Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 44 · 28 October 1904
4printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 44

How pitiful it looks, how grey, how tedious! Forty-five years have passed. In England and in America there are five million Jews—one million in England, four in America—the English and American Jews have united, and their head is the Chief Rabbi of London, who "is, however, American by birth". In Roumania it goes well with the Jews, since that country has been placed under tutelage and compelled by the signatory Powers of the Berlin Congress to emancipate the Jews. Poor Jews, who would lead an existence worthy of human beings in this fashion! Naturally the Zionist idea has failed, but in return the Alliance is in its fullest bloom. In order, however, not to rob the Zionists of everything, our seer of the future leaves them something, namely the colonies in Uganda, which he calls "Israelia", and—O merciful Heaven—the colonies in the Soudan, and two more in Tibet (!). In this last country the Jews even feel quite at home, because the Lamas are said to be descendants of the Ten Tribes. Naturally—who is not descended from these blessed Ten Tribes? "Ma d'rachmono owid l'taw owid", says the Talmud: what God did, He did for good. This dispersion of the Ten Tribes is truly a piece of good fortune. And if one day in East or West Africa we should come into contact with the negroes or similar peoples, it would not be difficult for us either, for these too are surely descended from the Ten Tribes; in case of need it can also be proved by a verse from the Bible. And to return to the dream of our worthy Jewish Philistine: the dominant of our life will then be religion. On the Sabbath the synagogues will be full. The leading Jewish men and women will be strictly orthodox—a side-thrust at the present Jewish notables—one flock and one shepherd. In Ireland the good Irish have come to see that there is no need to beat the Jews to death, and these live there as parasites in peace. In short—why go on painting this monotonous picture any further! An idyll, sheep and lion in one pasture. A paradise, Messianic times. And the Jews too have at last come to see that "they must be witnesses of the whole world, and may not shut themselves up in a small State in Western Asia".

I have dealt so fully with this utterance of a sated bourgeois, insignificant in every respect, because it appears to me a symptom, a characteristic of the Jewish petty-burgher spirit. Formerly these people did not get a hearing, formerly they did not dare to come forward, because the prestige of Zionism impressed them and held them under its spell. Territorialism has emboldened them. The step from East Africa to Lhassa is not a long one. And an "Israelia" instead of the proud, great, beautiful dream of Zion—a paltry Jewish colony, subject to another's rule, un-Jewish through and through—that is intelligible, comprehensible, accessible to the Philistines. And what do they care for the deeper questions, the higher needs of the spirit, the great struggle of the soul, the striving after knowledge, after self-knowledge, the whole tragedy of the modern Jew? What's Hecuba to them? They have no ideals in the present and none in the future. And their Utopia looks so dreary that, if one were to imagine for a single moment that it would actually come to pass, one would truly envy oneself for living in the present, in the time of great sufferings, but also of great dreams. It is a paradox, and I venture to utter it—better a life full of suffering with fair prospects, with a faith in the future, than the peaceful existence of a "witness among the nations". Judge or accused, hammer or anvil one must be—but no middle thing. We have been "witnesses" long enough; the time will come when we ourselves shall take a hand. And to take a hand is hard. I read in an Italian newspaper, "Il Momento", a letter from Leghorn. Italy is a free country, one of the most liberal in Europe. For the Jews a paradise. Now new elections are just being called in Italy. The Government party is agitating for its candidates, its opponents are fighting them. And in the "Momento" we read: "In Leghorn the Government will support the advocate David Cassuto against the retiring Republican Marzocchini. The Commendatore (corresponding roughly to the title of Hofrat) Cassuto is an Israelite and a Freemason, and is also a member of the Supreme Council of the 33... I certainly do not wish to indulge in Antisemitism, but... the candidature of Cassuto would be a mockery for the People's Party. Cassuto is, namely, little desired in Leghorn as representative, because he is a Jew. Leghorn has never felt too much sympathy for the Jews.. On the contrary!" These words of the Italian semi-clerical paper show us sufficiently what we have to expect if the clerical party in Italy were strengthened. And that is by no means out of the question. And even if not, the dilemma always remains the same. Either we remain Jews, real, culture-creating, self-sovereign Jews—and then the paths to development and to the unfolding of power in the Golus are closed to us; or we wish to count for something, we wish to live our lives to the full—and then we must give up Judaism, overcome it inwardly. Both together are not possible. And no amalgamation, no half-measures will help to solve this dilemma. Nor will Territorialism, which is so gladly accepted by all the assimilationists, contribute anything to the solution of the question. Where an ideal is lacking, where no aim in life is present, a future is impossible. I have come unawares to speak of Territorialism. It is a very important question, which in spite of the numerous discussions has not yet been treated exhaustively. But of that another time.

cor.

The Jewish Intellectual Proletariat in Austria.

I.

It is the old song of glittering misery, which hides itself bashfully behind alluring diplomas and deceptive titles. The sad chapter of the over-production of the academically educated, of their social declassing and hybrid position, is by no means peculiar to the Jewish intelligentsia in particular. The "reserve army" of a surplus intellectual proletariat belongs to the social phenomena of the modern capitalist-militarist epoch of domination, and grows of necessity out of the glaring disproportion between opportunities of earning and the number*) of students, between the possibility of income and the standard of living. While the Continental States, thanks to their military organisation and burdens, form the richest soil for the thriving and alarming growth of an intellectual proletariat, England and America, in consequence of their enormous industrial development and because their military system the steadily increasing multiplication of such


*) At this year's inauguration of the Rector at the University of Vienna, the retiring Rector also spoke of the attendance figures of this University. His noteworthy remarks, according to the summary given by the Viennese papers, run as follows: "If we look back upon the attendance figures, what strikes us above all is the very high attendance in the Faculties of Law and of Philosophy as against the low attendance in the Faculty of Medicine. Certainly the high number of students in the Faculties of Law and of Philosophy pointed to a false estimate of actual conditions. To speak first of the Faculty of Law, there had for a long time already been a surplus of men in the professions to which it opens the way. A position, or even rapid advancement