Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 26 August 1903
10printed page
scan 10 of 16

Page 10 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 3

He spoke likewise of more or less benevolent intentions towards the Jewish people in general and our national feeling in particular. In view of the extraordinary interest which must be attached to the expression of such feelings in such a manner, I should like to ask Dr. Herzl whether it is possible for him, observing all necessary reserve, to say here in what form such feelings were expressed to him, or, or to put it more precisely, whether he received merely an oral communication to this effect, or whether these prospects were expressed to him in some other form.

Dr. Herzl. To this question I can answer that I am in possession of a written document. Whether I can and shall lay these documents before the Congress seems to me a matter to be discussed first in a meeting of the Greater A. C. I shall therefore convene the Greater A. C., which we meant to call together this evening for another purpose, for this intermediate meeting, and give you tomorrow the answer which the Greater A. C. authorises me to give.

Dr. Nordau makes some further business announcements concerning the meetings of the various national delegations.


Zionism and Charitable Institutions.

A national movement such as ours must advance like one man, and not one man like a national movement. I wish, however, to take upon myself the responsibility for my conclusions, which I hold to be the logical result of a general survey of scattered phenomena. We know what Zionism is. But what are charitable institutions? Charitable institutions are the outwardly visible sign of the defectiveness of a social organism. In a perfect society they would not exist. Even under present conditions there are, in every social organisation, broad strata where they do not exist. Indeed, the line of charity is at the same time the lower boundary of the classes conscious of their dignity. The efforts of social reformers should be directed not so much to developing the work of charity as to making it unnecessary. When one looks into the immense sufferings of Jewry and considers that the Jews, by the degree of their organisation, stand in truth lower than even the ant or the bee, since they possess neither a hive nor an ant-hill, one would almost ascribe all the misfortune of the Jew to precisely this want of a territory of his own. Israel has always played Odysseus in history, and Homer gives us Odysseus' opinion on this point: The resourceful Odysseus then answered: Nothing can bring so much misfortune upon a race of men as want of a homeland and constant wandering from place to place. But when we consider that even in countries like France or America we everywhere "have the poor with us," it is clear that, in order to strike the balance of how far the blame for all these sufferings of Jewry can be ascribed to the lack of a soil of our own, we must first carefully deduct from the account those general evils with which the work of charity is everywhere concerned: evils which no country has yet been able wholly to root out of its organism.

For my part I am convinced that these black spots, which cling to all civilised societies, can, if treated scientifically and rationally, be greatly reduced, if not entirely effaced. Never would so many of our hopes have been concentrated upon Zionism, did it not carry within it the hope that one day the Jewish State will be able to offer the world the solution of these social problems, and that that race whose first lawgiver was so infinitely far in advance of all other lawgivers alike in science and in compassion will once more bring forth a helmsman who will lead it gloriously through new times in the light of the new science and the old love. It would be infidelity to the principles of our great teacher Moses were we not now to put every modern method of work into operation in order to realise the ideal of "a sound mind in a sound body," and to provide for the welfare not of some favoured stratum, but of the community as such. I am also firmly convinced that even among those charitable institutions which, I will readily grant, are not to be ascribed to the want of a homeland of our own, there are many whose activity could be greatly restricted if the Jews once more became a people on their own soil, quite apart from the fact that a better organisation of social life would diminish them altogether. That many of these institutions have in part the same field of activity, that each encroaches upon the sphere of another, and that all meddle in one another's trade, is a fact which, although it is certainly true, I likewise do not wish to discuss further. It is their business to bring about their unity on all sides, in so far as this is practically possible, perhaps after the example lately given them by the Federation of Jewish-American charitable institutions.

Even if they hold themselves aloof from the Zionist movement, they may nevertheless learn this unity and concentration from it. It is characteristic of Judah that a catastrophe like that of Kishineff must first occur before its philanthropic corporations hit upon the idea of uniting their forces. Nay, even at the international conference on Kishineff lately convened at Berlin, where our Zionist Congress was paid the honour of a flattering imitation, and where representatives of the Jewish Coloniziation Association met with members of the Alliance Israelite, the Anglo-Jewish Association, the Israelitische Allianz of Vienna, as well as the relief societies of the German and Russian Jews, etc., etc., it was laid down in advance as a matter of principle that not a single one of the resolutions adopted by the conference should be binding upon the corporations there represented. We may regret this mutual distrust, as we deplore the petty jealousies between the various relief societies of the German Jews and the German branches of the Alliance; but far be it from us to deny the philanthropic value of the activity of all these institutions, even though they signify an economic waste.

In so far, however, as these institutions carry on an activity which would become unnecessary if we had a land of our own, but which, as things now stand, promises to last for ever, like pouring into a leaky cask, we have the right to demand that the solution of this problem be conceived on a higher plane, namely so that the hole in the cask is stopped. If, meanwhile, these bodies continue to tinker at this problem and to solve it again and again only provisionally, perpetually having to make good mistakes which they could have avoided once for all, we must nevertheless