Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 16
There is only one unity. That is unity in thoughts, ideas and principles. The bread question has nothing to do with it. The misfortune of the Jewish nation consists precisely in this bread question. But we cannot comprehend how, in the great Jewish problem, you can come forward with the Uganda question and believe that with this little nostrum you can solve the great economic misfortune. You come to the people, which is hungry and in want, with the word "goal." The people will always snatch at it, and it will not stop to think whether this bread really means help. We all appreciate the great proposal of the English Government, but this proposal is an enormous success for the Zionist movement only if it is declined — a misfortune if it is accepted. In Russia there are 5,000,000 Jews; the annual increase amounts to about 3 per cent., that is, some 150,000; 50,000 emigrate yearly, and to this people, which in spite of the enormous emigration cannot reduce its increase, one comes with the Uganda project. All proposals to divert the stream of emigrants are a policy of alms; as Dr. Herzl himself said at the Fifth Congress, the final goal of a movement must always be strictly bound up with the day-to-day movement, otherwise the final goal becomes a mummy. Our final goal is laid down in the Basle Programme. That we cannot change, for it has been made through the centuries. We therefore said at Charkow: we want clarity in the Uganda matter; we want to know whether Dr. Herzl is in earnest or not. With Uganda one arrives at nothing, and for the sake of this nothing our great cause is disturbed. If you wish to have peace, return to Zion.
Tuesday, the 12th of April, Fourth (Afternoon) Session.
The fourth session, too, was taken up with the debate on Dr. Herzl's statement.
Rabbi Rabinowitsch holds that the Congress may not occupy itself with the colonisation of Uganda. It may only give the initiative, otherwise I should certainly not have voted Yes. The expedition must of course be sent out, for it is a resolution of the Congress. Our work belongs, now as before, to Palestine alone. If we cannot obtain the Charter now, then we must colonise the Jews who are already there, there.
Adolf Stand: I have come from Galicia solely for the purpose of acting here as a mediator. But I conceive of mediation not as the settling of a personal question, but as the bringing about of a unity on the basis of the idea. I will therefore throw light on the main question, the Uganda question. I see here three alternatives, which may be put into the following formulas: Zion or Uganda; Uganda as a middle way to Zion; and Zion and Uganda. Whoever puts the question "Zion or Uganda" already stands outside our party and has ceased to be a Zionist. With him, therefore, we shall not speak here. Zion and Uganda: our people, which is scarcely in a position to solve the first question, is to solve two at once. We have neither the money nor the human material in such strong measure as to fulfil the second question. But if we have it, then all the more do we wish to solve the first. Until a resolution of the Congress binds me to be for Uganda, until that moment I shall fight, since I will not squander our precious money, will not sacrifice our human material, and may not give away the precious person of our leader for an alien cause. Uganda as a middle way. Wherefore the middle way? If Palestine is easy to attain today — good; if it is hard to attain, then an all the greater spurring of all existing forces is necessary so that it may come to pass. The middle way can only delay the final goal, indeed perhaps in time annul it. Should a resolution of the Congress in the Uganda sense come about, then as a disciplined soldier of the party I shall neither speak nor write for it — but I shall keep silent.
