Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 49 · 2 December 1904
12printed page
scan 12 of 20

Page 12. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 49.

(continued from page 11)

…to its ancient God and the ancient customs is contained; further, the "Triumphal Song of the Jews after the Destruction of Babylon," filled with a deep love of home, and the ballad "Samson," which depicts a night of love of the hero in Gaza in glowing colours of a truly Oriental cast, and then the downfall of Samson after Delilah's betrayal, the poet making the impulse to the dying hero's last deed of vengeance proceed from the Philistine daughter of Gaza. The close of this group was a mood-picture from the Jewish cult of the dead. Besides these, the ballad "Ziska," the "Dialogue of Three," "Old Landsknechts in Heaven" and some lyrical pieces by Münchhausen were recited, among them the one about the "Souvenirs" and "Land of One's Own," filled with the proud feeling of the landowner. This speaker, too, found a grateful audience.

Jewish National Fund.

The Golden Book.

"Bnei Zion" and "Bnoth Zion" in Schaki, for the inscription of the late Dr. HerzlKronen 479.18
M. Z. Ippo in Tichwin, for the second inscription of the "Schiwas Zion" Society" 252.—
Bristol Zionist Association "The late Dr. Herzl"Pfd. St. 10.—
"The Zionist Concil of Cleveland, Ohio," inscribes Dr. Harrys, Friedenwald, President, Federation of American Zionists, dollars50.—
"Leman Zion Association," Randfontein, inscribes Dr. HerzlPfd. St. 10.—
Messrs. D. Schereschewsky, Dr. Isidor Eliaschoff, Max Soloweitschik, for the inscription of "Sonia bas Aba Soloweitschik and Mr. Sulim ben Issabea Wolff" on the occasion of their wedding on 23 Cheshvan 5665Kronen 504.—
"Agudas Zion" in St. Gorodeja" 252.—
"Agudas Hazionim" in Demjewka" 240.—
"Agudas Zionis" in Kaniew" 240.—
"Agudas Zionis" in Ostrog" 240.—
From Mr. J. Hofmann in Radomysl, for the inscription of Dr. Mandelstamm in memory of his jubilee" 240.—
"Bnei i Bnoth Zion" in Sudilkow" 240.—
Sch. Tartakowsky in Tscherkassy inscribes Dr. Benjamin Seff Herzl" 240.—
S. Kiselhof in Tschernigowka inscribes Doctor Benjamin Seff Herzl" 252.—
Through Mr. Mansohn in Berditschew, for the inscription of Nachman ben Josef Grobinker and his wife Nechuma bas Jacob on the occasion of the marriage of their daughter Sarah to Abr. Nichamki on 20 Tam. 5663" 252.—

Correction: In No. 37, instead of "German Zionist Society," it should correctly read "Danish Zionist Society inscribes Rabbi Dr. Goitein."


Feuilleton.

American Seminarists.

(Year Book of the Jewish Theological Seminary in Cincinnati, published by the students of that institution. 1904.)

A stately volume of 480 pages, not counting the advertisements at the end, in which a Mr. Krell recommends his pianos, Mr. Kohut his girls' school, Mr. Hannaford his architecture, Mr. Arenburg his jewels, Mr. Rouda his clothes. Twenty-five essays from every field of Jewish learning — theory and practice equally represented; minutes of the general meeting of the Seminarists' Society; and finally the well-executed portraits of the professors — my fellow-student Gotthard Deutsch stands at their head, which fills me with joy and pride — and of the seminarists graduated this year, whose course of study is also briefly given.

What enviable people they are, these seminarists of Cincinnati! In the first place, they are fought over; the American congregations evidently cannot await the day of their graduation! The very first portrait shows us a mere stripling; he was born in the year 1882, is thus all of 22 years old — I am not mistaken in my subtraction, am I? — and this year became rabbi in Wayne. Another gentleman, by name Mendel Silber, whose cradle stood in Lithuania, does not look a day older; well, he too was born in 1882, and he too was this year called to a pulpit. The rest are grey-beards by comparison with these; the eldest is entering his 27th year!

Secondly: these Sunday's children have a public that takes an interest in the Seminary and the seminarists, in Judaism and all things Jewish. One sees this from the whole plan of the Year Book, from the essays, the get-up, even — no, above all from the announcements of the tailors and piano-makers. The book is evidently meant to be read by thousands; out of the motley medley of its text everyone is to be able to pick out what pleases him; quite on the principles of a more distinguished Review, but one nevertheless calculated for the uncontrollable needs and mixed tastes of a many-headed circle of readers. The round is opened by a seminarist — pardon! a rabbi of 22 — with a rather flat epigram; there follows a "Picture of Yiddish Sweat-Shop Life in New York" by Morris Rosenfeld (in Jargon). These are the light hors d'oeuvres, the ticklers of the palate; then come the heavy dishes. The Rector of the Seminary, the Rev. Dr. Kaufmann Kohler — to judge by his first name, formed more anglico, a thoroughbred American — thunders against blind veneration of the Talmud in general, rejects in particular the view that the Talmud is the beginning and end of Jewish theological study, and sets up a programme of his own in which — one marvels at the bold originality of this stormer of the heights — besides the Talmud, the Bible, grammar, history and even pedagogy are listed as subjects of instruction!! Never yet in the history of Judaism has anyone battered in open doors with greater force than the reverend Kaufmann Kohler, Rector of the Seminary in Cincinnati. And how gladly would we have heard something instructive from a competent quarter about the training of the American seminarist! What is demanded in America of the rabbi, of the preacher? Knowledge of the ritual is not the be-all and end-all of the modern Jewish pastor; we need no Rector to tell us that. But what, at its deepest core, is the justification for the existence of the present-day theologian in America? Is he there too on the point of sinking to a registrar and gravedigger? What relation exists between him and his congregation?

The editor of the Year Book, Ephraim Frisch, one of the grey-beards (25!) and not yet a permanently appointed rabbi, evidently felt the need of being instructed on these questions by others than Mr. Kohler, and asked that excellent man and distinguished scholar Claude Montefiore for some remarks on the Jewish pastor. Montefiore was just travelling up the Nile when he received the letter, but nevertheless, though only hesitantly, complied with the request. Well, from the mouth of so honest, experienced and thoughtful a man everything is acceptable, and so also the counsels, thrown off extempore, which the Year Book publishes.