Page 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 52.
(continued from page 5)
. . . which food grows in sufficient quantity and which is large enough, and give it shelter and sustenance until the first harvest, and this people will in a short time have attained the prosperity of the land from which it has been transported as by a magic spell. For the wealth of a people, as we well know, rests not in what is stored up from past labour, not in the accumulated capital goods of the past, but in the strength of present labour. The more numerous a people is, the more it can divide its labour among itself, the more productive is its labour. On the other hand, the people, the land, from which the people has departed as by an incantation, will sink into the bitterest poverty. For past labour has value only when present labour, the sole creator of value, fructifies it.
And so the settlement of a people would be a comparatively easy game, practicable with comparatively little capital, with a comparatively small expenditure of trouble and labour — in proportion, that is, to the gigantic work — if a people were at hand and if a land were at hand. If one of these two requisites is lacking, the difficulty rises immeasurably. And, ladies and gentlemen, the work which Zionism has set itself to accomplish is the hardest of all, for it lacks both factors: there is no people at hand and there is no land at hand. Therefore the task is of a difficulty such as the world has never yet known.
I say there is no people at hand. By that I do not mean to say that the Jews, scattered over all the world, do not still form a nation. As a nation they may be regarded, as descendants of the same ancestors, as bearers of the same religion, of the same moral outlook, and above all held together by the same social suffering, by the same distress of the Golus. That in itself constitutes a nation. But by a people we understand a nation firmly rooted upon its own soil. And that the Jews are not.
What we need, what first of all forms the foundation of any possible national life upon new soil, is the fist of the peasant, agriculture. Only upon the foundation of agriculture can all higher culture flourish, and the people whom we are to transplant out of hideous misery, out of crushing distress, has only the very fewest peasants. All the more, however, of poor, wretched artisans and traders, run down even in body by the everlasting oppression.
And we have no land either. We hope to obtain a land, a land in which this most pitiable mass of humanity in the history of the world may blossom again into new life, in which the withered root of this nation will once more come into contact with the moisture of the soil, so as to bring fresh sap to the withered branches, to the dried-up trunk. But here too, in the most favourable case, we have to contend with the great, great difficulty that this land will be small, very small for the fearful mass of distress which we have to redeem, for the enormous number of suffering human beings for whom we wish to prepare a new home.
We have, then, neither people nor land, and yet the task confronts us with all its imperious force. We must attempt to master this difficulty. Why must we attempt it? Because these poor people cannot wait, because we cannot wait until they have been beaten to death, massacred, and have utterly perished in filth and mire, in the moral sense as well. Therefore we must stake all our strength on making the seemingly impossible possible, on carrying out the seemingly impracticable. Certainly, were the condition of these disinherited ones — who are crushed not only, like the Russian peasant, by hunger and by the bureaucracy, but by antisemitism as well — were their fate such that one could say they will hold out until better times, then one might wait. For there can be no doubt that the light which has risen in the West, dim yet visible, must also illumine the dark East. There is no doubt that if once, in the distant future, perhaps in a future not so very distant, in the Russian Empire too, in Roumania too, in the whole of Half-Asia, if once the social idea should have beneficently made its way there, the distress of the Jews too will thereby have reached its end. But for that these wretched people cannot wait, and therefore we must redeem them, lead them into a land in which they may look forward to better times. That is the task of Zionism as I understand it.
Well, I have already said that we need agriculture as the foundation of every new national life. We must lay the foundations of the building in agriculture, so as to be able to raise upon them the upper storeys, industry, commerce and intellectual culture. And fortunately there are forces enough in the East for the staking out of the first foundations. There are a few hundred thousand Jewish farmers, and among the miners too there are sufficient vigorous elements of whom the heavy work of husbandry may be expected. With these elements, I think, the organisation will have to begin. I should like to repeat the image with which I began my address in Basle.
The first colonies are to be the hooks that we drive in. Between these we are to stretch the ropes, colonies already in connection with one another, these too probably still formed of agriculturists. Into this wide-meshed net we are to set the best elements among the artisans as agriculturists. So we must advance slowly; that is the only way. Every other kind of colonisation than peasant colonisation is excluded from the outset. Suppose one wished to try to introduce a plantation system: it would needs be impossible, because such a system offers opportunities to only a few people, and Palestine is far too small for it. But the great estates, moreover, positively drive people off the land. The owner of great estates is like the lion, from whose neighbourhood everything flees the land. Were we even willing to carry all the misery of the slave-traders into the new land, we should have to give it up, because a land like Palestine would have room for only thousands of people, whereas we are called upon to settle hundreds of thousands. The same holds for large farmers. The large farmer, too, still devours too much land; and no continent is being placed at our disposal. So we are directed as a matter of course to small-peasant colonisation. How, then, is this to proceed? Consider the difficulty that confronts us! We cannot and must not set people who have hitherto plied the needle down into life and let them fall into guilt. We cannot tailors, shoemakers