Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 36.
The Director reads the report of the Board of Directors (see the last number of our special edition) and thereupon opens the discussion upon it.
Dr. Arschawski:
(President: Dr. Farbstein was appointed auditor by the previous General Meeting and could give his report at once. But as he is not here, you may speak.)
(speaks Russian) observes that he understands nothing of finance. He therefore ventures no judgment upon its substance, but he does upon the manner in which the matter has been furthered. The Bank made a good beginning, but did not take the proper steps to make itself as popular as possible. For years people waited. There was no dividend. The people ought at least to be told every half-year how matters stand. He considers that the prohibition of import had not the slightest influence upon the circulation of the shares, for even before the prohibition they were no longer being bought. One could observe the sad spectacle of a share being sold for 5 roubles. To remedy this, a dividend, however small, must be given to the people precisely now. He is convinced that a great part of the shareholders would not make the slightest use of it. But it must be given to them.
L. Pines speaks to the same effect as the previous speaker.
Ginzburger-Riga moves that this year's dividend be assigned to the National Fund (dissent), not as an obligation, but in order to set an example to the shareholders who are not present.
Aschkenasi advocates the payment of a dividend on financial grounds. There is a law in Russia which prohibits foreign bank shares if they pay no dividend for three years. In the interest of the circulation of the shares this must be prevented.
Karr asks the Board of Directors why it has altered a resolution of the General Meeting of shareholders and no longer grants to shareholders who have paid only one instalment the right to pay the arrears later. He then states that in Roumania, where there are 30 000 shares, the Jewish Colonial Bank has fallen under suspicion because no report on its financial position has ever appeared in any Roumanian newspaper. Moreover, last year, in October, at the meeting of the Greater Actions Committee, it was stated there that the Jewish Colonial Bank would pay a dividend of 3 per cent. Something about it had also appeared in the "Welt." Thereupon, in the hope that if dividends were spoken of in October they would come in January, after the close of the Bank's first year of activity, an agitation was begun that this dividend should be donated to the Jewish National Fund. He begs the Board of Directors not to come forward again promising a dividend that is only resolved upon ten months later. That breeds suspicion, and has had the effect that for two years the Bank has sold no more than a few thousand shares. He moves that the Jewish Colonial Bank publish, at least every six months, a detailed balance-sheet of its financial position in all the newspapers of the countries where many shares have been disposed of — in Russian, Hebrew, Roumanian, and English papers, etc.
President Mr. Wolffsohn: The Board of Directors has hitherto refused no subsequent payment. From Roumania in particular inquiries have reached us whether we would perhaps accept payment in later years. We have thereupon in each case fixed a definite date. Further, if it is your wish, the finances will be publicly accounted for at regular intervals. I believe, however, that it is impossible for us to advertise this matter in all the newspapers of the world. It is sufficient if this is done in the "Welt." Every Zionist knows this paper; the other papers that are interested in it can reprint the announcement.
A motion by Rosenbaum to limit speaking time to 5 minutes is carried.
L. Weizmann: I must uphold the remarks of the previous speakers; for the prestige of the Jewish Colonial Bank has fallen. I consider the answer the Chairman has given insufficient. In the "Welt" one has indeed seen a brief balance-sheet from time to time. But in our case, where the shareholders are not always bankers, a reasoned balance-sheet ought to be submitted. One gentleman has proposed that we should forgo the dividend. I believe that at a meeting of shareholders one ought to speak in no other than a business-like way. We are reproached everywhere that our shares are not securities. We must demand and accept dividends: that will raise our prestige. Then I should like information on a few questions. In the balance-sheet it is noted that from 32 516 shares not taken up, 33 000 pounds sterling have fallen to the Bank. Further I find that 4277 pounds sterling are still on hand as reserve. I ask you to explain to me where in the balance-sheet we are to find these 28 000 pounds sterling. I assume that part of this money was used to cover the promotion expenses of the Bank. But so far as I remember, those sums amounted to considerably less, the more so as it was announced at the time — at the General Meeting of 1899 — that considerable amounts had also been contributed towards them by various gentlemen shareholders. Consequently only a part of the expenses remained, to be covered out of these 28 000 pounds sterling. Where, then, is the rest?
I should also like to know whether the "advances from bankers and other advances," amounting to 26 500 among the liabilities of the balance-sheet, were borrowed at interest or free of charge. For if the Bank pays interest on these advances, I do not understand why this is done. What are these advances for?
Mr. Dr. Farbstein: You have received with great satisfaction the favourable result of the Bank's operations. It is so favourable that it is even proposed to us to distribute a dividend. One of the gentlemen said: As shareholders we must demand that the dividend be distributed. I say: As sober men of business we must demand that this dividend be given to the reserve fund. It is not large, and we do not know what events may occur in this or the following year. The proposal that the dividend be handed over to the National Fund cannot legally be carried out at all. No resolution of a joint-stock company can compel me to give away my dividend.
Attention has further been drawn to the point that the balance-sheet of the Bank ought to be published several times a year. Since we have so many who are not men of business among the shareholders, I am convinced that such a publication would cause still far greater disappointments than a publication once a year. A balance-sheet is nothing actual. Consols, etc., may be worth more in one month, less in another. Such publications may call forth a false picture.
I should now like once more, on behalf of my constituents, the South African Federation, to the Direc-