Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 34 · 19 August 1904
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 34 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

…to this measure: the Christian soldier has a priori an insuperable aversion to the Jew; the Christian soldier is not, indeed, a party-conscious "antisemite," but he cannot abide the Jew; he is so accustomed to look down with contempt upon the Jew that he can never bring himself to raise his eyes to a Jew of higher grade. — And the army administration submits to this popular instinct, which is like a law of nature, and does not even undertake to set the Jews upon the rung of non-commissioned officer.

Lieutenant-Colonel (retired) Karl v. Wartenberg is a well-informed professional writer, and we have no reason to doubt the correctness of his commentary. We owe to his sincerity a new and sad contribution to the chapter "Equality of Rights of the Jews." sch. l. h.


The Conference of the "Misrachi."

Concerning this conference we are written to as follows:

בע״ה. Pozsony (Pressburg), 1st Elul 5664. 12th August 1904.

The Jewry of Pressburg, apostrophised in the "Tel talpijoth" by the Rabbi of Waitzen and his associates, hereby raises an energetic

Protest

against the truly shameful and wholly unjustified hunt which a not inconsiderable number of Hungarian orthodox Rabbonim have set on foot against the holding of the Misrachi Day in Pressburg, in connection with the press campaign of the official organ of unbelief and assimilation, and in faithful obedience to its directions. Has it then come so far with orthodoxy in Hungary that its appointed representatives submit to the dictate of an "Egyenlőség"? The anti-Misrachi doings of the "Egyenlőség" might fairly have been ignored, by anyone acquainted with the tendencies and the fighting methods of this assimilationist paper, as something wholly natural and self-evident. But when orthodox Rabbis, of whom it must be presumed that they are conscious of the dignity and the duties of their position, set their names to a pamphlet which contains nothing but a flood of condemnations and insults, directed against a mighty spiritual current of the most genuine and truest Judaism, and against men who are guided by the sincere and unselfish endeavour to strengthen steadfastness of faith in Judaism and to renew the faded splendour of orthodoxy — then such a proceeding must drive the blush of shame into the face of every law-abiding Jew. It is truly not necessary on our part to defend the eminent men תלמידי חכמים וגדולי הדור who will assemble in our city on the 10th of Elul against the boundless attacks and groundless suspicions of the "Tel talpijoth"; but these men are our guests, and we cannot suffer that our guests, even before they have set foot upon the soil of our city, should be exposed to such aspersions, from whatever quarter they may come. Against this protest must be made all the more, since we know that these attacks have been called forth only by the circumstance — materially quite a secondary one — that the Misrachists have chosen orthodox Pressburg as the place of their first Congress.

It is not our purpose here to pass judgment upon the worth or worthlessness, the blessing or the dangers, of Zionist and Misrachist principles: on that every Jew may form his own judgment who compares, with an unprejudiced mind, the activity of the Misrachim hitherto and their call to Congress with the pronouncements of their opponents. The final verdict remains reserved to the Jewish future. But — so it must now be asked — how is it at all possible that orthodox Rabbis should make to a Jewish community the insulting demand that it close its gates against a considerable Jewish assembly which seeks its hospitality, and so put to shame before the public these men who hasten hither from far away? This demand we must reject with indignation, lest it be said of us in the world that we have disregarded the most elementary sense of decency, and grossly violated the duty of hospitality towards our brethren by turning them away from our gates. How could we so lower ourselves in the esteem of the world and of all Jewry? The political authority most readily permits the holding of this Congress, and we should be so spiteful as to thwart it?! How should we so far forget ourselves as publicly to put our brethren from abroad to shame in this manner, when according to the saying of our Sages even the public shaming of a single man is a crime worthy of death?

Verily, the Rabbis who give us this counsel in the "Tel talpijoth" are themselves ill counselled, and have evidently become the victims of a mystification. We know quite well that only a few inflammatory agitators are to blame for this Kol kore, and that the great majority of the Rabbis who signed were moved to give their signatures only by the boundless, intimidating agitation of those few. Both the Orthodox Executive Office in Pest and our highly revered Chief Rabbi of Pressburg שליט״א have for years maintained a benevolent neutrality towards Zionism, so that this sudden abrupt change of attitude would be incomprehensible, did we not also know, from complaints of several Rabbis which have reached us, that they were forcibly, under the high pressure of an unscrupulous agitation, positively compelled to take this position. For weeks the Chief Rabbi of Pressburg, who had originally honoured the cause of the Misrachists with his sympathy, resisted taking a stand against the Congress, since he did not wish to be charged with the inconsistency that he — who had expressly permitted the Talmud students to take part in the movement, he who for five years had shown a benevolent neutrality towards the stormy development of Zionism in Pressburg — should now suddenly take the opposite position. But the tale-bearers terrorised the venerable man, who was staying far from Pressburg at a health resort and was in need of rest, for weeks together in so boundless a manner, and slandered the Misrachists before him, until at last, though reluctantly, he did their will. And by such tale-bearing and almost forcible influence were most of the rabbinical signatures collected. For us, however, a declaration given under the constraint of agitational high pressure and on the ground of tendentious misrepresentations cannot be that unconditional word of authority which every wish of our revered Chief Rabbi has otherwise been, and always will be.

Thus has this Kol kore come into being, which will ever remain a black page in the history of Hungarian orthodoxy. Verily, the respect which every law-abiding Jew owes to the rabbinical dignity as such, without regard to those who bear it, forbids us to waste another word upon this document. It condemns itself, and, without being able in the least to shake the rock-firm Zionist conviction of the Misrachists of Hungary, it will harm only the authority of those Rabbis who have signed it. Let those, therefore, to whom the good name of our orthodoxy is still dear, possess, like us, the courage of their conviction, and pronounce their judgment upon this sad episode openly and frankly, so that the law-abiding Jewry of the world, whose eyes now rest upon us, may learn the true, unfalsified sentiment of the orthodox Jewry of Hungary.


"The Essence of Judaism."

Under this title there appeared in Number 38 of the Berlin periodical "Die Zukunft" an essay by a certain Dr. Elias Jakob, which, in the garb of impartial scholarship, contains the most violent and entirely argumentless attacks upon Judaism.

Dr. Jakob begins with the assurance that what he here sets down is "the result of decades of study, testing and struggle." Now that is nothing remarkable. For the Jew who thinks at all is compelled, as is no other member of a community, by the outside world itself to reflect continually upon his situation; quite apart from the fact that a bent for brooding, speculating, dissecting, turning things this way and that, has always been peculiar to the Jew — a bent which was further nourished and cultivated by centuries of Talmud study, and by the mind forced into idleness in the Ghetto.