Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 7 · 17 February 1905
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 7.

(continued from page 5)

…degree of self-denial and readiness for sacrifice are capable, which has been a revelation to the Jews. We must continue to lay this good foundation — we must likewise preach Jewish national feeling as a great, eternal principle. We may rely upon it that our best prospect of ultimate success lies in how many we can convert to the splendid ideal to which we have sworn fidelity.

But this is by no means to say that we should let opportunities which now offer themselves pass by; and precisely because I see in many circles, within and without the ranks of the Zionists, the inclination to let the opportunity pass which is offered us in East Africa, I must doubt whether we have set our ideals before the Jews in sufficient measure, or whether we ourselves are animated by them in any eminent degree.

Nor do I at all mean to say that we should not further our work in Palestine with restless zeal. I have seen with pleasure that our friends in Vilna resolved at a conference there to promote the formation of a special committee which is to betake itself to Palestine and there organise our people on national principles. If this work is in good hands and is carried out within certain limits, it seems to me precisely the work with which Zionists should concern themselves and which is likely to bear good fruit. This thought seems to me to have more of a future than the idea of acquiring interests in the land and other things while we as yet possess no political rights in the country.

I have long been of the opinion that, as regards Palestine, the Zionists should devote their strength to the settlement of a much larger Jewish population than is now resident there. It seems to me only fair that, whatever our moral and sentimental right to the land may be, we yet have no practical right to it so long as a pronounced majority of the population does not consist of Jews. And this brings me to say that the activity of the Zionists in Palestine should now turn to a thorough examination of the reasons which induce our people to choose other places for settlement and not Palestine. It would assuredly not be advisable to promote emigration to Palestine by almsgiving, even if this could be carried out. A settlement so formed would be of little use in the building up of a strong, self-reliant population. An emigration on grounds of sentiment alone would not be much more successful. The reason why our people do not now emigrate to Palestine lies in the customs and laws prevailing there which restrict liberty, which are sometimes, though in a covert manner, directed straight against the immigration of the Jews, and sometimes lay fetters upon our industry and our spirit of renown, under which they cannot possibly develop and thrive. The Zionists should, before they seek to effect any taking possession of land, but keeping such a thing always in view, exert themselves to carry through in Palestine all such reforms as will make it possible for all Jews who wish to do so to emigrate to Palestine, and will remove all hindrances to labour and trade. These reforms will not come soon. Egypt, after having been in fact governed by England for over twenty years, is still struggling with its Capitulations. But what has nevertheless been attained there through just government and freedom can, mutatis mutandis, be achieved in Palestine also. What has been done in the province of the Lebanon is perhaps a nearer example, but in view of these results a wise plan of reform for Palestine will perhaps find the approval of the Sultan and obtain the support of the Powers. It must be very much in the interest of the latter if the land which has the greatest attraction for the Jews is opened to them, should they wish to emigrate thither; the former would see no small advantage in bringing a great influx of prosperity to Palestine. For us the advantages of such reforms are too evident to be entered into more closely here.

I have here ventured to indicate four directions in which, in my humble opinion, the activity of the Zionists should extend in the immediate future:

  1. The securing of the offer of a large territory in East Africa for the Jewish people on the part of the British Government, if the report of the Commission justifies this.

  2. The propaganda of the national ideal as a cult among the Jews.

  3. The appointment of a committee in Palestine for the purpose of organising its Jewish inhabitants and of the propaganda of the national ideal among them.

  4. The promotion of reforms in Palestine which shall give the Jews every opportunity of settling there and carrying on industries.

This programme embraces things in comparison with which secondary matters, such as the manner of the leadership and the personnel of our movement, are of no significance. Nor do I mean to say that there are no other directions than those indicated in which the activity of the Zionists might extend with advantage. If we have a wise and logical programme, with the hearty goodwill of those who adhere to it, the rest is of comparatively small importance. I have said that it is not probable that we shall all be in agreement with every point of the programme that may be drawn up. But is it hopeless to believe that some among us will declare themselves in agreement with every point, and that we can all agree to place no obstacles in the way of those points with which we are not in agreement, even if we do not help to further them by word and deed?

I have felt myself moved to write this letter because I hope that it will contribute, if only in a small degree, to finding the right means of solving the East African question, of continuing our work in Palestine, and of making energetic propaganda for our ideals. As regards the East African plan, some Zionists are strongly prejudiced against it. The Zionists who are for it respect and esteem the objections of its opponents, although they do not share them; but they share their motives, even as they respect and esteem them. They believe that all those who oppose the East African plan take up this position only with the wish to bring about so much the more speedily the moment in which Israel will again be a people in Palestine. We who are for the plan ask of them only the same consideration. All talk to the effect that we are not such faithful Zionists, or that our Zionism does not bear the true stamp, is unworthy, or worse still, it is useless, for it leads to nothing. It will be a sad day for our movement when any section of us arises which styles itself "orthodox" and derides and mocks as "heterodox" those who do not agree with it in every particular. In our midst there is no