Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 4 · 27 August 1903
8printed page
scan 8 of 16

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 4.

(continued from page 7)

…future Jewish commonwealth? If you are against it, you must also be against this Congress.

I must further repudiate the remark that it shows how low Zionism has sunk in some Western European delegations. It is precisely because we feel the immense responsibility that we have said we cannot decide this question so quickly and offhand, but that it must be deliberated upon by a commission. Our way is comparable to a mountain railway which, through many tunnels, yet at last climbs up to the light. We too are drawing nearer to the sun of Zion (Applause).

Dr. Jakobsohn: I fear that we shall go away from here robbed of our Zionist ideal. We have no right, it has been said, to renounce this offer. But with East Africa you will certainly not help the millions of suffering Jews. That would only be a momentary relief. You will have to admit that if we wish to set on foot even a small colonisation, we must explore the land well and seriously. That takes a long time. You will not be able to divert the great stream of emigration to America towards East Africa. To go to America one does not need much money, but to go to East Africa one does. It is sad for me to come before you with these arguments. One thing unites us Zionists: pride in our Judaism, and the Basle Programme. It is hardly comprehensible to me how national consciousness is to be raised in East Africa, a land plucked out of the air at random by a statesman. Instead of organising the people, we are beginning a new and heavy task merely to provide for a few thousands. Either Palestine or East Africa. For for decades this will claim all our forces.

Dr. Pasmanik came forward with democratic principles. It is uncommonly difficult to place our people in an entirely new situation. We expect our people to accomplish this difficult work. It is said that we need only speak about the commission. I am against that. There are various questions in a party which cannot be dealt with in a commission, because these questions belong to the fundamental idea of the party. On this point one can make no compromises. (Stormy applause.)

Pines speaks against East Africa and against the appointment of a commission.

Diesenhof speaks in French. He turns against the East Africa project and against the "politician" Friedemann: after all, it would also be "political" to recommend assimilation to the suffering Jews. The Russian, Roumanian and Galician Jews want no asylum, but a fatherland. A fatherland has never been founded by a majority resolution. (Applause.)

A motion to adjourn the sitting is rejected, and the sitting is continued.

Dr. A. Marmorek: So that no misunderstandings may prevail, I declare that I am absolutely against the East Africa project. (Applause.) All those arguments of a more philanthropic nature have not been able to shake me in the opinion that the East Africa project is at bottom anti-Zionist. (Lively applause.) The question which occupies us here, however, is not whether we like East Africa or not, but whether we should make up our minds before we have examined it or not. We have an unnecessary fear of this commission. It is not to decide, not to say yes or no, before it has spoken to us again. Will it not be taken from our own midst? And our vote on the matter means the more, the more we know about it. Let us not believe that our leaders would have been ready to abandon Zion merely for the sake of a vague phantom. There must perhaps be something in the matter. And then the appointment of a commission will not shake us in directing our thoughts towards Zion. That is no compromise. Further: is it right that, when our leaders wish to make communications to us, we should say to them: We will hear nothing? Will it not be said: "In the Zionist movement things are rejected before they have been heard? The Zionist Congress is not to be taken seriously?" I have confidence in the commission that is to be sent out. Examine we must. We doubt that anything will change in our convictions, in our striving for Palestine. (Applause.)

Granowski speaks against the East Africa project. He remarks, against Dr. Friedemann, that he wants no "Rachmones" Zionists. It concludes his suggestions on the policy to be followed in Palestine: a publicly secured home is not something one buys; one receives it as a people. (Applause.)

Dr. Herzl, President: I reprimand the previous speaker for his remarks: things such as he has brought forward do grave harm to our cause. I cannot let that pass, and I call upon the speakers who follow to keep away from such things as are not in the spirit of the assembly. (Lively applause.)

Rabinowitsch speaks in Russian. Bogoratscho speaks in Hebrew.

Chasan: In this hall there are two parties, Africans and non-Africans (Laughter). The goal, however, which we Zionists have in view, we shall never forget in any case; why, then, should we resist appointing a commission and reject the matter from the outset? We want a commission which does not indeed decide, but deliberates!

Herr Mosisson speaks in Jargon.

Dr. Moses, Mannheim: I should like to maintain that the for and against of the East Africa project in no way signifies a narrowing or a widening of the Zionist programme; rather, we have regarded the strict rejection of the project as a piece of ill-considered policy. This consideration has led us to support the acceptance by us of the proposal of the A. C. It is, after all, first of all an act of courtesy to examine a proposal that one is offered, especially from a Power which previously behaved in an extremely friendly manner in the El Arish question. We owe it to prudence, and above all to our people, not simply to pass to the order of the day over an offer that has been presented to us, without any deliberation whatever. (Bravo!) But it would also be an injustice to our leaders if we were simply to reject the work of their labours. So much has been said of confidence in our leaders, who have worked so honestly, and it would be gross ingratitude if we were to reject the project without taking the trouble to investigate what the project really means. What we want is nothing other than an examination by trusted men in conjunction with the A. C., from the standpoint of the simplest political prudence, as well as from the standpoint of confidence in our leader Dr. Herzl (Hear, hear!) and from the standpoint of duty towards our Jewish people.

Chairman D. Wolffsohn. A motion has been brought in for the closure of the debate, with a hearing of two general speakers, two for and two against.