No. 1 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11
(continued from page 10)
…strict. But nothing can be clearer than that the "finest distribution" would also be the ruin of religious Judaism. Our religious law is cut to the measure of a people living in one land, and requires gatherings of Jews, not only for the festivals but also for daily prayer. I know a Jewish community somewhere in the East which numbers 10 adult male members and which clings with the old fidelity to the Law. It is clear that it would be a catastrophe for these people if one of them should in any way be lost to the community. Within a wide radius of this dwarf community there live — again separated from one another — two single Jewish families, and I can report as an eye-witness how these two travelled at Passover to this "chief community" of 10 Jews, and I gained an approximate idea of what it means for poor people, who are in any case fighting for their existence, to remove their whole household for several weeks to another place, from which they live a day's journey distant.
Although, then, the principle of dispersion, which until the most recent times we regarded, out of a healthy instinct, as the disintegration of Judaism and as a continuation of the wars of extermination waged for thousands of years against the Jews, ought to be combated most resolutely by the religious and the national among us alike, we see it carried out ever more consistently from day to day, with the approval of official Jewry in, one may well say, every country.
Against this momentous error, which, so far as it spreads, must with the necessity of nature lead to the disappearance of the Jews and of Judaism, an energetic campaign must at last be opened. The danger of this tendency, which has recently gained the upper hand, must be pointed out in word and in print, and religious and national Jews alike should apply all their strength to combating the evil. The matter becomes greater still when one considers that here is a ground on which all the positive elements in Judaism find a common field of labour. And from this very point co-operation in all other Jewish questions will follow of itself; for if we grasp the problem widely enough, all the other parts of the Jewish question lie within that of Jewish migration.
The Jewish migration question is the Jewish question.
*
In order to be able to combat a bad extreme energetically, one must set up the opposite as a demand, or at least as a watchword. It is plain, of course, that every extreme is bad; but when one has overshot a goal, it is necessary to halt and to go in the opposite direction. Nor is it to be supposed that, after going astray in one direction, one will now quickly go just as far astray in the opposite direction. A wanderer who has lost his way will be more cautious on the way back.
We will therefore first set up, as a watchword, the principle of ingathering, the opposite of dispersion; and it is clear that if we set against the finest distribution of the Jews over all the countries of the world their most compact ingathering in one land, this land can be none other than our old land of Palestine, if only because the union of all Jews upon any other land would be unthinkable. We should thus have, as the other extreme, the demand for the return of the Jews to Palestine.
*) The Gipsies perhaps form an exception. But neither by their number nor by the area of their spread do they come into consideration beside us, and above all they lack the religious and national union, the common tradition, which would stand over against dispersion into so many countries.
We have already said that every extreme is bad. But we have also said that an extreme may be a good watchword for turning back from a wrong road. In this sense the extreme demand for the return of all Jews to Palestine is only the extreme formulation of the sound idea and of the only reasonable policy, which consists in this: to call a halt to further dispersion, to withdraw so far as possible the outposts pushed too far forward, to check emigration so far as is practicable, and, so far as it is unavoidable, to centralise it.
With the existing organisations, and with those to be created for this purpose, embracing the whole of positive Jewry, the solution of the Jewish question is possible.
*
Now that the goal has been shown, the ways too must be shown, and once again we have to learn from past errors and shortcomings.
It has happened that Roumanian emigrants set out without any plan and were sent on from station to station, by way of Budapest, Vienna and Frankfort, by the respective committees to London, because it was believed that the passage to America would be cheaper from there. The affair was so grotesque that the legend arose that the wicked Zionists had artificially directed the emigration to London in order to teach the rich London Jews a lesson. This "diabolical plan" (so a prominent English Jew described the matter to me) was exploited to the full against the Zionists, until it turned out that the "Alliance Israélite" was responsible for the detour.
Less before the eyes of the great public, numerous emigration mishaps of this kind have taken place even in the last few years. I know of cases in which people had to go through the most incredible detours, delays, belated arrivals and privations, because, proceeding from the view that express trains and steamships would be dearer than jog-trot trains and sailing-boats, the emigrants were recommended routes which exceeded the usual, well-known and reliable routes by far, not only in time but still more in money.
A particularly frequent mistake consisted in this, that emigrants to America travelled steerage in order to have "over there" the 10 dollars which the second class costs more. The result in countless cases was that the steerage passenger, because he could not show the prescribed 30 dollars, was sent back to Europe, while the second-class passenger goes ashore in New York as one steps out of a horse-tram with us — that is, without the slightest formalities.
But this concerns in the main only the routes of travel, about which, with some care, one could still always inform oneself. With the destinations it is much more difficult. It is not enough for the emigrant to rely upon the news he received years ago from relatives or acquaintances since lost sight of; and yet such news, which for the most part is no longer correct, if it ever was, plays perhaps the greatest part in the choice of the "new country." Nor is it enough if the news is of fresher date. The individual emigrant, who for the most part belongs to the proletariat, is not capable of judging the situation of a country, an industry, etc., and will for the most part perceive nothing of changes until they strike him personally.
Much wrong has also been done in this direction, that emigration to particular countries has been allowed to continue when it would have been time to stem it by suitable work of enlightenment. Instead, one has waited until compulsory restrictions were decreed on the part of the countries of immigration. Indeed, it has even happened that countries were publicly recommended for emigration which were at the time, and for long afterwards, closed — such as South Africa and Asia Minor.