Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 38 · 18 September 1903
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 38

(continued from page 5)

. . . Strasburg, which, by the way, is signed "Zioni." That too is a sign of the times.

The socialist "Reveil du Nord" (Lille), a decided opponent of all national aspirations, takes its stand against the Congress. It is against Palestine as well as against East Africa, and appeals to the Jewish proletariat, of which, as we must add, it knows not the least thing, and of whose aspirations and most ardent wishes it has no notion.

The radical "Gironde" (Bordeaux), on the other hand, shows itself very sympathetic towards the Congress, and particularly towards the East African plan.

Peculiar is the opinion of the "Independance Belge" of Brussels: "Zionism is an error, and the great majority of the Jews who live in the countries of Western Europe, where they are not the victims of an exceptional régime (!), will certainly not join it." How plainly the timid and anxious assimilationist Jewry speaks here!

And finally we may refer to an article by Jacques Landau in the "France." He calls himself a Positivist and declares that Zionism, instead of philosophising, must act in accordance with the traditions of the ancient Jewish people, which no longer exists. It must proclaim the new idea (which?) to the multitude, continue the work of evolution, etc."

*

The Russian Press.

The St. Petersburg "Novosti" discusses the Congress very benevolently and even enthusiastically. The paper most decidedly approves the East African plan, pays unreserved praise to the English Government, and expresses its astonishment that the Russian delegates voted against it. The paper also wishes at the same time to assert its priority, since some years ago it put forward the opinion that Manchuria might be left to the Jews, so that "the wolf be sated and the lamb unharmed." At the same time the paper holds that all governments ought to follow the example of England and place a free country at the disposal of the Jews.

The St. Petersburg "Viedomosti" likewise advocates the plan. The paper also rejoices at the circumstance that the Russian Government has promised to further Zionism, which bears witness to a change in its internal policy that will lead to good. The "Viedomosti" already addresses a farewell speech to the Jews and exhorts them in moving words "not to forget their old fatherland in their future one" ....

The "Mosk. Vied." (Moscow) is very anxious as to how the Jews will speak in Palestine. It devotes to this question a long article, meant to be witty, which treats of the Congress. To waste a word of criticism upon this tasteless exercise in style would be a sin.

The "Novoye Vremya" discusses the Congress very zealously, and indeed from its own standpoint. It turns against the East African project and declares it a chimera. While, after its fashion, bespattering the Jews and everything Jewish with calumnies and abuse, it says among other things: Where, then, is the "liberating deed of England" (this refers to the article of the "Novosti")? Does it consist perhaps in giving the Jews for settlement an uninhabited and uncultivated desert which belongs to it only nominally, and that not as property but as an autonomous province, even though with a Jewish governor at its head? In the end England will not make a bad "bargain" here. In short, the "Nov. Vr." is against Uganda, but far more still against Palestine. "To give Palestine away to the Jews would mean to strike many centuries out of the history of Europe, to blot out one of the tasks of modern Christianity."

The "Vilenskij Viestnik" contains stenographic reports of the sittings of the Congress, and this Russian paper speaks in words of great admiration of the successes of Zionism and foretells a good future for the Jewish movement of liberation.

In the "Hameliz" (St. Petersburg) M. L. Lilienblum, one of the oldest Zionists of Russia, takes up a position on the East African question. He seeks a psychological explanation for the sudden appearance of this settlement plan, which lies in the fact that the Zionists, weary of petty work and of collecting money, impatiently long to see greater results. The sad events in Kischenew in particular pressed for a speedy decision, and this presented itself to them in the offer of East Africa. The Leader of the Zionists could not, in logical consequence of his diplomatic endeavours, flatly reject this offer, for the sake of which he had entered into negotiations with Chamberlain. But what induced the author of "Altneuland" to think of East Africa? It is the grievous and shameful fact that the Jewish people could not raise the means needed to redeem its historic fatherland. The great Jewish magnates held the Leader who had initiated this undertaking to be a Utopian and a dreamer, if not indeed a seducer. For the honour and in the interest of the Zionist movement the Leader had to show that he had not dreams but deeds to point to.

L. seeks further to explain why the various parties at the Congress voted "yes" in the East African debate, and at the close raises the question how the "Zionist" Zionists are to conduct themselves when the expedition shall have completed its work. These — in L.'s opinion — ought not to reject the African colonisation. But the Zionists must not allow the appearance to arise that they are entitled to speak in the name of the whole people, so long as they have not asked the whole people about it. Nor have they the right to counsel the people: Endure, bear all conceivable sufferings and persecutions until we give you back Zion. At all events it must be admitted that it is better for the preservation of our nationality if our people finds an autonomous centre somewhere than if it scatters aimlessly to all points of the compass. But if such a centre is created, Lilienblum fears, our hope of Zion might suffer by it. He does indeed believe Dr. Herzl's assurance that he means to continue the work for Zion unwearyingly, but the people, once it has an autonomous home somewhere, would not think of Zion. Persecuted and suffering Jews would go thither and would no longer wish to leave this home in order to go to Zion. The "Jews" might then take the name of "Ugandans," just as the Dutch colonists of South Africa are no longer called "Dutchmen" but "Boers."

Lilienblum concludes with the demand that the East African settlement should not be undertaken in the name of Zionism, for this has quite a different goal before it. He has, indeed, no misgiving, if this settlement is carried out by non-nationalists and non-Zionists, that the national spirit might suffer by it. He fears only that the success of Uganda would turn the people away from Zion, and this would mean a sad conclusion to Jewish history.

Press Opinions.

The following newspapers have so far come to our knowledge as having reported on the Sixth Congress, for the most part daily and at some length:

Neue Preussische Zeitung, Allgemeine Zeitung, National-Zeitung, Post, Berliner Neueste Nachrichten, Berliner Börsencourier, Vossische Zeitung, Staatsbürger-Zeitung,