No. 19 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
The Aliens Bill in the English Parliament.
On Monday, the 25th of April, the second reading of the Aliens Bill took place in the House of Commons of the English Parliament. The debate turned not so much upon the Bill itself as upon an amendment moved by Sir Charles Dilke. As is known, the Bill aims at restricting the stream of immigration from Eastern Europe into England. The preventive measures are roughly as follows: every immigrant must produce a passport on his arrival. He must then prove that he is no "pauper" and that he will not become a charge upon public charity. When at last permission to land has been granted him, he is registered and placed under police supervision. Should any police officer state that the "alien" has availed himself of public relief, even if it were twelve months before, the latter is expelled from the country without further ado. Further, "prohibited areas" are to be introduced in London and the other great centres of England, that is, immigrants are to be forbidden to settle in this or that quarter of a town. That by aliens Jews are meant is openly admitted by all, despite the assurances of the former Lord Mayor, Sir Marcus Samuel, who at a Jewish meeting energetically denied the anti-Jewish character of the alien movement. That the matter stands otherwise, however, is proved both by the attitude of the press, especially of a certain section of it — for example the "Daily Graphic" — and similar newspapers, and above all by Monday's debate in the House of Commons. Sir Charles Dilke, as has been said, moved an amendment which runs as follows: "Whereas the House is of opinion that the evil arising from the ill-paid labour of aliens must be met by measures against the sweating system, it nevertheless desires, before assenting to the Aliens Bill, to assure itself that sufficient regard has been had in the proposed measure to maintain the principle of asylum for the victims of persecution."
In support of this amendment — which, as may readily be seen, is in itself already a criticism and a restriction of the Bill — the mover himself, Sir Dilke, spoke first. He subjected the Bill to a sharp but objective criticism; he spoke in figures, in statistical data, and overturned the whole edifice of the anti-alienists. He related the previous history of the Bill. It was properly a child of Socialism; it originated with the Socialists. But the Socialists disown it in its present form. The Conservatives, the antipodes of the Socialists, have adopted the Bill as their own. Now, however, the Commission for the study of the question has brought to light results that are positively astonishing. It has shown, namely, that the figures of Sir Akers-Douglas, the Home Secretary — who ought surely to be the most competent authority — are plucked out of the air. The Home Office has quite simply, if unwittingly, misled the House. Thus, for example, the official report stated that in the year 1901 the number of immigrants was 81,000, but in 1902 rose to 82,000, which fact was interpreted to mean that alien immigration is constantly growing. The truth, however, is that in the year 1901 9000 aliens came, and in 1902 about 8100. That is an inadmissible error of tenfold. Then the Home Office described as "destitute" all immigrants travelling third class, which is far from corresponding to reality. The enormous growth of traffic with Canada and America, brought about by the passage of aliens through England to those countries, the official report has left entirely out of account. And the number of emigrants thither is still growing. 387,000 persons embarked in English ports, particularly in Liverpool, for Canada in the year 1902. The rumour is spread everywhere that England has an enormous number of aliens. That is far from being the case. In comparison with other countries England has very few aliens.
In Germany the percentage of aliens is 1.38%; ten years ago it was 0.48%. In Belgium it is as high as 2.82% (formerly 2.6%). In France there are 3%, in Switzerland 9.5% aliens, in England only 0.69, as against 0.58% ten years ago. It is said that the Jewish alien immigrants undercut labour and promote the sweating system. But this can be counteracted by appropriate measures. And then, there are in truth so few alien workers here — some 25,000 tailors, 5000 carpenters — and against this trifling number special laws are to be enacted!
Experience has proved that the Jewish immigrant neither is nor remains a pauper. Even the poorest, who possesses nothing but his two hands and his brain, works his way up; a striking proof is the case of a Jewish immigrant who, having come as a pauper, became within a few years one of the largest clothing manufacturers, employing 3000 Christian workmen. And if the Bill is carried, will not England then have ceased to be an asylum for the persecuted? The speaker then recalled the debt which the English owe the Jews, the benefit the Jews have brought to England. Did not Disraeli say that the Jew had brought with him to England the spark of genius which the English so often lack?
The alien movement is an anti-Jewish movement, and it is a twofold violation of the principle of asylum and an exchange of that principle for the principle of hatred and intolerance.
Mr. Trevelyan, Mr. Asquith (a former Minister) and Mr. John Burns spoke against the Bill and for the Dilke amendment. They proved with figures and irrefutable evidence that the alien danger is vanishing, and that it is only exaggerated by demagogic politicians and agitators.
Two Jewish members also spoke for the amendment: Mr. B. L. Cohen and Mr. Stuart M. Samuel. The speech of the former was very colourless; Mr. Samuel, on the other hand, spoke very vigorously.
The chief pillars of the anti-alien movement, Mr. Evans-Gordon, Mr. Howard Vincent, the Home Secretary Mr. Akers-Douglas and others, defended the Bill and rejected the Dilke amendment. The arguments they advanced were nothing new. Despite the annihilating criticism to which the argumentative basis of their assertions had been subjected, they kept repeating the old tale that the aliens, the Jews, constitute a danger to the English people, and so forth.
After the debate the House proceeded to divide on the Dilke amendment, and it turned out that 241 had voted against it and 117 for it. The amendment is thus rejected, and the Bill passed on second reading. It is interesting that of the ten Jewish members three voted for it, two — Colonel Francis A. Lucas and Sir Harry Samuel (Unionists) — against it, while Messrs. B. L. Cohen, Captain J. M. Jessel, L. W. Rotschild, Sir Edward Sassoon and Louis Sinclair abstained. Spectator.