Dr. Tschlenow is glad of the explanations Dr. Friedemann has given in the name of the German Zionists, that they by no means stand on a philanthropic standpoint. The speaker confesses that he, too, was among those who had hitherto regarded Western Zionism from the philanthropic standpoint, and he is glad now to be persuaded otherwise and to find the Western Zionists on the same standpoint which we have always taken. If the matter stands so, then we must regard the Uganda question too from this standpoint alone. Apart from a few exceptions there is surely no one who would dare to say that instead of Palestine another land could be chosen for our final goal. But when it is asserted that besides Palestine another land might be brought in as well, I do not take the standpoint that every mention of a land other than Palestine must be regarded as treason, as Ussischkin, and before him Prof. Gottheil, have said. But if another land is now spoken of as a programme for the present, then we must ask ourselves whether we can really achieve anything in this respect. We have as yet made no experiments in the colonisation of virgin lands, but others, such as Carl Rathgen, who has treated English emigration policy in the nineteenth century, can instruct us on the point. And he proves this: all attempts at mass colonisation have failed for the English. Lord Kimber, the President of the Natal Land Company, worked out a project which was debated in the English Parliament and which fixed 3000 roubles as the minimum for the settlement of one family under large-scale colonisation. With our emigration from Russia, of 75,000 persons a year, what money would have to be spent to settle even a small part of them! Thus the Uganda question, as I said already at the Sixth Congress, is an illusion which cannot harm us. The people who now rave about Uganda will come back to us. Now, however, the resolution of the Congress is held up before us, which must unconditionally be carried out, and there I am not of the opinion of my colleague Ussischkin that there are also resolutions which are not obligatory for us. Therefore I say that, provided Zionist money is not touched, the expedition should be sent off.
Yet this illusion has already done us great harm in our agitation, since no one shows any real desire to pay the shekel or to buy shares; even for the National Fund there is no longer any proper collecting, since no one has certainty as to what is being done with the money. All our explanations are of no avail here, and therefore we wish to know precisely from the leadership what its attitude is to the Uganda question. And so I ask Doctor Herzl to declare to us: is he a Territorialist or a Zionist? It was to clear up this question that we sent our colleagues to Charkow. At Charkow we sought only to bring about peace. The same purpose lay in my circular too. If ever a man wrote anything with his heart's blood, I did so in the circular. I stand fully by every assertion. In conclusion, two words more. Doctor Jelsky has made us a fine speech about unity. I too am of the view that the greatest thing Zionism has created is unity. Only, if there is to be unity, there must also be a purpose that unites men. Therefore I say to you now, brothers, we stand before a great danger. If the ideal is broken, then there is no unity. That is why I have come, to tell you: the one thing that unites us is Zion! Let us guard that, and then we shall be united!
Greenberg: At Leeds I said nothing other than that, had our movement from the beginning been called a Jewish-national one, a good part of the misunderstandings would have remained outside our movement; and I declared there that a Jewish nationalism without Palestine is impossible. My whole speech at Leeds was necessary because Dr. Gaster and others too had come out vehemently against the resolutions of the Congress, and because I learned that extracts from their speeches had been handed to the Government in order to show that Dr. Herzl's influence was diminished and that the resolutions of the Congress were not recognised. It was therefore necessary to show at large meetings that Dr. Herzl was, now as before, our leader. The gentlemen in Russia, however, misunderstood my speech.
It was never intended to regard East Africa as the final goal of our work. East Africa is rather a springboard for carrying forward our work for Palestine. But if you, gentlemen, are not of this view and fear that the Jewish people might be turned away from Palestine, then it is your duty to remain in the movement as the old guard, in order to prevent a diversion. I will, however, put the following question to you: would it not be better that as many Jews as possible should go to East Africa, so that they may find themselves there in a settlement of Jewish character with Jewish autonomy, rather than that they should scatter themselves in the ghettos of America and the other parts of the world? It is as necessary for us to save the Jews for Palestine as to save Palestine for the Jews. Certain it is that an end would then be made of the dreadful wavering to and fro of the great mass of Jewish poverty and Jewish misery. If we could give the unhappy wanderers a quiet resting-place, the whole position of the Jews throughout the world would be raised as well, for the world would think us capable of being entrusted with the creation of a State in Palestine.
From the present confused situation there is only one way out, and that is to conclude a compromise. Let Dr. Herzl accept the offer of the English Government and bring it before the representatives of the other great Jewish bodies which stand outside the Zionist movement. Let these bodies, if the report of the expedition is a favourable one, carry out the colonisation in East Africa independently of the Zionist movement; but do not forget that it is the duty of the Zionist movement to uphold the principle of autonomy, for without