Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · 29 January 1904
3printed page
scan 3 of 24

No. 5. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.

The Palestinian Crisis *).

The crisis in the Palestinian colonies, which it was believed had already been overcome, appears to be on the point of breaking out anew. An exchange of telegrams has taken place between the colonists and the Administration of the Ica, but neither the reasons nor the entreaties of the colonists make any impression in Paris, and the despairing people in the colonies are at a loss and do not know what to undertake in order to avert the danger that threatens them.

The cause of this sudden worsening of the situation of the Palestinian colonies is the resolution which the Ica has recently taken to press down still further the price of the grapes which it buys from the colonists.

In order to grasp the whole bearing of this resolution and the disastrous consequences it might draw after it, one must remember that most of the Palestinian colonies possess vine culture exclusively, and that the grapes furnish the colonist's sole income. Now this income was always slender, since the Ica has gradually pressed down the prices of the grapes so far that the colonist can scarcely live on the yield of his vintage. And only the owners of the large vineyards could do so; the smaller colonists were from the outset dependent upon an income which does not suffice for a year's provisions.

The Ica now justifies this disastrous resolution of theirs as follows: Palestinian wine does not yet bring in any profit; on the contrary, we lose on every hectolitre we sell. For this reason we cannot pay the same price for the grapes as in the previous year. In view of the larger vintage and the consequently larger loss which we shall have on the wine, we see ourselves compelled to press down the price of the grapes, so as not to exceed the sum which we have set aside in our budget for this purpose. The argument appears to be irrefutable. Indeed, once the wine is sold below its price, by what right do the colonists then demand of the Ica a higher price for the grapes than that which it offers? Even the present price is already below the market value of the goods offered. But let us consider the question more carefully. We know that all the wine produced in Palestine is sold, and at prices which are not at all bad when compared with the price of the grapes. We know, on the other hand, that the German colonies in Palestine, which sell their wine at the same price as the Ica, contrive not only not to lower the price but even to raise it.

And while the Ica will not pay 20 Frcs. for French grapes, the Germans at Sarona pay 30 Frcs. and still make a profit by it. How is this contradiction to be explained? If the wine once finds buyers, if the colonists earn no more on it than all other vine-growers in the corresponding countries, how has a deficit arisen in the coffers of the Ica? But one need only be informed of what goes on in Rischon and in Sichron to grasp the cause of these losses of the Ica. The price of the grapes plays a lesser part here. The gap in the budget, so hard to fill,


*) From the "Echo Sioniste," No. 1, 1904. Without wishing to pronounce a final judgment in this matter, we hope that the publication will suffice to induce the Ica to shed light upon this affair.

The Editors.

is, however, created by the costs arising from the making of the wine.

This making proceeds with such negligence and extravagance that, even if one were to pay for the grapes half their present price, a deficit would arise all the same. The wine-cellars are managed by a wholly incompetent and petty Administration. Every tool, every instrument however small, is procured from Paris or from other places. It is burdened with enormous freight charges, and moreover requires repairs after its arrival which come to more than the article itself. Would you have an example? Here is a very typical one: all the casks needed for the wine from the cellar at Rischon-le-Zion come from France and cost 30 Frcs. apiece, whereas the same cask, if made in the country, costs no more than 15 Frcs. Besides this, the casks arrive in a totally ruined condition, and they must be repaired. Now this year the cost of the casks rose, according to figures furnished by someone versed in the business of the cellar at Rischon le-Zion, to 84,000 Frcs., and the repairs cost 142,000 Frcs. These figures need no comment. The same phenomenon is met with everywhere. Everywhere such extravagance and slovenliness.

Of the Administration itself we would rather not speak. Composed of people who are wholly strangers to colonization, it is harmful by its very existence, since it brings no benefit and merely weighs heavily upon the budget, its staff exceeding tenfold what is really needed. Under such conditions it becomes comprehensible why the making of the wine is rendered so very dear. A vine-grower in France or in Algiers would not believe it if he were told that for the preparation of one hectolitre of wine in Samarine one must spend sixteen francs. This wine is then paid for at the price of 25 Frcs., and by every calculation the Administration, in order to bear no loss, ought to pay the colonist only 8 Frcs. for the grapes. Now the colonists in one colony in Judaea have tried to make their wine themselves. They likewise sell it at 23 Frcs., whereby there remains to them for the grapes not 8 Frcs. but more than twice as much.

Let us take another example. The price of a hectolitre of cognac with the Administration is 240 Frcs. The colonists of Chedera have manufactured their cognac themselves and now sell it at 140 Frcs., a price which is still very advantageous for them. The conclusion follows of itself: The colonists must make their wine themselves. Since the Ica has been active in Palestine, it has accomplished much good; it has certainly contributed much to the improvement of the situation of the colonies of Baron Rothschild. It grasped at once where the root of all the evils lies; it grasped that it is the Administration which, through its involved mechanism, its Chinese routine and its absolute ignorance of the colonist's true needs, makes the work of colonization impossible. Scarcely had the Administration been abolished, scarcely had the internal management of the colonies been handed over to the colonists themselves, when an improvement was felt at once, and the colonies began to develop freely and normally, without asking anything of the Ica, and have advanced by their own strength as the Administration never dreamed. May a reform like that in the internal management now be carried through in the making of the wine as well, which forms the colonists' sole means of existence. May the Ica, instead of the grapes, the already finished wine from them