Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 34 · 21 August 1903
16printed page
scan 16 of 36

Page 16. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 34.

And behold! In Mesha as in Jama the peasants were completely self-supporting after the lapse of only one year, demanded no subsidies of any kind, and were more contented than those of Rischon and Sichron. Here, in short, human nature, with its virtues and its weaknesses, was rightly reckoned with, and it is now known how one must proceed in future. In the first place, the successes in Galilee have brought the Baron to the resolve to work on bravely, and near Acre and in the neighbourhood of Tiberias some 90,000 dunams of land have been bought for colonisation purposes within the past year. The Ica, too, will not be able to escape the impression of these successes and will have to go on colonising, now that the proof has been furnished to it that colonisation can very well be carried on. What reasons will it still put forward to-day for its "No"?

The settlement of one family under the new system still costs 8–10,000 francs. But let it not be forgotten what the first settlements cost, and it must further be considered that the peasants of the new villages are colonists from the old Rotschild colonies, who have already been accustomed to making demands. Later it will be possible to proceed far more cheaply with other labour. A second, very successful experiment also deserves attention. At Sedjerah the Ica has laid out a model farm on a very large tract. The land was cleared, and grain sown and reaped, with Jewish day-labourers only. Already in the second year Sedjerah covers all its working expenses; in the next, not inconsiderable surpluses will be obtained. From half-past five in the morning until late in the evening work goes on in the fields — ploughing, sowing and reaping. Practical cattle-breeding is carried on, and here alone did we also find the women at work in the fields, certainly a great success. Thus, on the one hand, the invested capital earns interest, and on the other real peasants are trained — peasants who have been brought up in hard peasant labour, who know the newest agricultural implements and the best methods of husbandry, and who will thus furnish excellent human material for a later colonisation.

Here, it seems to me, the signpost is given for our provisional activity in Palestine. So long as we do not possess the Charter, and therefore cannot colonise on a large scale, we ought to buy land out of the National Fund, establish model farms upon it, and in this way attain three things: to secure land for ourselves, to earn interest on the invested moneys, and to raise a stock of peasants whom we shall later, at the beginning of colonisation on a great scale, urgently need as instructors of the immigrant multitude unacquainted with agriculture. One of the most difficult questions for the future lies in the circumstance that there is a lack of practical models for the new peasants. On the experimental and model farms they can be created, and the Actions Committee ought to give this question its earnest attention.

The Ica, however, will now have to explain why, even after the successes in Galilee, it persists in its standpoint hostile to Palestine. Or else it will expose itself to the reproach of ill will even among those who endeavour to judge justly and objectively.

Dr. Adolf Friedemann.


Zionism and Progress.

By Dr. J. B. Sapir. (Authorised translation by A. Benjamin.)

It is said that Providence has destined the educated class of the Jews to guard the interests of defenceless humanity, and German Jewry babbles that therein consists our lofty mission. All nations are by their nature egoistic, and are above all concerned to shape their own lot as well as possible, without thinking much about the "mere man." They assume that humanity loses nothing if things go well with them. The Jewish educated, however, are above all troubled about what will become of humanity in general, and of the neighbouring peoples in particular, after the Jews shall at last have succeeded in establishing themselves in a manner worthy of human beings. And even before these gentlemen have undertaken the least thing to bring nearer the long-desired moment of Judah's independence, they are already much troubled about what will happen then, for "very often," they say, "a nationality that has become free begins to oppress other nations"; and in alarm they turn their backs upon the national aspirations of their people. They stop their ears so that they may not hear the cries for help. They are pursued by one thought alone: "What will become of the poor Bedouins, their future neighbours, if the Jews obtain a commonwealth in Palestine? Will they not quarrel with them?"

That would be ridiculous were it not so sad. The Jewish educated, too, pursue national interests — but not those of the Jews: for the sake of the Bedouins, of the Arabs, they sacrifice their own nationality. Where is the humanity in this? The Jews are suffering now; why do you think of the not yet existing sufferings of a tribe foreign to you? Kossuth and Petöfi did not put such useless questions to themselves. Garibaldi with his "Thousand" did not ponder before the fight whether, forty years after the union of Italy, the Milan riots would not take place. These great sons of their people thought of one thing only — of the freedom and the greatness of their nation. And these and other nations too attained their freedom only thanks to the circumstance that neither Gambetta nor Washington nor Mazzini merely brooded. The Jewish politicians, as distinct from Mazzini, Gambetta, Fichte and other "narrow" nationalists, advocate — and that in view of the inconveniences to the neighbouring peoples which hover before their prophetic eye — the self-annihilation of their own nation.

How is this unnatural phenomenon to be explained? If we look at the matter more closely, it will become clear to us. Gambetta, Kossuth and others loved their people without bounds; every blow that struck their people found an insurmountably painful echo in their souls, and where one feels insurmountable pain, one does not merely deliberate — one seeks means to remove that pain. When a mother sees her child drowning in the whirlpool of the sea, she plunges in after it at once and does not ask herself what will one day become of this child. And if every blow the Jews receive found a painful echo in the hearts of the Jewish learned, there would be no abstract debates about Zionism to-day.

Besides the welfare of the Bedouins, our opponents advance the principle of cosmopolitanism as a reason against the national rebirth. The cosmopolitans demand of the Jews complete fusion with the other nations, since the final goal of humanity is the "mere man," and the separateness of the Jews runs directly counter to this ideal of humanity. In order, therefore, to remove the discord between our people and these aspirations, it must be erased from the ethnographical map of Europe. Once this obstacle has been cleared away, humanity will stride towards its ideal at an accelerated pace.

Before we prove how false and illogical such a demand is, we will first see what actually