Jews in the Ghettos of Eastern Europe. You have done me the honour of summoning me because you wish to hear the truth. Permit me, then, to express my view upon this point also. If you wish to understand this question, you must not regard it merely from the standpoint of the East End of London, but must try to take up the Eastern European standpoint. And if I may anticipate a question which will undoubtedly come, I should like to permit myself a comparison: If you see a pool of blood in your room, your first and natural wish will certainly be to clean the room. But what is the cause of the pool of blood? The cause is a wounded man. One must first help the wounded man and then clean the room.

Mr. Norman: Among the forces of attraction which bring these immigrants here, the moral forces of which you have spoken, and also the material ones, you also named Jewish charity, a magnet which draws the Jews hither.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly. — May I be permitted to add that from the human standpoint I am very grateful to these great Jewish charitable institutions in London. The objections I make are from the political standpoint. Assuredly I do not say that it is wrong to give a crumb of bread to a starving man.

Mr. Norman: We all appreciate these splendid charitable institutions; but the question has often arisen before the Commission whether they do not have a perplexing effect, namely that of serving as a magnet for the very poorest.

Dr. Herzl: You see, then, the difficulty! — The reproaches against the resident Jews would be far greater if they had not founded these charitable institutions, if they were to leave their poor kinsmen to general charity. You see, then, the entanglement.

Mr. Norman: I am not discussing the moral aspects, but the economic effects. You speak in your statement of a state of things which, with continued immigration, will arise in this country too. What state of things do you mean?

Dr. Herzl: I will not attempt to play the prophet, but I believe that the same natural forces rule here as elsewhere. If the number of immigrants grows, then, I believe, even in this country, where, as I am happy to be able to say, no Antisemitism exists at present, it will arise. I believe one may state in general that England is not an Antisemitic country, but I greatly fear it might one day become one. That, however, is of general interest, for the character of England as a free country is not solely an English question, but one of world-wide interest.

Mr. Norman: Therefore you regard the possible rise of Antisemitism in this country, which everyone would deeply deplore, as one of the dangers of continued unrestricted immigration?

Dr. Herzl: I should prefer not to answer the question of restriction or non-restriction. Restriction is a separate question. I merely fear that undiverted immigration might one day produce an anti-Jewish current.

Mr. Norman: That was my point too. As regards remedies, on the other hand, it has been put forward here, as you will have seen, and supported by some people, that the dispersal of the Jewish immigrants and their distribution from the one small centre in East London to various parts of the United Kingdom would be a possible and suitable solution. Is that not your view as well?

Dr. Herzl: No! — I recall from my legal career the prohibition which exists with us against change of domicile. I do not know what you call it, for I believe you have no such prohibition at all.

The Chairman: No! — That is not an English idea, rather a Russian or reactionary one. To prescribe to a man where he is to live — that is a kind of police regulation. We know nothing of the sort. English feeling will not tolerate such a thing.

Dr. Herzl: I cannot comprehend how Jews themselves could make such a proposal.

Mr. Norman: Distribution, as we have understood it, aims simply at relieving the congestion in one place by encouraging settlement in other districts, but by no means through compulsion.

Dr. Herzl: I believe this to be a quite impracticable idea. I will not go into details, for I hope you will see it for yourselves.

Mr. Norman: You are of opinion that after a certain time it will merely produce in many places the evil which at present exists chiefly in one place.

Dr. Herzl: That is an idea which, I believe, was not fully thought out by those who hatched it. A man whom you advise to settle somewhere will believe that you are bound to maintain him. He will tell you again and again: You advise me to stay here; you must give me the means to support my life here.

Mr. Norman: So you regard this proposal as senseless?

Dr. Herzl: Yes! — If the word is not too harsh for me.

Mr. Norman: And assimilation as a remedy, as I gather from you, can neither be expected, nor is it to be desired from the Jewish standpoint?